Recommended Posts

Posted

I need a few dedicated saws (western style) but I am a bit confused. I definitely need a dovetail saw, probably about 20 tpi, as most of my dovetails are for 1/2 inch stock drawer sides. It looks like the veritas may fit the bill.

I also should have a crosscut saw. I am a bit concerned about the depth of the veritas one, however. It's only like 1.5 inches wide, so it would seriously limit the depth of cut. Is this a concern with a tool of this length and purpose?

Finally, I would like a dedicated tenon saw. It does not appear that veritas offers one. I was looking at the Lie Nielsen saw, but am unsure of what options to choose (other than rip grind). Can a carcase saw also be a tenon saw?

I have read this article, which was quite good:

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/article/Understanding_Western_Backsaws

Any advice?

Posted

Get the 15ppi dovetail saw.  It will probably be easier to learn with the 20ppi, but that's very fine.  You will very quickly come to appreciate the courser saw. 15ppi is still quite fine and there is a good reason that it has become the most common pitch for dovetail saws.   I wouldn't advise the crosscut dovetail saw... to small for a general purpose carcass saw.  You know they sell an 11" carcass saw with a 2 3/8 depth of cut? Get that one. Truth be told I actually like something bigger for a general purpose crosscut saw, but that one will work fine... it will be very much preferable to the little xcut dovetail saw.

 

Tenon saw.  This all has to do with the scale of your work. Yes you could use the rip version of the aforementioned LV carcass saw as a tenon saw for a whole lot of tenons, but anything wider than a couple inches max and you will want something larger.  Its inexpensive enough that it might be worth getting anyway, but if you only have one tenon saw you WILL want something larger.  14"-16" are IMHO the ideal sizes, I don't tend to do large scale work so I don't really have a strong preference for 14" vs 16".  For most medium scale furniture work the choice between 14 and 16 has more to do with feel and preference than it does with necessity of a certain size.   If you are going to get the LN get the 16" thin plate. Its a great saw (don't own but used at show).  Really any of the 14-16 rips on the market will work though.  

  • Like 1
Posted

Agree with Chris on the dovetail saw. The larger teeth will allow dovetailing a wider range of stock thicknesses. The 20 point saw is a very specialized saw for really thin stock. I've tried it and really don't like it for anything over about 1/2". The 15 point on the other hand will be great for thinner stock as well as thicker. LV uses a really relaxed rake on their dovetail saws, so even the 15 point will not be that aggressive or hard to start.

As for the crosscut and rip saws, I think the LV is too small, but that's just me. I'd look into something more like the Grammercy sash saw or a Bad Axe hybrid filed saw in about a 14" length. The sash saw is a nice size and I find I use mine for most tasks requiring a larger back saw. It's filed half way between rip and crosscut and does both tasks well, so I find I don't have to constantly switch saws when going from crosscut to rip. These days, I only pull out my deep 16" long rip filed tenon saw when I have wide, deep tenons to cut, like for a table apron or something like that. Smaller tenons like for door frames or drawer divider blades are easily done with the 14" sash saw. I like the look and feel of the Grammercy myself, but their tooth geometry is a little aggressive for crosscutting for my taste. I'm sure they could add a little more rake and fleam though if you asked them. Mark at Bad Axe will also file to your specs if you ask, though the rake and fleam he uses for his hybrid filing is about the same as I use on my personal sash saw and I like it. The other option is to find yourself a good old 14" Disston or Atkins or Spear & Jackson or any other number of good old saw brands and have it filed and tuned up for you. In the end it may not save you a lot of money to do so depending upon how much work the old saw needs, but it is another option and can save you some money if you find a good deal on an old saw that doesn't need a lot of work.

  • Like 1
Posted

Just to add... I agree with everything Bob elaborated on. I'm actually really only using two saws at my bench these days. A 10" 15ppi dovetail saw I made, and a 14" 12ppi sash saw I made filed mostly rip but with a bit of fleam to allow for crosscutting. It does both 95% as well as a pair of dedicated xcut and rip saws.  Bob's suggestion for a gramercy sash or Bad axe hybrid may be a really good option for you... you really don't need a saw with a lot of fleam (e.g. a dedicaed xcut) to get clean xcuts cuts in North American hardwoods. I'd like to make a big 16-18" tenon saw just for giggles, but truth be told I can't think of a time I've personally needed anyting larger than 14" (that will change if I build dining table or bedframe I suppose)

Posted

As pointed out, it all depends on your type of work. For backsaws I have 4 Bad Axe saws to cover all my bases at the moment. I have a 10" rip DT saw for 1/2" "ish" thick DT's, a 12" rip DT/Small Tenon saw I prefer for DT's in a little bit thicker material, a 14" dedicated x-cut, and a 16" filed hybrid. These saws are awesome, but no doubt spendy...

 

Now the LV saws are what I used before buying Bad Axe and they work very well and are also well priced, especially compared to anything else on the market at that caliber. If you pay attention to the multitude of forums out there, you may have seen that Rob Lee of LV announce they will be releasing a larger tenon saw in the relative near future, so that may be something you want to consider if you think the other LV offerings are a little too small for the work you do...

 

Here is a pic of the prototypes...

 

hbsaw.jpg

  • Like 1
Posted

As pointed out, it all depends on your type of work. For backsaws I have 4 Bad Axe saws to cover all my bases at the moment. I have a 10" rip DT saw for 1/2" "ish" thick DT's, a 12" rip DT/Small Tenon saw I prefer for DT's in a little bit thicker material, a 14" dedicated x-cut, and a 16" filed hybrid. These saws are awesome, but no doubt spendy...

 

Now the LV saws are what I used before buying Bad Axe and they work very well and are also well priced, especially compared to anything else on the market at that caliber. If you pay attention to the multitude of forums out there, you may have seen that Rob Lee of LV announce they will be releasing a larger tenon saw in the relative near future, so that may be something you want to consider if you think the other LV offerings are a little too small for the work you do...

 

Here is a pic of the prototypes...

 

hbsaw.jpg

 

Now those are some pretty saws , can't wait to try them .

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 52 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined