Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Antique Quarter Sawn Oak Flooring

Featured Replies

I have striped and sanded this flooring and tried to finish it but the color all bleached out when the installer used waterbased poly varnish. I really want this flooring to pop and look as beautiful as possible and what he did so far did not do it.

I have read about using dyes to get the color to really pop but not sure if I can still get this result now that there is a coat of finish on it. He only did one thin coat and it really raised the grain.

This flooring was salvaged from an old mansion and is supposed to be 100 ys old. I have gone through more trouble to get it strip it and install it than any sane person should, but at this point i owe it to the project to see it finished correctly so that the beauty of the wood can shine for another 100 yrs.

Any suggestions?

you can use dye or a lesser step is to use boiled linseed oil try it on a small area first to see what it does then you can go from there. i prefer a oil baised finish as it looks nicer then water bases.

  • Author

im afraid I'm not quite following you. There is already a thin coat of Benjamen moores water based stays clear poly on the flooring now which raised the grain considerably and also bleached out the stain I had applied.

At this point i am trying to figure out if I can still get a two tone color with the grains being dark and the top being that lovely honey tigar yellow of antique quarter sawn furniture. Should I try sanding it all back to raw wood or can I apply the dye and then sand?

I'm not sure what the boiled linseed oil would be for other then a top coat but I still would need a dye first right?

im not a finish expert by any stretch but the poly will have probably sealed the wood somewhat. and the stain and poly might have raised the grain when it got wet or if the temperature changed drasticly. plus if its realy 100 year old flooring then it was probably air dried and even more susectable to wood expanding due to temperature and moisture.

if you put one coat of poly on then some of it will have probably soaked into the wood. and if you do need to strip it down it wont take as long because its not as thick.

im not realy shure how the poly can have bleached the stain unless they didnt mix well together. my sugestion is depending on what other people tell you to do i would try it in small area first to see what the different stuff does that way its easy to sand off a few inches then it would be to sand off the entire floor. to put the linseed oil on you need to strip the wood down so it can soak in. not shure about the dye aspect and Boiled linseed oil. wait and see what more expierenced finishers give as advise.

I think if it were me (understanding what you're looking to achieve for an end result) I would try one of two things:

- Apply a water based stripper to try and pull as much of the original finish out of the grains. Use and clean the stripper per the directions, let that dry then give a heavy sanding :(. The fleck in the wood is what you're looking to accentuate but this is also the grain that has pulled the original finish in deeper than the lighter colored areas. If the original original finish (which will also act as a sealer) isn't completely removed I am afraid you may get blotching and un-even appearance when you re-coat everything. A stripper I've used with good success is called Aqua-Strip.

- If you have a planer available this will be the fastest and cleanest means to an end goal (you could probably fore-go the stripper all together). As a guess I would think that you'll need to remove roughly 1/32" or so.. If this is an option this is what I would recommend.

Once everything is cleaned up I'd start experimenting on small pieces with different stains and finishes. A good starting point for trying to pop the grain is Marc's video here. He's using maple but the same concept applies:

http://www.thewoodwhisperer.com/videos/pop-goes-the-maple/

Good luck!

I had a similar issue when re-finishing some older oak floors. I don't know when it becomes "antique", but for reference their floors were about 50 years old, and burried under carpet for at least 30 of those years. Just a word of warning for others thinking of a task like this.. this was one of those projects that seemed easy enough for a competant DIYer, but after words I swore I would hire a pro to handle any future wood floor restorations.

Ok, now to what I learned the hard way. Way back when the floors were installed they used oil based sealers that seeped way, way into the wood. So you may not be able to completely sand it away, at least not without taking some serious cuts into the wood. When we tried to stain the floor (they wanted a dark mahogany color on the Oak) the stain took in some spots and not in others because the oil had penetrated deeper. Back to the sander...

I then spoke to a friend who installs wood floors (not a refinisher) but he suggested that we try an oil based stain and sealer instead of water based. He mentioned that once there is oil in the wood it is very difficult to get a water based product to take evenly since the oil absorbs unevenly. Not wanting to sand the floors a third time, we went with an oil based stain and it covered much better. Still not perfect, but very very good. Long story short, I don't know if the second attempt was more successful because we took off more wood with the second sanding, or if it was because of the oil based product. My guess is that it was a little bit of both.

