Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

I need a workbench and assembly table but only have room for one

Featured Replies

I don't have a lot of room in my shop. I do have enough room for a nice size workbench, or assembly table, but not both. I see most assembly tables are made from MDF due to the flatness. I was wondering if anyone here has made an assembly table that also doubles as a workbench with a vise and bench dogs and the whole nine yards.....I guess I want the best of both worlds, all in one. Plausible?

I don't have a lot of room in my shop. I do have enough room for a nice size workbench, or assembly table, but not both. I see most assembly tables are made from MDF due to the flatness. I was wondering if anyone here has made an assembly table that also doubles as a workbench with a vise and bench dogs and the whole nine yards.....I guess I want the best of both worlds, all in one. Plausible?

FWW had a shops issue a while back with this idea. It was a workbench with a front vise that did double duty, as it had a dog hole. The base was hardwood, and the top 3 layers of MDF stacked together.

http://www.finewoodworking.com/woodworking-plans/article/build-your-first-workbench.aspx

  • Author

I am sort of wondering if I can run hardwood Maybe 6-12" on the front, and one side. The rest made from MDF. The hardwood can then be use to attach the vise and house the dog holes? Or just make a pretty large wooden workbench and hope it stays flat enough to assemble things...

I am sort of wondering if I can run hardwood Maybe 6-12" on the front, and one side. The rest made from MDF. The hardwood can then be use to attach the vise and house the dog holes? Or just make a pretty large wooden workbench and hope it stays flat enough to assemble things...

The MDF top will hold dogs with no issues. The vise will certainly need hardwood. The top should have a hardwood edge for durability. The base cannot be MDF, as it does not have the structural integrity required.

I did the hardwood section next to MDF/Melamine thing on my bench.

 

http://krtwood.com/ww/bench.html

 

Honestly I wouldn't do it again, but I do like all the storage I have underneath.  The MDF section of the base has held up fine for 7 years.  Never felt the need to wrap wood around it either.   I use the cubbies for organizing sandpaper now mainly, but they can take hand planes on their sides too.  The main problem with it is I've moved the bench around to different places in the shop over the years and with it really being basically two cabinets together it isn't as flat as it used to be with the uneven concrete floor.  Just because MDF starts out flat doesn't mean it's going to stay flat if what it's attached to isn't flat.  With a more normal base you've got an easier time shimming to the floor.

 

If I had it to do over again I would probably just make the whole top out of 4 layers of plywood.  3/4" Baltic birch 5' square, rip it in half and glue it up.  It'll be flat enough.  At the time I had no way of dealing with full sheet goods so I built it around the 2'x4' quarter sheets you can get at HD.  The one row of dog holes honestly hardly ever gets used.  I wish I had two rows of dog holes going the short way in line with a front vise.  So if you build your bench so that you can only put dog holes in a certain spot you may find out later on that you want them somewhere else.

 

The other thing is that if you make the bench a comfortable height for hand planing, which it turns out I don't do very often, then it's too low for a lot of other things.  I ended up making a 6" tall miniature bench that I clamp to it.  I used a premade laminated maple slab from grizzly, it's maybe 16" by 24" or something like that.  I put 3 rows of dog holes in it and use the veritas wonder pups to clamp things for sanding and what not.  I was killing my back and the back of my neck leaning over too much with the 30" high bench.

I share your small shop issue mine is 15' X 9'.  For bigger glue ups, I bought a roll of brown paper (grocery bag consistency).  I lower my table saw blade, remove the blade guard, cover the top with paper (and blue tape) and use the perfectly flat surface for my glue ups. 

 

I find the table saw top is just about the right size for glue ups.  If you try to make your workbench an assembly table, you'll probably end up making a bench that is wider than it needs to be, which is going to slow you down doing what you do most of the workbench...work. 

Same problem here. I created a simple whitewood frame to go around my bench top and have a sheet of Masonite screwed down to that. I don't have a vise yet, but when I do, I can just open the vise, put the "cover" on it and then close the vise lightly to that if I want. (Gravity holds everything down fine without a vise). In fact, I keep the cover on it normally since the shop is in the garage and a nice big flat surface invites people to stack things on it.

  • Author

Krtwood. That is actually the exact idea I had, but didn't know how well it would work. 

Godet, I have been using my table saw. But the more I use hand tools for delicate work the more I realize I need something with a vise. 

 

I just need to find a way to have the best of both worlds. i don't need the assembly table to be PERFECTLY flat. Just big enough for glue ups.

Here's the system I mentioned that I did to solve the same problem. This is my basic 2x4 and laminated plywood bench without the assembly cover. (I'll be adding dog holes when I add a vise.) While this is a very basic bench, this idea would work for any kind of bench.

