Jasahan Posted August 8, 2013 Report Posted August 8, 2013 I'm planning way ahead for our shop upgrade. One of the ideas I had was switching to pneumatic sanders. I don't really know anything about them. Our shop is semi-commercial (part of a nonprofit that makes furniture, mostly word of mouth orders, but soon potentially very regular orders of tables and chairs). We haven't bought high end electric sanders (actually last ones we bought were the $12 ones from Harbor Freight; lasted a good while but shaped weird so weren't actual 1/4 sheet). Had a decent milwaukee donated but it's dying, and some Ryobis, but they are also not doing well.. Had several others burn out. So, what are everybody's thoughts on pneumatic sanders? Quote
Tpt life Posted August 8, 2013 Report Posted August 8, 2013 The good ones won't run on your standard job site compressors which typically supply around 5 cfm recycle rate. The higher end sanders call for around 6 and benefit from a large reserve volume. Carefully purchase with those specs in mind to match your sander with your compressor. They'll never heat in your hand but then you also have to plan for compressor noise. Many cabinet shops in the RV trade around here are still using 30 year old jitterbugs. Also be careful to choose the orbit you want because some manufacturers are vague about rotary vs random orbit. Quote
Boatworks Today Posted August 8, 2013 Report Posted August 8, 2013 All of the air sanders I have are ones designated for wet sanding (QuickCutSanders). The air consumption on them is at least 8cfm per sander.. If you ever plan on having more than one unit running at a time you will need some serious air; something along the lines of a rotary screw compressor. The compressor alone will probably be in the $2-$3k neighborhood (minimum).. For a smaller shop, my personal opinion would be to look at electric models, but good ones (Fein, Festool, etc) that are designed for "dustless sanding". Really there's no such thing, but they do a very good job keeping it under control. I have a 6" Fein hooked up to one of their vacs. I've had it for 10 years and sand everything from wood to fiberglass. Other than replacing the velcro pad it still runs like a champ! It's a very aggressive sander; maybe more-so than what I would like if I were strictly working with wood. If it weren't for working with fiberglass I think I would take a hard look at festool. Both units are pricey, but they last! Quote
Jasahan Posted August 8, 2013 Author Report Posted August 8, 2013 Thanks guys! I will definitely be looking for an electric option. We were planning on getting some air compression, but probably not along the lines mentioned. Just saw the festool was $325. Wow. But if it lasts forever, I guess that's good. Quote
Jasahan Posted August 8, 2013 Author Report Posted August 8, 2013 How's this look? Much cheaper. http://www.rockler.com/m/product.cfm?page=30394 Quote
dcustoms Posted August 8, 2013 Report Posted August 8, 2013 Plan on more like 12 to 14cfm for a dynabrade 5" RO sander. That translates to a 60+ gallon 2 stage min 5hp industrial compressor, also add in an air drier, and plan on listening to the compressor run all day while you are sanding. If you are looking for a really good sander that will be versitle and powerful enough to survive in a production setting look at the Mirka Ciros sander. Lighter and more powerful than a dynabrade and will last a long time. Just my experience... 1 Quote
dwacker Posted August 8, 2013 Report Posted August 8, 2013 I would stay away from air for sure. The cost are going to be prohibitive unless your cranking out some volume. I would not run air sanders on a piston compressor. Your looking at about 5K to get a decent rotary screw with a refrigerated dryer. I also would think about the more affordable sanders like the PC low profiles they do a fine job for alot less money than festool. The dust collection is just fine on the PC low profiles and for $100 they are hard to beat. Quote
pghmyn Posted August 8, 2013 Report Posted August 8, 2013 Unless you are looking to invest more into the Festool system, I would not choose their sander. I have the ETS150/5 and I love that thing because I also have the CT midi from Festool. It would probably work with another vacuum, but you really benefit from the variable controlled suction and HEPA filter on the Festool dust extractors. The Porter Cable models are really nice, and affordable. I used an older non-low profile version for a good while. I hooked up a regular shop vac to it and got pretty good results. No where near as much dust was captured as compared to my Festool, but it was a significant upgrade to just using one of those detachable bags. Quote
Trip Posted August 8, 2013 Report Posted August 8, 2013 I’ve owned several Dynabrade, several Mirka air, every Mirka CEROS, every FT, two PC low-profile as well as a half dozen other misc sanders over the past decade or two. To run an air sander properly requires about 8cfm dry & filtered air delivered at point of use. I think my filter stack and dryer was about $3K, compressor another $3K, after-cooler about $1K and piping about $1K… Now with that investment, I do a hell of a lot more then drive a sander or two---air tools are very useful to have around the place… That's not to say you HAVE to invest $5K to run an air sander -- you can run one with a smaller shop compressor -- but it's going to cycle constantly, output hot/wet air and you'll burn-out the compressor and rust-out the sander in no-time... But folks do get away with it --- typically to drive a small finishing sander for final 'finishing-the-finish' operations.... It works for that limited-scope application... With the improvements in electric sanders and the cost of shop air, why are air sanders still sold? The air sander’s speed, weight, compact size, power, smooth operation and reliability all exceed what is available in today’s electric sanders – full stop. Air sanders still rule the production environment. In both production and non-production shops, many folks ‘finish-the-finish’ using a schedule incorporating water and/or solvents as carriers or lubricants – air sanders are much safer around liquids. That’s why I (and many others) still have a few air sanders around the place… That being said, I’ve been moving away from air sanding over the past few years… With the availability of Abralon (et al) finishing pads and high-quality automotive glazes, the need for air sanders to finish-the-finish is rapidly declining... If you go electric, the closest in size, weight, power and smooth-operation are Mirka CEROS. At about $500/unit, they are prohibitive. One below that is the Festool ETS line with the 150/5 and /3 being most favored -- the 150/3 being quite a smooth operating finish sander. But again, these are about $350/unit. Both the Mirka and Festool have impressive dust collection (the FT is a bit better). In the $100 arena, the PC low-profile is the clear winner over the Bosch, Makita, etc offerings. Do the Mirka and Festool outperform the PC low-profile? -- You bet, but at 3 or 4x the price, they should… The PC low-profile is probably the ‘best-buy’ in ROS… Quote
Jasahan Posted August 9, 2013 Author Report Posted August 9, 2013 If you are looking for a really good sander that will be versitle and powerful enough to survive in a production setting look at the Mirka Ciros sander. Lighter and more powerful than a dynabrade and will last a long time. Just my experience... So I looked this up. When the picture came up, I thought, "Wow, that is the prettiest sander I've ever seen." Then the price showed up. Jeezy peezy. $500! I guess this shows my ignorance of tools. I thought it was crazy that there were $300 dollar sanders. Anyway, thanks all for the input. I appreciate it tons. I was sanding yesterday on our cheap sanders and the sandpaper kept slipping. So I hope eventually we can get some quality sanders. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.