  • 4 weeks later...
  • Author

Well I decided to have the installer sand the water based poly off and as it had risen the grain quite a bit I believe most if not all came up. I then experimented many different ways to finish the flooring on scraps I had left over from the job.

I started with The wood whisperer Marc's grain popping technique which he shows on a little maple box but try as I might I just could not get a consistent coverage on a piece of 12" Oak scrap so I was very nervous to try it across a whole floor. I tried several colors but I also could not get a consistent grain color from one scrap piece to another. What I was looking for is to have the pores of the wood dark and the top of the wood a warm yellowish brown to give it a tiger look. Some of the pieces did this with the Antique Vintage Maple but others didn’t so I ordered some more transtint in the medium brown but still no consistency from one sample piece to another and all of it had lap marks that I couldn't seem to prevent.

Another test I tried was that from the Transtint's own website and after applying the Vintage maple/Dewaxed shellac I came back over it with GF Gel stain in walnut but the color grabbed so quickly it turned way to dark and although it did a good job of filling the pours, it also flooded the top grain and the end result was way too dark for what I was looking for. I even tried sanding it back but the gel stain only came off in some areas and not in others and the end result looked like almost blond in some areas and dark in others and really looked jacked up. Maybe I should have tried to sand it back farther I don't know.

Next I tried a mixture of boiled linseed oil and transtint but while it worked like a charm on my first sample it turned another one kind of a gray color and not at all what I was after. I tried mixing the 50/50 mineral spirits and denatured alcohol then adding the dye and then adding that to the BLO bot it separated and would not absorb right into the wood.

I tried straight Watco medium walnut but the color looked too flat and didn't have enough honey/amber to it.

Finally, after testing and testing, and retesting, I decided to try a blend of 50/50 Watco Medium Walnut/Golden Oak and because I didn't have enough of this for the whole project and I had bought a whole gallon of BLO I mixed the Watco 50/50 with a mixture of 35% BLO/40%MS/25%Spar Varnish. This allowed me to stretch the Watco out to complete the whole floor. I applied it with a brush and wiped off after about 30 min. It already looks 100% better than it did after the water based poly that the installer had used but I still want more depth and a two tone color.

I am now contemplating what step to take next. Should I give it one more coat of the Watco/oil mixture? Should I sand in-between using say 320 grit? Could I then retry the shellac/transtint on top of the oil and perhaps I will get more consistent results now that the wood has been sealed? I like the yellowish glow that Shellac has and I think it might be easier to control over the oil. If so how many days should I let it dry first? I live in the NW and this room is in my basement and the temp is only about 60 so that might delay things a bit.

I was thinking that at this point I could try to fill the grain with the walnut gel stain and perhaps it won't bit into the wood so much.

Once I get the color I am looking for I was planning on doing a top coat of Benjamin Moore's oil Poly as the installer left me a gallon. I really don't generally like the finish that comes from Poly but I’m thinking that on flooring I should use it for durability especially as this room is our wine, whiskey, and cigar bar so alcohol spills will happen I am sure.

I'm open to suggestions, ideas, or just comments

You obviously have a very specific look in mind, but I'd be remiss if I didn't at least throw out the suggestion of just letting the wood be the wood. Aside from fuming QSWO with ammonia, you can't really do much to improve such a species that is so aesthetically pleasing right off the tree. I find that the more complex your finish, the more ingredients you add, the more you take away from its natural beauty...that's just my opinion of course. Here's a close-up of a project I recently completed in QSWO. I just used a bare-bones oil-varnish mix (Arm-R-Seal satin), and I can't imagine a change I could have made to improve what nature already made perfect. Food for thought...

abhenxmas2012123.jpg

W, I think you are wise in going with a poly finish over the floors. If you read the lables on the water-based poly, all the ones I have read say that the product is not suitable for floor finishes. They wear too easily.

One question that came to mind was, How did you sand the floor (what machine did you use?)? I've found in the past that in order to take older finishes out of the equation, you normally need to use a floor sander for the job, not a belt sander and/or RO. This cuts deep enough to completely flatten the surface and remove any older finish residue. Starting with fresh wood always makes finishing easier.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.