Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Butcher block Woes

Featured Replies

Ok, I have a client with an Old butcher block  40x 30 about 12' tall. It has been in the basement of their building for years and years. The problem I have is  it was laying on the dirt, so I has some surface rot which is no big deal because I have to cut it all down to make it all flat again. But the problem is the smell of what I believe to be fuel oil, I can only assume there was an oil burning furnace there at one time and someone sat a can or spilled some on this block. I've never  had this problem so I'm looking for any advice? We took the block is completely apart, but I'm not sure if I let it air out will that smell ever go away. Or anyone got any Ideas on how to get rid of the smell, or seal it in???.. doesnt look good to me, but thought I would ask you guys. thanks for your time and views.

post-13742-0-29578000-1364409930_thumb.j

Given the nature of wood and the extent of the exposure, I have to wonder if there is any realistic way to recover this beast.  I know shellac can be used to seal in odors, but I'm not sure that's the route you want to go for a cutting surface. 

 

If I were posed with this challenge, I think I would begin by simply milling the wood down and cleaning everything up. I think it's too early in the process to make a call on the odor and the extent of the rot. Need to peal a few layers away first. :)

 

After some milling, you might find the odor to be minimal or gone completely. Then again, it may still be so strong that you decide the thing isn't really recoverable for the sake of food prep. But be sure to post pictures of your progress. I'd love to see how this pans out.

If it has been down in the basement next to the oil burning furnace, I would be concerned about how much of that oil seeped into that wood.  Even if you are able to get the wood cleaned up to a point where it looks useable, I would be concerned about the chemicals that have been absorbed into the wood fibers over time.

Hi Kurt,

 

Unless there is some sentimental value to the block I think it might be time to say goodbye. I don't think old butchers blocks had any treatment on them and trying to seal nasties inside does not feel right. Not sure mineral oil is the best marinade out there :) . I hope I'm wrong and you can save it but if it was me I would be placing an order for some new Sycamore. 

Damn that is cool....before the milling can start...you need to clean that thing. How about hitting it with some bleach mixed in with water. I would say fuel-oil is gonna be a tough to remove.

 

-Ace-

  • Author

Thanks guys, kinda thought the same things. I have pulled apart every row, and gave them the "sniff" test. The smell is kinda Hit and Miss. I think I might just try to mill a few rows down and let it sit for a few months. It would be a shame to just toss this lumbering giant, I'm going to do all I can to try to breath life into it. They want it made into a Island for the kitchen, so I'm pretty sure they wont be cutting anything on it per say, just using it as a table more like it. I'll keep posting some photos as I take her apart, and the progress. thanks!

post-13742-0-40924700-1364414194_thumb.j

post-13742-0-87630500-1364414219_thumb.j

post-13742-0-20013200-1364414242_thumb.j

Are you sure this was a butcher block and not a wooden base block for something in the basement?  I'm not very familiar with butcher blocks having coming in a tongue and groove style...  Then again, I've never deliberately taken one apart, either.

 

I would see if you can get some information on typical fuel oil for the time that some could have been spilled on it.  Then, I would apply some of the approved solvent agent (as long as it's wood safe) to the pieces to remove any fuel oils... Or, check if naptha will work, and try to have the naptha pull the oil out.  Something like this, I would not make into a surface that someone would be tempted to eat directly off of... but I think it would be cool to see it turned into an island counter.  (or a backsplash, or a deck chair, or a pair of side tables, or sliced into layers and turned into the shelving of some open kitchen cabinets, or a coffee table, or an entertainment center...)

 

Then again, I'm not someone in the chemistry world...

Are you sure this was a butcher block and not a wooden base block for something in the basement?  I'm not very familiar with butcher blocks having coming in a tongue and groove style...  Then again, I've never deliberately taken one apart, either.

 

I would see if you can get some information on typical fuel oil for the time that some could have been spilled on it.  Then, I would apply some of the approved solvent agent (as long as it's wood safe) to the pieces to remove any fuel oils... Or, check if naptha will work, and try to have the naptha pull the oil out.  Something like this, I would not make into a surface that someone would be tempted to eat directly off of... but I think it would be cool to see it turned into an island counter.  (or a backsplash, or a deck chair, or a pair of side tables, or sliced into layers and turned into the shelving of some open kitchen cabinets, or a coffee table, or an entertainment center...)

 

Then again, I'm not someone in the chemistry world...

