jmaichel Posted April 12, 2013 Report Posted April 12, 2013 I am going to get a cheap dust collector only have about $300 to spend and looking at this Grizzly DC, I know its probably grossly underpowered but its better than nothing. I looked at this DC but I am worried it overload my 20 amp breaker when I fire up my table saw or bandsaw. This is more a shorter term solution and eventually I when I settle down and get dedicated space I intend to run 220 cyclone. I just hate to spend more knowing that I am going to upgrade in the next 5 years or so and at that point I dedicate the 1 HP DC to a router table or miter saw. Any Suggestions or input? Quote
pghmyn Posted April 12, 2013 Report Posted April 12, 2013 Since it is shorter term, what do you think about the smaller wall mounted units? I am thinking about getting one of those, unless I can find a really good deal on a floor standing one. Quote
krtwood Posted April 12, 2013 Report Posted April 12, 2013 Do you have a good vacuum? Because I actually get better results on my band saw using my vacuum sucking just under the table than anything I've come up with using my DC. My table saw has a shroud around the blade with a 2-1/2" port so I use the vacuum there too. Things like router tables and miter saws and portable sanders want a vacuum instead of a DC. A DC doesn't like being restricted that much whereas a vacuum can deal with it. So my point being you should have a good vacuum solution and a good DC solution eventually, so you might just skip the DC for now and only use a vacuum. Get the DC later when you can do it right the first time. A Fein Tubro II is $300 but I would recommend putting a dust deputy cyclone separator in front of it. I even got away with using my Turbo II and cyclone on a shop built drum sander for a while, which is something you wouldn't think a vacuum could do at all. Quote
Bobby Posted April 12, 2013 Report Posted April 12, 2013 I worry about the 30 micron filtration on the cheaper model. The fine dust is the most difficult for your body to filter out...much more important than just a clean shop. If you use a shop vacuum, make good shields really close to the source of dust. Suction power to pick up fine dust drops rapidly with distance away from the hose end or tool hood opening. So with the low CFM of a shop vacuum you need to close that distance. 1 Quote
tim0625 Posted April 12, 2013 Report Posted April 12, 2013 I have the same collector upstairs and it is hooked into 4"pvc with plastic blast gates at each machine. It does ok...not stellar but ok. I don't notice a lot of fine dust upstairs but I'm sure a filter would help. James, I think you can spent the same money on Craigs List and get one more powerful. You know how collectors are, most are barely used. Quote
jmaichel Posted April 12, 2013 Author Report Posted April 12, 2013 Thanks for all the feedback. My current setup is a Rockler Dust Right connected to a shop vac. I would get the more powerful unit but am worried that my 20amp breaker could not handle the startup load from my table saw and a higher amp DC. Quote
dwacker Posted April 12, 2013 Report Posted April 12, 2013 If your only running one tool at a time with a 4" or smaller port your only going to pull 450 cfm anyways. The bags are the issue. Beats nothing at all thats for sure. Quote
jmaichel Posted April 12, 2013 Author Report Posted April 12, 2013 If your only running one tool at a time with a 4" or smaller port your only going to pull 450 cfm anyways. The bags are the issue. Beats nothing at all thats for sure. Thanks Don, I was hoping you would chime in. All the ports are 4" or smaller and only running one tool at a time. Quote
dwacker Posted April 12, 2013 Report Posted April 12, 2013 Thanks Don, I was hoping you would chime in. All the ports are 4" or smaller and only running one tool at a time. Maybe just get one of those long collapsible hoses from rockler they shrink up pretty small and push the collector outside if your doing mdf. Also if its in your garage with a house entrance box fans blowing out help with the fine stuff you cant see. Quote
jmaichel Posted April 12, 2013 Author Report Posted April 12, 2013 Is that 1 HP DC going to be significantly better than a dust right vortex connected to a shopvac? Quote
dwacker Posted April 12, 2013 Report Posted April 12, 2013 Is that 1 HP DC going to be significantly better than a dust right vortex connected to a shopvac? More likely than not. I have a 6hp 12g shop vac and the specs on the lowes site says it only moves 200 cfm. Quote
rodger. Posted April 12, 2013 Report Posted April 12, 2013 Delta 50-760 is a well reviewed and cost efficient unit. Quote
tim0625 Posted April 13, 2013 Report Posted April 13, 2013 Is that 1 HP DC going to be significantly better than a dust right vortex connected to a shopvac? Definitely Quote
bglenden Posted April 13, 2013 Report Posted April 13, 2013 I'm amazed at how much better the $150 (with coupons) Harbor Freight dust collector was compared to my Ridgid shop vac, similarly connected to the dust right separator. (The shop vac was respectable for, e.g., the bandsaw, but just couldn't cope with jointer/planer.) My $0.02. Cheers, Brian Quote
Bobby Posted April 14, 2013 Report Posted April 14, 2013 Moving more air is better, all other things being equal. Typically shop vacs move small amounts of air at higher static pressure, while dust collectors move larger amounts of air at less static pressure. That's why you want larger ductwork with the DC. More air=more fine dust collected at a greater distance. Also, flex hose has high static pressure per linear foot, so try to have as little as possible and you'll get more air at the tool. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.