williaty Posted June 3, 2013 Report Posted June 3, 2013 Since I finally have space to set it up, I've taken my grandfather's table saw out of storage and I'm working on bringing it back into fighting trim. I noticed excessive vibration and the pulley was blurry the first time I turned the motor on. I removed the pulley and the key stock. With the pulley removed, the motor vibrated less but still shook more than I've ever felt an electric motor do before. The only other electric motors I have (that aren't integrated into the body of a tool) all run nearly perfectly still with just a faint feeling of rushing if you put your hand on it. This one shakes and sort of reminds me of a weed whacker engine. Does this mean the motor is faulty? If so, is this likely to be something that can be repaired or is it time to look for a new motor? Quote
mikem Posted June 3, 2013 Report Posted June 3, 2013 Sounds like a bearing in the motor is bad. It may be possible to replace the bearings, but you may also want to consider replacing the motor as well. Quote
jimmykx250 Posted June 3, 2013 Report Posted June 3, 2013 I agree w/ Mike. The motor may be toast. But if it is just bearings you could find someone to re-build it for you. Not sure how cost effective it would be vs buying a new one though. Quote
tim0625 Posted June 3, 2013 Report Posted June 3, 2013 Since the motor runs, the internals are ok. The bearings on the ends of the shaft are probably bad. I took a 2HP motor to the "motor shop" here in town. He replaced the bearings, cleaned up the inside, and painted the outside for $45. Runs like a new one. 1 Quote
Spencer_J Posted June 3, 2013 Report Posted June 3, 2013 Damn, timwood! You got a deal... Im about to pay $160 to have my 3hp unisaw motor cleaned and bearings replaced. Not even paint! Apparently the new bearings are top notch though. Ill post more info as the work gets done As of now my motor vibrates a bit more than my iphone just as a reference. But i get intermittent squeeks without the belts on. As i turn the shaft by hand there is a squeek every full rotation. Quote
jimmykx250 Posted June 3, 2013 Report Posted June 3, 2013 You can have the motor re-wound as well and it will be more efficient as well- but a new motor will cost you less. Tim wood I wish we had someone like that where i live. WE have Drisilker motors which is a quality company but very pricy. And by the way just because the motor runs doesnt mean its ok. IT should spin freely if not there are problems brewing. Quote
tim0625 Posted June 4, 2013 Report Posted June 4, 2013 You're right...a motor should spin freely and a noise like a squeak means friction and that usually means a dry bearing or something beginning to fail. If the shaft has some lateral moving in and out play, that's ok but up and down says the bearings are worn. When we get to testing it to see how good of a shape the windings are in or the stator or armature, we're above my pay grade. I just took mine to the shop and said "what kind of shape is the motor in? It seems to need bearings - please check out the innards and see if it's worth replacing". (he knows motor innards) He called and said the inside was ok - $45 - I said go for it! I'm an insurance guy - for a looooong time now. I'm pretty knowledgeable about what I do. I always try to find someone who is knowledgeable in their field and trust their judgement. Heck....would you like me to get the shipping address and the shop's info so you could UPS your motor here? Quote
Trip Posted June 4, 2013 Report Posted June 4, 2013 ==> Tim wood I wish we had someone like that where i live. +2... It's really too bad, I haven't seen anything like a 'handyman' shop in about fifteen years... I remember accompanying my dad to the local guy as a kid, but these guys just don't exist around here... It's too bad. I'd love to get my stuff fixed rather then buy-in-to the obsolescence/replace-it mentality... Unfortunately for motors, it's usually just cheaper to replace. But it also depends, if it's a top-shelf motor (Baldor, et al), then it may be cheaper to replace the bearings... You know, it's not really that hard to do -- the biggest pain is dismounting/remounting a heavy motor -- but cracking it and replacing bearings is usually not that big a deal... A bearing puller is also not too expensive. Quote
tim0625 Posted June 4, 2013 Report Posted June 4, 2013 $45 and UPS...the guy is available to all of you as well. As far as buying a new one....sometimes I have an extra $250 for a new one, and sometimes $45 works for me better. Quote
tim0625 Posted June 5, 2013 Report Posted June 5, 2013 Cancel that UPS offer....the guy knew motor innards. I haven't been to the motor shop since last summer. I went by yesterday morning and it was closed. That was curious. Went by again later in the afternoon and the guy's wife was there. Since last summer the guy came down with something and died! 55 yrs old. That's way too young. The place was almost empty as she was selling out. So Williaty....the moral is replace the bearings and kiss your loved ones. Tim out Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.