Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Spray finishing advice needed - drawers

Featured Replies

Guys,

I am building my all maple drawers for my new Greene & Greene kitchen. I am really new at spray finishing. I have an Earlex 5500. I was thinking of the spray sequence on my drawers. I'm not sure the right order but was thinking:

1. Round spray pattern to hit the inside corners.

2. Vertical fan pattern to hit the inside of the sides, front and back.

3. Vertical pattern to hit directly down on the drawer inside bottom.

4. Vertical pattern to hit the outside faces

I figured it would not be necessary to finish the bottom.

Finish is GF Endurovar

Slides are Blum soft close undermount.

Did I figure right on the spray sequence?

Pre finish is much easier. Otherwise dont over think it. I hang my drawers if for some reason prefinish isn't a good option. Spring balance makes hanging spray jobs easier.

Take a cardboard box about the size of your drawer. Cut the sides down to drawer size and leave the bottom in. Prrrrrrrrrrrrrrrractice.  :) :) :) :)

 

 

Start with the inside of the drawers and work your way out and do the exterior last. The overspray from the exterior will melt into the previously sprayed interior.

 

Its best to build your drawers whereby you can remove the drawer bottom and spray separately. This helps with bounce back! Turn you air pressure down helps, but ummm, its an Earlex.

 

-Ace-

I would use the horizontal pattern for the inside corners. I never use the round pattern except when spraying water (or thinners) through to clean the nozzle.

The sequence sounds ok other than the corners and on the Earlex have the intensity screw set around 1/8 to 1/4 open and it will be fine. Enduro Var is very forgiving just remember to use 320 or finer between coats and finish off with 1000 to 2000 or even 4000 (very light sanding).

I personally would finish the bottom as somebody in the future will examine it and say "Hey this maker has even taken the time to finish the bottom too - that is very classy"

There are no sequences to finishing inside boxes or drawers. The only steadfast rule is to control the bounce back by throwing out the rules. Spray at an angle forcing the bounce back to go one direction and move the gun in that direction. Its like a push in and scooping action with the gun always held at an angle. Think of your fan as a shovel head scooping the cloud of bounce off material from one side to the other. If you keep the gun angled properly you will see the cloud exit the box before the gun. This is how robotic sprayers work in large factory enviroments. Its not hard once you get the hang of it move fast and  you should have no overspray even with fast drying lacquers. 

 

My only concern would be with the lack of adjustment of the earlex but if you watch your viscosity you should get an even fan with the earlex.

+1 on prefinishing cabinet drawer stock....   Think of it as cabinet box stock, prefinished is awesome!    On furniture, I don't prefinish drawers, but I use a simple wipe of thin shellac, followed by a waxing, for those.  They aren't sprayed.

 

This is Don's 2nd recent mention of spring balances, and I really think I need to check some out...  :D

first choice is pre-finish (i do this when i can).  second choice is to build drawers with slide-in bottom (I do this when i can't pre-finish), spray carcass and add bottom later...  third is wipe-on shellac (i do this on restores when i can't remove bottom).

I would never make a bottom removable. Relieving the back is a no no in the cabinet industry unless your ikea. Dovetail all four sides with captured bottoms. Back pins are to close to bottom.

I would never make a bottom removable. Relieving the back is a no no in the cabinet industry unless your ikea. Dovetail all four sides with captured bottoms. Back pins are to close to bottom.

 

FYI:

Old antique drawers have been dovetailed and the bottoms are removable. Has stood the test of time, go look at how it’s done. Your drawer box is plenty strong even with the bottom pin cut.

 

Your always going to have overspray, I don't care how good your spray technique is. It's like saying your gonna cut wood and make no sawdust. Sequence is important or you will get dry spray.

 

-Ace-

 

==> I would never make a bottom removable. Relieving the back is a no no in the cabinet industry unless your ikea.

 

Ikea??

 

When I was starting-out in woodworking, I had daily access to well over a hundred pieces of museum-quality 18th and 19th century furniture.  I used to spend hours just studying individual pieces to see how they did it.  To this day, some of it still amazes me.  But one this was clear, they almost always dovetailed drawers with removable bottoms.  I could easily slide-in/out fully-laden drawers without binding, racking, etc.  Unlike Ikea, these folks knew quality and how to build-to-last.

 

 

==> Old antique drawers have been dovetailed and the bottoms are removable.

+1

==> I would never make a bottom removable. Relieving the back is a no no in the cabinet industry unless your ikea.

 

Ikea??

 

When I was starting-out in woodworking, I had daily access to well over a hundred pieces of museum-quality 18th and 19th century furniture.  I used to spend hours just studying individual pieces to see how they did it.  To this day, some of it still amazes me.  But one this was clear, they almost always dovetailed drawers with removable bottoms.  I could easily slide-in/out fully-laden drawers without binding, racking, etc.  Unlike Ikea, these folks knew quality and how to build-to-last.

 

 

==> Old antique drawers have been dovetailed and the bottoms are removable.

+1

I didn't mean to start a debate. It's a kitchen not a dresser. Kitchen drawers should not have removable bottoms. I've fixed way to many kitchen drawer over the years. Even elcheapo HD drawers are made fully captured.

FYI:

Old antique drawers have been dovetailed and the bottoms are removable. Has stood the test of time, go look at how it’s done. Your drawer box is plenty strong even with the bottom pin cut.

 

Your always going to have overspray, I don't care how good your spray technique is. It's like saying your gonna cut wood and make no sawdust. Sequence is important or you will get dry spray.

 

-Ace-

FYI:

Old antique drawers have been dovetailed and the bottoms are removable. Has stood the test of time, go look at how it’s done. Your drawer box is plenty strong even with the bottom pin cut.

 

Your always going to have overspray, I don't care how good your spray technique is. It's like saying your gonna cut wood and make no sawdust. Sequence is important or you will get dry spray.

 

-Ace-

NO you should not get over spray on the inside of your drawer if you do it right. Yes you get overspray in your shop but the drawer should be ready to load into the box for delivery with no sanding off overspray.

==> It's a kitchen not a dresser.

 

now that's an interesting observation -- do you think the reason is:

 

nature of the drawer contents/usage (size to contents size/weight ratio -- we always over-stuff our kitchen drawers),

quality of materials (kitchen drawer carcasses are typically not a decent secondary), 

usage style (we tend to abuse kitchen drawers more than dressers),

captured drawer bottoms lend themselves to modern mass-production, or simply that

mass-production has cheapened everything to the point that fully-captured drawer bottoms are now necessary to guarantee longevity?

 

or some combo of the above?

 

or do you think it's some other reason?

I also have repaired too many inserted bottoms that have not stood the test of time. If your piece will not see heavy use then I can go with Ace's recommendation, but I buy second hand well crafted furniture and have come to appreciate Don's recommendation. This repair for me (in well made boxes) is second only to incredibly poorly designed drawer guides or slides. I rarely find a captured bottom broken through. I would pursue the recommendations that allow you to have good success with finish on a captured bottom.

NO you should not get over spray on the inside of your drawer if you do it right. Yes you get overspray in your shop but the drawer should be ready to load into the box for delivery with no sanding off overspray.

 

Ok so no overspray...dryspray....then........... how do you go about spraying an entire drawer with a fixed bottom?

 

-Ace-

Trip H, you dress once or twice a day on average. In a heavily used kitchen, some drawers will be operated multiple times for multiple meals a day. Flatware is dense. I went through an entire rental property once repairing flatware drawers. The drawer backs were very thin at maybe 5/16". The drawer bottoms were pinned in but the pins blew out the bottom. The inertial force was too great as the drawer was slid closed and the flatware kept sliding. Some people even multiply the force because they hear the flatware tray sliding so they get a frictional drawer mat. This increases the inertial purchase on the drawer bottom. Again, there has to be a place for what Ace is saying because far too many carpenters recommend inserting bottoms, but I am not nearly as experienced as Don and already I am seeing trending that makes me wary.

==> I also have repaired too many inserted bottoms that have not stood the test of time.

 

on the repair jobs where drawers that have failed, are the pieces well-made or more run-of-the-mill?

 

I've seen old drawers fail but only in 'lower-grade' secondary furniture that finds it's way to a kids room, country house, etc.  I.e., before there was Ikea, there was 'Ikea-grade' furniture...

 

I've got a commission to re-furnish a country home replacing '20s and '30s 'Ikea-grade' pieces with bespoke. One thing I noted was that many of the pieces have drawer stability issues...  But the pieces were not of high quality to begin with...  So is it the nature of the drawer design itself or the execution that is causing the failure.

==> In a heavily used kitchen, some drawers will be operated multiple times for multiple meals a day. Flatware is dense.

 

so that's my points 1 and 2...

 

==> The drawer backs were very thin at maybe 5/16".

 

that's my point 3...

 

 

==>  In a heavily used kitchen, some drawers will be operated multiple times for multiple meals a day.

 

however, I've studied 18th c buffets and silver chests that were clearly used more then a dresser.  Not as heavily used as a modern kitchen drawer, but built out of good materials by someone who knew what they were doing...

==> It's a kitchen not a dresser.

 

now that's an interesting observation -- do you think the reason is:

 

nature of the drawer contents/usage (size to contents size/weight ratio -- we always over-stuff our kitchen drawers),

quality of materials (kitchen drawer carcasses are typically not a decent secondary), 

usage style (we tend to abuse kitchen drawers more than dressers),

captured drawer bottoms lend themselves to modern mass-production, or simply that

mass-production has cheapened everything to the point that fully-captured drawer bottoms are now necessary to guarantee longevity?

 

or some combo of the above?

 

or do you think it's some other reason?

I think its because people abuse kitchens and the drawers get more use. Nothing to do with production they are still assembled by hand in factory type shops. Mass production using cheaper materials has nothing to do with it 1/4" ply bottoms are 1/4" ply bottoms no matter who's who's shop they come from. Drawer boxes today are better than those of the past. In the 80's drawer bottom failures were the number one warranty failure for the industry. Today it's finish failure and door hinge failure, drawer box failures are a thing of the past with fully captured bottoms with dovetails or lock miters. Door hinge failure only make the list due to MDF doors being so heavy, with the new clip in hinges that is falling. Today finish failures are on top. That is due to inadequate finishing with WB finishes, the change over from solvent hurt the industry. That will go away one the shops learn a new product, we hope anyways.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.