Recommended Posts

Posted

Here's my take on a G&G keepsake box for my Wife's Birthday (on Wed). We have a good indication that come Spring we're going to have another member to our family and I thought this would be kind of a cool way for her to keep all of the 'memories' for the pregnancy in one place.

I haven't decided on the hardware for mounting the lid nor have I given the final placement for the handle on the lid. In the pic it's shown forward of center but I'm actually leaning towards having it centered?

This was my first shot at at G&G style anything. Woods are Sapele and Ebony (all solid wood).. I still have a couple days to tweek things, so if there are any suggestions on the final design please let me know!

Thanks!

BTW, looking for some brutal honesty :)

~Andy

post-6031-0-05918000-1352170455_thumb.jp

post-6031-0-64220500-1352170475_thumb.jp

post-6031-0-29780000-1352170497_thumb.jp

post-6031-0-40737700-1352170519_thumb.jp

post-6031-0-94818900-1352170559_thumb.jp

post-6031-0-68129300-1352170587_thumb.jp

Posted

Okay, I'll take first crack at this.

I like it. It looks sturdy as all get out. I'd probably center the handle on the top.

My only issue with it is that in my opinion the walls look kinda thick for the G&G Finger joints. I might have planed them to about 5/8-3/4 the thickness of what ever their current dimensions are. That would have made the finger joints appear longer or taller and less square which is my preference, but certainly not a standard by any means.

The other thing I would have suggested is instead of putting the ebony plugs in the ends of the lid, I would have used an elongated ebony spline into the side of the breadboarded end.

Over all I think you did an incredible job. Especially for your first G&G project. I bet your wife loves it. I'm probably the only woodworker in America who's wife thinks Greene and Greene were a couple of raving loonatics. So, I only do G&G stuff for other people's households.

Posted

Thanks Chet :) My original plan was to have the ebony splines like you mentioned but after figuring the top I thought that the stock was a little thin to do. The box itself is 3/4" and the top is 1/2" with 3/4" breadboards. In all I made 3 different tops and settled with this one; still not sure if it is exactly what I'm looking for but of the other designs it seemed to look the most "right" :wacko: I had a hell of a time with the top. The box came together pretty quickly..

The fingers are (3) different thicknesses; 3/4", 1" and 1.5" for the middle...

I'm trying to type between times my wife walks into the room :wub: I'll try and add more specifics later tonight...

Posted

Looks like some superb craftsmanship. The exact proportions might be a bit off from the original Hall brothers work, but trust me it is far easier to see that it is a bit off than to figure out what would be just right when you are building it.

My first Greene and Greene styled cloud lifts were pretty awkward . I built 3 doors, used the best 2 for the project and kept the other as an example. 15 years later I can see where I could have done better.

Your wife should love it. It shows the kind of craftsmanship I can see in your projects.

I would vote for a centered handle.

Have you seen Darrel Peart's book about Design Elements of Greene and Greene? I wish I had it 15 years ago. My girlfriend recently got me a copy. Be glad to look something up for you if you have questions.

Steve

Posted

Darrel's website is furnituremaker.com if you want to look at examples for ideas. He is on the restoration board of directors for a Greene and Greene house, the man has skills and access to original work to learn from.

His book has some x rays of furniture to show how they made the joints , neat stuff!

Posted

Thanks for the replies guys! @Wdwerker I've become a regular visitor to Darrell's site over the past few months. His work is pretty much what hooked me on this style. I've been wanting to get his book for a while now (I keep hinting to my wife / family as gift suggestions) along with a few others but so far no takers; all I seem to get is clothes! I guarantee I'll get my hands on a copy very, very soon :) .

As I mentioned in my initial post this was my first attempt at this kind of design. This first box was somewhat of a trial run to try and figure out some of the quirks and processes. Didn't have a particular piece or design I was trying to replicate, just grabbed a piece of paper and pencil and started drawing. After I established the dimensions then looked at ways to try and work in as many of the traditional 'accents' as possible. A few of them made it, others unfortunately didn't. Really wanted to fit the spline in on the breadboards, but that was one of the aspects that got put on hold for the next piece..

A few more specifics; box O.D dimensions are 13" x 8" x 5" deep. The side handles add another 1.5" overall.. The lid is 8 3/4" x 15" including the 1/4"overhang of the breadboards. Ended up mounting the handle for the lid centered; really like it. Also added 4 small leftover ebony plugs on the bottom as feet to raise it up 1/4".. Finished it with a few light coats of clear satin lacquer..

Now I just need to decide if I want to actually hinge mount the lid or leave it as more of a lift off top which some simple cleats on the underside to center the lid when replaced.. If I hinge it my only concern is that my daughter will accidentally over-extend the lid and not only damage the lid but also the box. If I leave it as a lift off / removable top then the only thing that can be damaged is the lid (simple to replace).. Hmm.. Any thoughts?

Posted

Horton Brass has hinges with a 95 degree stop built into them for box lids. Most of the hinges I have seen on G&G furniture are dark bronze finished with ball tips.

Put the cleats on for now, give it to her tomorrow, add the hinges when they come in.

Beautiful box!

Posted

Thanks for the heads up on the hinges! Ordered 2 pair of dark antique box hinges (always nice to have an extra set for the next project). I don't think those particular ones have a stop built in, but if they can rotate all the way back then my daughter can't snap them off!

Decided not to add any cleats before I give it to her. As a last minute thought going to try and incorporate a shallow 3 picture display on the underside of the lid (3x5 pics). This would also act as a shallow cleat of sorts but don't want to do anything more until I have the hinges installed :)

Posted

I'd have to agree with Chet on just about every point.

Incredibly well executed, fine craftsmanship, excellent selection of materials, precise jointery and it has G&G written all over it.

As has been stated, I think I'd have planed down the thickness of the primary box to about 3/4 of what you have there, it seems a tad heavy.

Otherwise. Excellent job.

Posted

Thanks for the feedback! I agree with all the points that have been brought up. For the next attempt what would you guys (and gals) think of these dimensions:

- make the box sides 5/8" (I had mentioned earlier that they are currently 3/4; but they are actually 7/8") Oops... Probably why it looks a little 'heavy' :unsure:

- Keep the finger sizes and spacing the same (3/4, 1", 1.5") the thinner walls for the box would make even the smallest fingers appear more rectangle than square.

- Overall footprint would remain roughly the same (length, width and height).

- Increase the thickness of the lid to 5/8" with breadboards closer to 3/4 (flush on the bottom with the slight bump on the top reveal?)

* I kind of like having a reveal on both the top and bottom but am thinking that if the breadboards were done to 7/8 it might look out of place?

** Because of the thicker top, work the curved ebony splines into the front and back of the lid rather than having the straight end splines as I did originally

This is very much a work in progress so I really appreciate any and all feedback! Once I have the hinges installed I'll post some finished pics of this first box..

Thanks again!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 62 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined