Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

What's up Wood! Where's the ClearVue?

Featured Replies

So I was very excited about the latest issue of Wood Magazine. Not only was there an article with Marc, but the Woodwhisperer is actually mentioned on the cover.

 

 

I was also jazzed because they were going to review full shop dust collection systems. Boy, was I disappointed. I guess it’s my own fault, because I assumed “Whole-shop dust collectors” meant cyclones. I was surprised and little disappointed to find that “Whole-shop dust collectors” meant either cyclones or large bag collectors.

 


However, I was even more disappointed to find out they did not include ClearVue in the test?!?!?!


 

Not mention they didn’t have the JDS, or the Shop Fox Cyclone, or even the new Delta. (Although there was a small article later in
the magazine mentioning the Delta.)

 

When I began my search for a “Whole Shop Dust Collection” System I started with ClearVue, Oneida, Penn State, JDS, Grizzly, Laguna, and Shop Fox, all 2-stage cyclones. I quickly narrowed it down to Grizzly, ClearVue, Penn State, and Oneida for a host of reasons, but mostly because I wanted something permanently mounted. From there the last two standing for me were ClearVue and Oneida. I agonized for several months over ClearVue vs Oneida. I flip-flopped several times. ClearVue or Oneida, ClearVue or Oneida,
ClearVue or Oneida. Each time I was convinced I had finally made my decision.

I hear ya..  I still can't make up my mind. I think I've flip-flopped half a dozen times over the past year.  I like the metal and overall design of the oneida, and although the customer service people are responsive and polite it kinda bothers me that they don't seem to do much in the way of "Good Will Promotion".  By that I mean getting involved with the online community and offer either discounts, promotions, contests, etc.. 

 

When it comes to the social aspect of advertising and pushing their brand it seems they come up a little short.  Clear Vue on the other hand seems to be very involved which makes them seem a little more "community Friendly". 

 

I don't know if that makes any sense, but when it comes to making big purchases like that I like to know that I'm supporting a company that supports us, as well as provides a top notch product. 

 

I'm still on the fence..  Overall I don't know that there is a whole lot of difference between the two (quality wise).  Each have their following and I am sure both work very well. 

 

 
 

  • Author


Agreed. I think that more often than not, the woodworkers I know come down to deciding between Oneida and ClearVue. Which is just one more reason I was really excited to see Wood Magazine do side by side unbiased testing.

 

I’m no conspiracy theorist but do you think that there’s any chance that because Oneida advertises in Wood magazine that they didn’t choose to put ClearVue in the race because it might be the biggest threat to the product developed by one of their sponsors?

 

I’m not saying that’s what happened. I wouldn't think that would matter, after all Laguna advertises in Wood and it got what I would consider a poor review, but I thought I’d ask the question.

It crossed my mind :) .  If it's the same review I'm thinking of, it didn't even seem that it was a "Like For Like" comparison.  There were bag and can style collectors up against cyclone units (kinda apples and oranges IMO). 

 

Like you say, I would like to see a head to head with one of the Pro series from oneida and CV's top dog.  I've had a hard time even finding any good vids on the oneida units that wasn't a "sales" type video made by them.  Something that I think would be very helpful to potential buyers would be to see a start to finish un-boxing, setup and operation of the pro unit, as that would be the one from oneida that I'd be interested in. 

 

There's quite a few more vids out on the CV units which always sways me back in their direction. 

I didnt bother to look at them to close since my unit is outside in the weather. I dont think any of them are really going to be a whole lot better than the other. It takes more cyclone to match a bag collector in tems of efficiency the little units we use are just average tiny cyclones that do an ok job in a home small shop. Down sizing them to fit our small shops really cut back on the overall efficiency. In the cyclone world little 3 and 5 hp cyclones are like comapring a match box car to a Mack truck. I really dont think any brand is going to be much better than the other.

I bought the pro1500 last year, and while I didn't do a video, the setup was really simple.  I was able to do it basically by myself (though I wouldn't recommend that route).  It came on i think 3 pallets, one for the motor, and the other two for the cyclone and ductwork.  The manual(which I think you can download) does a pretty good job on walking you through the setup, I think I only had one question which was specific to my installation and their tech guys were great at getting that answered on the phone.  I think I got the cyclone up in one day, then spent another day on the ductwork, which I did have them help me layout, and I am really happy with the layout I got.  All the pieces were packed well, and arrived safely.  I am really happy with the unit.  If you have any questions I can try to remember more specific details.

  • Author

I've heard that most people who've worked with either CV or Oneida have had really good experiences. That's just one more reason I would have liked to see a side by side, unbiased comparison of the two.

 

I'm just disappointed in Wood not including the CV in their test.

 

I find ParticleBoard's comments interesting. My 5HP CV cyclone sucks pretty hard... tee hee... Granted my shop is under 600 square feet.

I have had an Onieda for over 5 years. Works great. This past year I upgraded my lines from 4" pvc to 7" & 6" metal. I spoke with the folks @Onieda and they were great with helping me reconfigure the sizes to maximize the dust collection. What a difference! When I first purchased the system, I had a little trouble with the remote switch. They were all over it and replaced not only the little remote but the mag switch also. No fus and they followed up after the fact to make sure its was all working.

 

Its all about the ccm not the HP, although HP does play a part in it. Remember, not all companies measure the ccm the same.

I put in the clearview my self 2 years ago with 6" metal all the the big machines. Super job, only thing I am missing now is the full can alarm, so I check it each Saturday. The duct is not vacuum duct, it is HVAC from Lowes.

My old one would suck the fur off the cat.. The ClearVue just eats the cat whole. :-)

BRuce

I have had an Onieda for over 5 years. Works great. This past year I upgraded my lines from 4" pvc to 7" & 6" metal. I spoke with the folks @Onieda and they were great with helping me reconfigure the sizes to maximize the dust collection. What a difference! When I first purchased the system, I had a little trouble with the remote switch. They were all over it and replaced not only the little remote but the mag switch also. No fus and they followed up after the fact to make sure its was all working.

 

Its all about the ccm not the HP, although HP does play a part in it. Remember, not all companies measure the ccm the same.

Its CFM.

 

I find ParticleBoard's comments interesting. My 5HP CV cyclone sucks pretty hard... tee hee... Granted my shop is under 600 square feet.

Swap it out for a cheaper 5hp bag and it would suck the chrome on a trailer hitch. :) Just kidding. Bags are just more efficient by nature but cyclones are cleaner. Our downsized mini units suffer from the downsizing there is just no way around it.

  • Author

Swap it out for a cheaper 5hp bag and it would suck the chrome on a trailer hitch. :) Just kidding. Bags are just more efficient by nature but cyclones are cleaner. Our downsized mini units suffer from the downsizing there is just no way around it.

 

I ran with bag collectors for years, but the problem I always ran into was life span. It seemed they'd be great for a while and then they would just peter out. I know some of it was due to the single stage pulling chunks of stuff through the impeller and slowly killing it. I supposed I could have put a separator in front of the bag machine, but then if I'm going to do that, shouldn't I just get a cyclone and be done with it?

Swap it out for a cheaper 5hp bag and it would suck the chrome on a trailer hitch. :) Just kidding. Bags are just more efficient by nature but cyclones are cleaner. Our downsized mini units suffer from the downsizing there is just no way around it.

 

What is your definition of 'efficient' in this case?

I hate dust and the 3HP Oneida Dust Gorilla does a great job in my shop.  All my duct work runs in the crawl space and is sealed with mastic. The customer service I had was excellent and setup with 2 people was really straight forward and not all too strenuous.  That being said, I doubt there is a huge difference in collection quality between Clear Vue and Oneida.  I went with Oneida mostly because I liked it to be metal and the free duct design.

What is your definition of 'efficient' in this case?

Efficiency is just that its effiency. Efficiency can be measured as in this case. CFM by HP, CFM by KWH, CFM by dollars................. Effectivenness and efficiency are two different things. Effectiveness varies by model and features. In tems of efficiency and effectiveness our little systems no matter the style suffer. Cyclones are more effective at keeping the fines contained but suffer from efficiency. Reason being is their small size. No matter how big of a motor you put on the things they can only handle so much air before going backwards in effectiveness. For example a big cyclone may only use the same 5hp motor but is lots more efficient because of the fan design. Our little collectors cant use a efficient design due to overall size. We are stuck with radial fans that move less are and draw more power, big collectors use torid fans that move much more air with less effort. This is why big collectors seperate chip collection from dust collection. Chip collection is a job better suited for cyclones but for overall movement bag houses are added to the cylcone. Take that big systems cut them into two different types and miniaturize and you get what we call dust collectors.

Efficiency is just that its effiency. Efficiency can be measured as in this case. CFM by HP, CFM by KWH, CFM by dollars................. Effectivenness and efficiency are two different things. Effectiveness varies by model and features. In tems of efficiency and effectiveness our little systems no matter the style suffer. Cyclones are more effective at keeping the fines contained but suffer from efficiency. Reason being is their small size. No matter how big of a motor you put on the things they can only handle so much air before going backwards in effectiveness. For example a big cyclone may only use the same 5hp motor but is lots more efficient because of the fan design. Our little collectors cant use a efficient design due to overall size. We are stuck with radial fans that move less are and draw more power, big collectors use torid fans that move much more air with less effort. This is why big collectors seperate chip collection from dust collection. Chip collection is a job better suited for cyclones but for overall movement bag houses are added to the cylcone. Take that big systems cut them into two different types and miniaturize and you get what we call dust collectors.

 

It's air.

It's air.

Yup and without it you wouldnt have or even have a need for dust collect. Its a big differnece in air. a 5hp CV cyclone moves half the air of a 5hp griz bag.

Fair point.  I guess I was looking more at the aspect of 'how much dust does it remove from the air', which to be fair, is really more a measure of the filter than whether it's a cyclone or not..  To me, you can't get 'real' filtration without canisters, which you can have without a cyclone, as long as you don't mind cleaning your filters more often..

Fair point.  I guess I was looking more at the aspect of 'how much dust does it remove from the air', which to be fair, is really more a measure of the filter than whether it's a cyclone or not..  To me, you can't get 'real' filtration without canisters, which you can have without a cyclone, as long as you don't mind cleaning your filters more often..

I dont know I give all my fine dust to my neighbor. I never installed my filter since the cyclone is outside.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.