Recommended Posts

Posted

My old crummp Stanley shoulder plane that I bought it on ebay, good condition back then means body and adjuster block stripped not to mention the sole was in VERY rough shape (wasn't the same plane in the pictures thars for sure), anyways it just isn't working on the hard maple for my Roubo I'm building so I am in the market for a new one.First thought was a Veritas medium, out of stock till March! Now it's between the Lie Lielsen and Woodriver, only problem is I havent heard any input from someone who bought a WR. Next is the size, my old Stanley is a medium but looks tinly compaired to the others. Chris Schwarz suggests a large is the one to get, I am just leary because it seems to me that with the shear size of the plane it would be akward to use on standatd size tennons and shoulders. Anyone else have the large that can chime in with thoughts? Really apreciate any thoughts.

Nate

Posted

I've got all the LN shoulder planes... On 3/4" joinery, I would break-down my usage as: 70% large, 30% medium, 0% small. I think the issue is one of 'mass'... It's probably why, despite the 44lbs, my 'go to' router seems to be the FT2200 -- I mean, how often do I really need that much power? ... In both cases, the extra mass seems to add the 'authority' behind the cut... In the case of the shoulder plane, there is really not any more surface to register on 3/4" stock, but the large flat surface of the plane seems to help... On smaller tenons, the large plane is really too much, and I grab the medium plane. The small is really for boxes, etc.

Posted

I looked on Veritas site and searched through their dealer and even looked on eBay, no luck and March is too long to wait.

hhh, if you just had the large would you be able to use it for pretty much everything, I know I have tools that are comfort tools, could do without them but they make it a little easier. My Stanley does work ok, ok being the key word, on small stuff so I will be keeping it, besides I couldn't live with myself if I took someone's money for it! Thanks for all your help guys.

Posted

==> hhh, if you just had the large would you be able to use it for pretty much everything

small tenons in 3/4 stock would be a push w/ the large -- doable, but a bit of an effort. If you are using 3/4 stock with 'regular' tenon range, then the 'large' is the way to go (probably the basis of CS recommendation). If you work with 3/8 stock for decorative items, then the large would not be the way to go... If you work in a variety of stock sizes or do some smaller joinery and had to 'get only one', then i think it would have to be the medium.

Posted

hi folks,

i own the large veritas shoulder plane and it's a nice one..;-) not too long ago, i had to make the same decision as Nate.

primarely i looked at the pieces, that i preferably build and the ones to come in the future, therefore the medium seemed a little bit too small for most of my jobs, so i went and bought the large veritas.

the mass helps really well, pulling it through the cut, the larger surfaces register firmly against the workpiece and if there might be more delicate work to do in the future, i'll have the funds for the medium, the small shoulder plane isn't a thing, i'd give a tought about.

nor to say, that the veritas and lie-nielsen stuff is pretty pricey here in germany, but worth every penny!

that's it for now from the metric universe...;-)

Frank

Posted

Well after calling every every Veritas dealer I could find I struck out so onto Lie Nielsen. Well go figure they are sold out as well. I guess there has been an issue with their casting and it will be at least a couple weeks before they start looking at new orders. After calling all their dealers I did accidentally stumble upon a place in Oregon that has a LN medium, I took it as s sign, should be here on Friday! Thank you all very much for your input, I really appreciate it.

Nate

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.