Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

My take on Arts and Crafts -Do your worst

Featured Replies

I started woodworking in March of this year. Other than youtube videos and forums, I have no formal training. I will say I don't think I am a gifted woodworker, but I really enjoy it and am not a total hack. There are a lot of really knowledgeable and talented people here, so please - rip this apart. My goal isn't to get pats on the back, I want to get better.

Statistics

Materials - Ash (some curly, all harvested and milled locally), and walnut

Joinery - Mortise and tenon, breadboard ends (stopped grooves, slightly oversized with edges chamfered), v-grooves routed in verticals, legs are laminated 4/4 as I could not source enough 8/4 ash

Finish - 2 coats of danish oil to pop the grain - Rubbed. 5 coats of semi-gloss arm-r-seal sprayed (HVLP), top buffed out with furniture paste wax applied with #0000 steel wool.

Dimensions - 21" high. Top is 21" wide by 24" deep. Breadboard ends are 22" wide.

The bottom shelf is in sections to keep the piece as "light" looking as possible

This was a real challenge for me. A lot of mistakes were made and there was a lot of "firsts".

Things I like

The walnut accents. I think I did a good job of staying subtle but noticeable - and I think the lines flow nicely

The front aprons - This was cut from a really cool/curly board. They don't quite match the grain anywhere else, but I like them a lot

The finish. These pictures aren't great, but the finish is amazing and flawless. I am definitely spraying from now on

The points? on the bottom of the legs.

The Corbels! That was an afterthought and I am glad I did it

Things I don't like:

​The grain orientation on the top. Believe it or not, in the right configuration these flow really well together. I had to sacrifice design for dimensional stability. One of the really curly boards (on the left) wants to cup really bad. This is the 3rd or 4th glue up and the only one that stayed flat (even after staying clamped/cauled for a week)

I messed up on the bottom apron on one side. The "back" is showing. There is a small knot in the piece and it bugs me. Rookie mistake.

And here are the (crappy) pics

table4.jpg

table3.jpg

table1.jpg

table8.jpg

Far better than my first table, let me say. The piece bears witness to a tremendous investment of time and attention. Walnut and Ash make a great team and give the table a very appealing palette. That the lower shelf is a negative of the legs is interesting and I would have wanted to see that idea developed more. Fit and finish looks great and congratulations for improvising the corbels. The corbels could have been a little smaller: In your first shot, we see that they project beyond the breadboard end of the top, producing a small shelf. This interrupts what is an otherwise lovely sense of line.

You've correctly pointed out that the grain matching for the top could be better and I have every confidence that you'll be more picky with your boards next time. Where I'd like to see more effort on in your next piece is a sense of proportion, scale and overall harmony. Witness: the lower stretchers could be narrower, the foot chamfers are a bit overdone, the bead detail on the slats (aside from being a peculiar mixture of country farmhouse and arts & crafts) brings us further into tiny dimensions that are out of character with the rest of the piece. The negative space between the lower shelf boards is trapped in the no man's land between fully closed shelf and open grille work. All this falls under the umbrella of having an eye for design and will come naturally as you build and study more furniture.

As you were putting the finishing touches on this one, what did you find yourself wanting to build next?

  • Author

This is exactly the criticism I was looking for,

I forgot to mention the corbels! They were cut a tad large to account for the breadboard overhang - which is proud of the rest of the top by 1/2". if my spacing was correct, they would have fit. If you notice in the second pic, they are set too far back. Another rookie mistake. As I mentioned, I actually did a great job selecting the top, however it would NOT stay flat in the "correct" configuration. This now has a rather large lamp on it along with a few other decorative things, so it breaks up the grain a bit and it isn't quite as distracting. In hindsight, I had enough ash that was curly all the way through that i could have just ripped into 3/4" strips and made a sort of "butcher block" for the top; displaying the side grain. I have seen that done with highly figured cherry and maple and the results were visually pleasing to me.

The "shelf" on the bottom still needs to be functional, and I didn't want too much negative space. Our floors are natural oak and look a lot like the finish on this table. I thought too much visible floor and the shelf element would blend completely and be lost, save for the walnut. I did toy with the idea of perpendicular pieces (cut in sort of a style and rail) as well and thought that would look really nice (a sort of grille as you alluded to), but to be perfectly honest the joinery scared me and I was pleased enough with this look not to attempt something I wasn't comfortable I could pull off. I was doubting my ability to make all 4 corners COMPLETELY square, which to my surprise I actually did.

I never thought of narrower lower stretchers, I wanted to keep some symmetry between the top and bottom ones. In visualizing the piece now, I agree that would look a lot nicer. I also think the foot chamfers look nice. By overdone do you mean they start too high, too sharp of an angle, or a combination of both? This is something I made quite a few test cuts in scrap, and the magic number for me was about 32 degrees.

I like the V grooves in the slats. Agreed it is out of place for arts and crafts, but without them they look very bland. Since there is no walnut or any accents at all in the side of the table, I felt it necessary to put some kind of detail there to catch the eye in the otherwise plain grain of the Ash. They had to be shallow or the mortise would show.

My very next piece will be a coffee table in a similar style and similar materials, but minus the obvious mistakes. This is a step to my ultimate goal of building a true greene and greene style desk for my office, which I hope to attempt sometime in the next 12 months (but no sooner than the next 6 months).

I never thought of narrower lower stretchers, I wanted to keep some symmetry between the top and bottom ones.

In general things look good with side to side symmetry, and top to bottom asymmetry. Like the human body, or a perfectly shaped symmetrical tree. It's good to repeat design elements between the top and bottom so the piece has a sense of unity, but it's often better to change the size.

I got this DVD on Marc's recommendation, and I've been recommending it ever since.

  • Author

Thanks! I will have to look into that. One other thing I've found is woodworking is a lot more enjoyable to me if I can design and build. Following plans feels mechanical and takes a lot of the fun/challenge out for me. I'll look into that DVD.

I like the design a lot. I think the use of the walnut with the ash looks great. Im not a fan of the V-grooves in the slats. I prefer the staight up arts and crafts look. I think you did an amazing job. You should have seen my first table. Let's just say not nearly as impressive.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.