Recommended Posts

Posted

So I am thinking about what's the next hand tool I should get on my long list of stuff I want for the shop. I am a pragmatic woodworker and use both power and hand tools so usually I am using hand tools to clean up power tool failings, do things power tools can't do well or where it is just easier to do things by hand then setup a power tool.

For hand planes I have an old Stanley Bailey #3, a old Stanley Bedrock #5, an old Miller's Falls #4 (that I can't seem to get a nice shaving from so I don't use it much) and a new Stanley block plane. I am using the #5 to flatten and square and the #3 for smoothing for the most part. The block plane is almost exclusively for fitting doors and draw fronts.

I am doing a decent amount of M&T joints lately so I am thinking about a shoulder plane or a bullnose/chisel plane combo but the router planes look interesting too. Also I thought about a low angle block as well, something better quality then the stanley I am using now.

I thought about getting a #6 fore plane but I'm not sure how much use I'd get from it since at this point I'm not doing a lot of thicknessing with hand planes and the way I have been using the #5 and #3 seems to work pretty well. I'm not sure adding the #6 to the mix would be useful in my scenario or if one of the others makes more sense.

So basically, if I went for the #6, how would it fit in my arsenal? If I went for a more specialty plane, what have you found to be the most useful (Router plane, Shoulder plane, Bullnose/chisel plane combo)? Anyone use a low angle block? Does it seem like it would be more useful then the other planes mentioned?

I'd appreciate any feedback...

Thanks

-Jim

Posted

The longer I own my router plane the more uses I find for it,and the tighter my M&T joints have gotten, I really like that plane.

However if you are having more trouble with keeping your shoulders square and tight, than you are trimming down a tenon just a little (or cleaning up the bottom of a dado or rabbet) then a shoulder plane could be more useful. The shoulder plane can also make a quick substitute for a rabbet plane, not ideal in the long run but it will work.

I think the low angle block is probably more common than the standard angle, as many use it for end-grain, and it just fits in the hand nicer.

For me I use my number 5 with a cambered blade for fast stock removal, and then either replace it with a straight blade or go to a 7 for getting it nice and square (depends on the piece), for the joinery I find myself able to cut the shoulder pretty well, and can usually clean it up with a chisel if necessary (its typically not very deep so its easy to keep square), then using my router plane to true up the cheeks, I do own a shoulder plane but really only end up using it on large shoulders where paring becomes more difficult, or on joints that I cut really poorly. I have a 4 1/2 for my smoother.

I use the low angle block on almost every project, from shortening tenons just a touch, to chamfering all the edges, smoothing any endgrain that shows, and more.

I think your next plane should be which ever (shoulder, router, or low angle block) you see the most use for in your projects.

Posted

I also find the router plane to be very useful. I have used it for cleaning dadoes, fitting tenons and even cleaning rabbets.

That being said, for me the most used plane, other than those you already have, is my Stanley #7. I don't have a power jointer, so the #7 gets used a lot. If you have a power jointer, you might find the 7 less useful.

Posted

Router plane no contest. You can use this plane to refine just about any joint you make. If you don't do a lot or any milling by hand then all you need is a jack or a smoother in the way of bench planes. I would focus on joinery planes and the router plane is the utility joinery plane.

Posted

OK, so it seems the router plane should be the next tool. Now the tough questions:

Open or closed base?

Veritas or Lie-Neilsen? (I know it's the age old question :) )

How useful are different blades?

Thanks

-Jim

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.