Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Kind of a beginner question..

Featured Replies

I'm kind of a beginner, because I do it as a hobby really, and I don't really get to do it as much as I'd like to.  I live in CT, and my biggest issue, nearly every time is doing glue ups.  I use them for scroll saw projects.  I use mainly 3/8" thick and 1/4" thick for the projects.   I buy rough lumber, joint a face and edge.  I then resaw it on the bandsaw to 1/2" usually.  I then glue it.   The problem I'm having is nearly all the panels I glue, (most are about 9x8)  cup on me.  The shop is my garage which is under the bedrooms. I dont' have it air conditioned or anything like that. 

 

I usually work in maple, red oak, white oak, ash, and cherry.  The ash, and oak usually don't cause a problem.  It's the cherry and maple I have the most problem with, and the 2 I like to cut the most.

 

Any suggestions on how to keep the cup out, would be greatly appreciated.

 

Some little panels I made Friday, flat when I put them in the clamps, flat when they came out 20 hrs later, after 2 days, have about a 1/16" cup across them. 

 

Any help how to stop it would be great.  I usually make the panels out of 3" strips, to try and stop it, but it's not helping..

You could try selecting some quartersawn stock. Vertical grain or quarter-sawn boards have straight growth rings parallel to their edges. When changes in moisture content occur, these boards swell and shrink the least and do not tend to warp.

But it sounds as if you are getting uneven drying. When a not so dry board is laying overnight on a workbench. During the night the side facing the air is drying out and shrinking. The side facing the workbench is not drying. As a result the board might cup. Even after both sides of the board have dried out the board may not be completely flat and may need to be planed again.

In this case leave some on after resawing maybe 1/32 to 1/16 on each side and plane it the next day flipping it over each pass to equalize the new wood being exposed.

  • Author

When I take them out of the clamps, I don't lay them flat on the bench.  I lean up up on an angle against something, or leave them standing on edge, so they get good airflow, trying to avoid the uneven trying cup problem.. driving me nuts.  Wondering if it's also because of it being thinner stock?

Are you sure the wood is fully dried to start with?  Is the 'inside' of the cup the resawn face (IE the inside of the original plank)?  Do your offcuts cup the same way?  If so, I'd say the wood simply isn't completely dry yet..

 

Hope that makes sense.

I've found that sometimes when thin boards are leaned up against a wall at an angle they tend to cup (toward the sky).  This obviously makes sense due to gravity.  Could that be what's going on here?

I've found that laying it flat (but up off a surface) is a better way to store wood.  I just cut some very thick cardboard (from large boxes) into long, ~1/2 inch wide strips and lay them out on a surface and then place the board on top of that.

 

(But I have no idea if that's what's going on in your specific case)

 

Best,

EG 

  • Author

Where I get it from, it's supposed to be kiln dried.  The inside of the cup is usually the jointed face, not the resawn face.    I only resaw, because I hate to plane down to like 3/4" then plane it all again down to 3/8 or 1/4 inch.  Waste of wood if you ask me.  Some times I try to bookmatch them, so I joint a face and edge, then resaw then, then face joint the resaw side to get flat, and rejoint the edge again, which should give me alternating grain direction, and glue it.  This is how I have 4 panels that all cupped about 1/4".  the pic below, shows one of the panels, where I ripped the joint, face jointed it, edged it again, then glued it.  that is why you see the convex at the top of each board.

 

My off cuts are usually only about a 3/4" piece, because I try to use the whole board in a glue up by ripping it into smaller strips.  When doing scrollsaw work, you dont' really see the grain as much, as the fretwork cuts hide it all.

 

I'm wondering if it is too wet..   It does stand on end on the concrete floor.  When I was resawing some of the maple Friday, the last 1/4" of  the boards..  I literally saw a wet line appear out of the end grain before the bandsaw blade finished the cut.

 

Do i need to get the ends off the concrete?  I can't see the wood pulling that much moisture out of the concrete..  Should i go and lay all the boards flat?  I do have an 8ft shelf system I made that I could prob lay the boards on.. maybe put stickers between each board for ventilation? Just makes it harder to find the wood i want if I do that, cause stuff will be infront of other stuff. Pulling it the long way out would not really be an option.  Too much stuff is at the end of the shelves.

post-14450-0-59139500-1377543129_thumb.j

I recently had this issue with Cherry that I had reduced to 3/8" as well.  I clamped it flat to my table, wet it down, and let it sit over night.  Next morning, it was perfectly flat and I was able to move on with the project.

 

I checked the moisture content of the wood before I started and it was at about 10%.  For some, that may be too high but, here in Washington state, that seems to be the norm..

 

Hope that helps.

Looking at the pic you have an even crown across the width of both boards. When you joint your boards are you alternating the faces. Meaning when you edge joint one boards face (the fence side) goes up and the other board fence side goes down. If your fence is off even 1 degree you will not have a flat panel but if you alternate the panels they will always join flat..

I recently had this issue with Cherry that I had reduced to 3/8" as well.  I clamped it flat to my table, wet it down, and let it sit over night.  Next morning, it was perfectly flat and I was able to move on with the project.

 

I checked the moisture content of the wood before I started and it was at about 10%.  For some, that may be too high but, here in Washington state, that seems to be the norm..

 

Hope that helps.

 

We dont care about a certain magical MC number we are looking at equilibrium. 

We dont care about a certain magical MC number we are looking at equilibrium. 

 

He mentioned it in his original post so, obviously he cares.

He mentioned it in his original post so, obviously he cares.

 

What I mean is that you dont look at the specific number like 8 , 10 MC what have you its meaningless. We are looking for equalibrium his Mc could be 15 at equilibrium which may seem very wet but in reality it would be more stable than 8 if equalibrium was 15.

  • Author

I don't have or use any cawls. For pressure, I usually put just enough to make the glue start to squeeze out... but also enough to be able to lift the panels off the top of my tablesaw, where I glue them up..  I also usually only use 2 clamps. I took some out of the clamps today, and they looked flat still.  I ran them though the planer and they were flat when done.  I cut a bunch of strips of some 3/16" luan into strips to use as sticker, adn put the 3 boards between them.  I'll look at them tomorrow and see if they are cupping also.

Honestly, I think you might be working the wood to fast. If I were doing it. I would joint the face and edge. Resaw the piece in half, and then let the wood acclimate. If you don't let the wood acclimate for a couple days. Once the wood is acclimated, I would again joint the face and edge then take it down to final width. 

 

Also if you are buying the wood kiln dried or not, and using it the same day, the wood isn't acclimated to your shop yet. A lumber yard is usually a lot more humid than most houses with the A/C on and whatnot. 

  • Author

I do tend to resaw it and glue it the same day.  Usually the wood sits around in the garage for like 2 weeks before I start using it.  This maple has been down there for about 4 months.

Might think about changing your sequence a bit.  Joint after you resaw.  I agree with what I've read above, however.  I'm not sure the problem is a moisture content issue.  Looks more like there's a bit of a crown in the center of the boards as well as clamping pressure causes a bow.  I'd consider using some cawls and some wax paper to keep them from sticking.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.