 

post-7964-0-86376100-1364767313_thumb.jp

 

For any assembly, glue up, or when my bench serves as a platform for a benchtop power tool, I put this cover on.

 

post-7964-0-18925100-1364767319_thumb.jp

 

It's just a home center 'whitewood' pine frame with a piece of masonite screwed to the top. Gravity holds it in place, and a new sheet of masonite is dirt cheap when this one is destroyed / too glue-drip covered / finish stained, etc.

post-7964-0-86376100-1364767313_thumb.jp

post-7964-0-18925100-1364767319_thumb.jp

  • Author

Bob, the more and more I think about it,the more I think a laminated plywood top would be best for me. If I can build a sturdy platform for the plywood to sit on and stay flat, I think that would work for me. Plus it would give me the strength for the vise and dog holes...

Bob, the more and more I think about it,the more I think a laminated plywood top would be best for me. If I can build a sturdy platform for the plywood to sit on and stay flat, I think that would work for me. Plus it would give me the strength for the vise and dog holes...

Here is a version of the FWW bench I posted the link to earlier. In have this bench in my basement, where I do hand tool work when I have to close the garage shop when it gets too cold.

I took this snap with my iPad, so forgive the poor quality. The base is maple, and the top is three layers if MDF with a maple banding, about 7/8 thick. The dog holes are about five inches apart, and the vise has a wooden dog instead of the brass dogs in the bench. This bench is solid, does not move at all (even on a concrete floor). Not including the vise, it cost about 200 dollars to build I would guess.

I left a few handplanes in the top to give a sense of scale. Joinery is half laps, glued, screwed, and then plugged with some walnut. The top is attached with a few angle irons that I had f,opting around the shop. I used some left over water based poly to finish the bench.

As you can see, I have one foot shimmed. The basement floor is unlevel, and I prob should have included adjustable feet.

post-6372-0-86615500-1364824259_thumb.jp

If I were forced to make this decision, I'd be building a traditional workbench with hardwood.  I'd much rather compromise on or do without the assembly table since you can do most of your assemblies on the bench.  What's more important to you?  A rock solid and versatile workbench that will last a lifetime, or the convenience of a large surface for assembling?   You should be keeping your bench flat anyway...at least "flat enough," which will be good enough for glue-ups as long as your joinery is cut right and everything is square.  For situations where you must have a dead flat surface, you always have your table saw.  I see an assembly table as a luxury, and the only benefit over using the bench, assuming you're not building the assembly table as a torsion box, is the size.  I use my TS outfeed table as an assembly table...it's not dead flat...just layers of ply...but I use it mostly for finishing and other odd jobs and do most of my glue-ups on my bench...with wax paper of course.

 

Just food for thought...how will you flatten a plywood or MDF surface if it does move?

I have to agree with Eric on the material for the bench top. My 2x4 and plywood bench has never been meant to be anything other than something to last me a year or two and then be handed down, which is why it's made from cheap materials. I built my first project on s 2x4 sheet of 3/4 MDF across two folding sawhorses, and it was a challenge. So I wanted something more substantial, but cheap and I had no tools with which to flatten even a laminated pine top.

 

My top is very flat. I took extra care in glue up and installing it, but Eric is right, it can't be flattened again if it moves. I fully intend to build a much more substantial bench in a couple years after we buy another house, and hand this one down.

 

I posted mine just to show how the 'cover' I created works. It would work for any type of bench and is something I'll do again when I build a 'real' bench.

  • Author

This is all great information! I guess I have a lot to think about! I have built a lot of things over the past 2 yrs since I started woodworking and decided its time that I need a place other than my table to do glue ups, and hand plane. I am finishing up a jewelry box here soon, and I think a workbench is next up

Two options for you.

 

One from Fine Wood Working: http://www.finewoodworking.com/woodworking-plans/article/rock-solid-plywood-bench.aspx

 

One from Woodwork (circa 1996): http://www.workbenchdesign.net/WeekendWorkbench_small.pdf

 

What I like about Mr. Caspar's design is the dog holes and end vice - a concept I'm exploring for my second (okay, third) bench.  (Second is being slapped together this weekend so I can get some quick projects done.)

Two options for you.

 

One from Fine Wood Working: http://www.finewoodworking.com/woodworking-plans/article/rock-solid-plywood-bench.aspx

 

One from Woodwork (circa 1996): http://www.workbenchdesign.net/WeekendWorkbench_small.pdf

 

What I like about Mr. Caspar's design is the dog holes and end vice - a concept I'm exploring for my second (okay, third) bench.  (Second is being slapped together this weekend so I can get some quick projects done.)

I really like that one from FWW. After covering up all the exposed plywood plys with solid wood, it would look REALLY nice. I bookmarked it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.