Good point, see if someone can find some animal DNA on it  :D. Seriously though I have also not seen a butchers block with t&g.  Any clues on what timber it is? 

My grandfather was a commercial butcher. I vaguely remember the huge butchers blocks having bolts sticking out the ends. They got scraped clean and drenched with scalding water at the end of every shift. So I would imagine they never dried out.

He loved to the tell the tale about the Rabbi blessing the kosher meat. On a regular week he would inspect every carcass and splash it with water, but when there was a football game that day he blessed it by the rail car load with a garden hose!

Thanks guys, kinda thought the same things. I have pulled apart every row, and gave them the "sniff" test. The smell is kinda Hit and Miss. I think I might just try to mill a few rows down and let it sit for a few months. It would be a shame to just toss this lumbering giant, I'm going to do all I can to try to breath life into it. They want it made into a Island for the kitchen, so I'm pretty sure they wont be cutting anything on it per say, just using it as a table more like it. I'll keep posting some photos as I take her apart, and the progress. thanks!

 

If you have the means, you might try a light solvent (like low odor mineral spirits to srat), a good soilid coating for a hour or so to let it break down whatever's in there, and then vacuum bag it for a day or two to draw out the volatiles. Lather, rinse, repeat four or five times if there's progress.

 

Worst case, I'd look into sealing the whole thing up with a marine barrier epoxy (i.e. water/vapor proof) such as West System 105+422, T-88, maybe something from 3M or Aeropoxy. That may be in your favor as a durable island finish.

  • Author

J HOP ~ Yep we are sure its an old butcher block, the store front was a butchershop long ago. Yep they want to make an Island out of it and I have forewarned them that I wouldnt eat off of it for sure. And we do think its just common fule oil from the furnace.

 

GS Haydon, we think it is Maple.

 

Wdwerker ~ I too was a "butcher" in my younger days, I had an uncle who ran the butcher shop in our little town, and at 14 he started training me. Thats how I'm positive it is an orgional Block. The first thing you learn, how to clean the Block, bleach and water, every night!.. using a giant wire brush. Man that was work.

 

Darth Rust ~ We will for sure be sealing it up tight, we will look into some of those Ideas you mentioned. thanks!

 

I'm just lettting it sit in the back of the shop for now in a 1000 peices, the smell has gotten better.

My family had a neighborhood grocery with a meat dept. and a large chopping block. I was able to get the block and stored it in the basement for decades. Stuff was put on it, spilled on it and it was generally abused. Once there was some motor oil spilled on it but many years later there was no trace of it any deeper than 1/8th of an inch when I finally got around to re-working it. Part of the reason it didn't go deeper is because the block was likely not cleaned thoroughly. The wood had a layer of what appeared to be fat stains from meats and there were two bowl sized gouged out areas where regular chopping took place over many years. It is very old but I don't know when it was made..it has a cast aluminum knife rack mounted on the side and big beefy, but short, legs on it. I took three inches off the top to get to clean and fresh end grain but even with that it was still at least six inches too short so that seems to indicate it was made back when folks were shorter. 

Looking at your pictures I see that the tounge and groove shape is identical to what I have, not cut as deep as typical T&G we see today. Yours is made of much larger pieces than mine, which is all end grain maple. While yours has two T&G's per board mine has only one. Most board are from about a 1x3 to about a 2x4 size with the outer boards being wider and consistent in size. This block is 4'x4' and was about 13-14" tall and with the legs is only about 26" tall. I tried to plane it down with a hand help electric planer with some success but couldn't get it anywhere near smooth. Then I tried using a 4x36 belt sander to smooth it out..but stopped trying after about 15 min. when I realized it would take till 2021 to sand that end grain maple. Finally, I built a jig for my router and used a 1 1/2" deep straight bit and took multiple passes to take off all that greasy grime and gouges. Surprizingly, the grime was only about 3/8" deep but the gouges required much removal of material. On my last pass the jig slipped and I dug a 1/2" deep trench before I realized it. That prompted me to build a better jig and take two final passes to smooth out the top. It is perfectly flat now and is still a work in progress. It will become the central piece of an island and will probably be mostly for looks eventhough it's sterilized and looks and smells like new end grain. I'm going to leave the outer surfaces rustic and let the caracter and many years of sevice show. I will eventually post pictures (when I learn how to do pictures on here).  

I think it's good you're going to pursue what it might turn out to be because it looks like a terrific piece full of potential and challenge. Good luck!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.