WoodNoob Posted April 21, 2013 Report Posted April 21, 2013 Hi all, I was about ten seconds away from buying a de Walt random orbit sander today, but stopped myself, because I saw that the comparable Bosch model's motor went up to26,000 rpm as compared to 12,000 for the de Walt. Is the rpm difference noticeable? Is this something I should care about? I was going to go for the de Walt, because I hear good things about their build quality, and coincidentally I was returning my Bosch sliding compound mitre saw because I was unable to get the fence square, so I'm a bit wary of the quality of the green Bosch tools (as opposed to their blue pro line). What say you? The choice was between a de Walt, a Bosch and a Makita in my price range. Quote
TerryMcK Posted April 21, 2013 Report Posted April 21, 2013 It's probably irrelevant what the actual motor speed is as it is all geared down before it gets to the friction pad. The figure you should be looking at is strokes per minute and orbits per minute. On a 280W to 400W variable speed 5" ROS figures of 8000 - 24000 spm and 4.000 - 12.000 opm are the usual standards although different manufacturers vary outside this figures (6" ones are sometimes lower). The other thing you should look for is low vibration, Bosch blue professional range and Makita excel at this, as there is nothing worse than suffering from a hand-arm vibration syndrome (vibration white finger). Also low noise can be a purchasing decider - look for lower dB(A) levels in the spec. Best to try a few out in store as they are all around similar price points. Quote
WoodNoob Posted April 21, 2013 Author Report Posted April 21, 2013 Ah! Brain flash! I wad the de Walt said 7000 - 12,000 opm, but I thought it was just a typo and they meant rpm! That explains a lot more. I'll do some more research. Unfortunately I think the Bosch blues are out of my range. As are the festools otherwise I'd just got straight to that! Quote
wdwerker Posted April 21, 2013 Report Posted April 21, 2013 With a tool like a sander that gets hours and hours of use spending the $$ for a better one makes since. Sandpaper falls in this catagory as well. Cheap sandpaper that wears out fast is not a good value. After wearing out several blue Bosch sanders I stepped up to a Festool ETS 150 in my small custom cabinet shop. The blue Bosch is a pretty good tool but I would be cautious with the cheaper versions. My grandfather taught me to buy the best quality I could afford and then take good care of it. Cheap tools are no bargain unless it is for light occasional use. 1 Quote
Trip Posted April 21, 2013 Report Posted April 21, 2013 ==> Festool ETS 150 +1 -- my 'go-to' sander. I've got the /5 and /3. If you want to save a few $$, then look at the PC low-profile kit. Not in same league as FT or Mirka, but still good stuff. Quote
wdwerker Posted April 21, 2013 Report Posted April 21, 2013 Variable speed sander is useful when you are sanding veneered pieces, slow it down and use fine grits to avoid sanding through. Hook a vac to your sander to keep the dust under control, the bags and canisters don't do that good of a job in my opinion. Quote
WoodNoob Posted April 22, 2013 Author Report Posted April 22, 2013 Mmm, I'd love the festool, but at nearly four times the price of the de walt/bosch/makita - that's going to be a struggle to prioritise the budget towards that! I'm totally in the "get the best you can afford" camp, but at my level of hobbyist (where I've been making do with hand sanding and a 1/4 sheet Ryobi for ages) it may not be worth it now. Regarding the speeds - I think I was talking more about the orbits per minute and also the the stroke distance, rather than the variable speed. I don't really know what to look for there - the bigger the better? Or doesn't it make a lot of difference? Thanks for everyone's feedback. Quote
Eric. Posted April 22, 2013 Report Posted April 22, 2013 Sanding is the most miserable part of every project...any advantage I can get, I'll take, when it comes to sanding. The FT sanders are worth the extra money. Quote
Trip Posted April 22, 2013 Report Posted April 22, 2013 ==> Sanding is the most miserable part of every project...any advantage I can get, I'll take, when it comes to sanding. There really is a certain truth in that... When I used el-chepo sanders, my hands used to numb-up quite badly. When I finally got some decent FT and Mirka kit, my hands are fine even after quite a bit of sanding. Quote
dwacker Posted April 22, 2013 Report Posted April 22, 2013 Remember abrasives make a big difference. A good sander with junk abrasives make for a crappy sander. A good sander with good abrasives makes for a good sander. One thing festool has done right since day one. Quote
Trip Posted April 22, 2013 Report Posted April 22, 2013 ==> Remember abrasives make a big difference. good point. i use FT, Mirka and Klingspor. FT seems to be the best. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.