Recommended Posts

Posted

I am always interested in the pre-prog influences. When ever you get some time, I'd love to hear more about it.

 

How far back you wanna go?

 

I am also interested in what bands are on the top of your prog list. 

 

Like I said, Pink Floyd and Moody Blues would be my top two pure prog rock bands.  It's a coin flip as far as sheer talent and influence, although obviously Floyd is astronomically more successful in terms of popularity.  But you can't have a conversation about prog rock without first mentioning Sgt. Pepper's (which is really the first prog rock album), The Beach Boys' Pet Sounds, and The Doors first three albums.  Dylan's lyrical genius was a critical influence on every prog rock band, and The Byrds were pretty much responsible for blending the styles that would eventually yield the new genre.

 

Yes would probably be a distant third, then Genesis, then a WAY distant fifth probably Jethro Tull.  King Crimson has to be thrown in there somewhere.

Posted

I'll do some more intense Moody Blues listening. Which album(s) should I start with? I am a huge Pink Floyd fan. Although, I really don't have much of the really early stuff... I'll get it though. 

 

I like alot of Yes. One of the best shows I have ever seen was with Jon Anderson at the Pabst Theater playing solo. It was amazing.

 

I'm not too big on Tull or King Crimson... So, I'm with ya on that one! I'm sure if I locked myself in a room with their stuff, I may likely come out more of a fan, but the casual listening I have done hasn't warranted a more intense look. 

Posted

I'm sure if I locked myself in a room with their stuff, I may likely come out more of a fan, but the casual listening I have done hasn't warranted a more intense look. 

 

My thoughts exactly.

 

Moody Blues...I'd listen to them in this order:

 

In Search of the Lost Chord

On the Threshold of a Dream

A Question of Balance

Days of Future Passed

Every Good Boy Deserves Favour

To Our Children's Children's Children

Seventh Sojourn

 

Their first album, The Magnificent Moodies, you can skip.  If you fall in love with them you can go back to it later.  It's an interesting album just as a reference of their evolution, but it's not perfection like their following work.

 

Days of Future Passed is probably their most famous album, but I wouldn't recommend it for a first impression.  It's great, but it's a little different from the others.

 

After Seventh Sojourn they took a six year break...and they were never the same again.  There are some nuggets of gold here and there on the later albums, but for the most part they're throw-aways.  Ignore them unless you develop an obsession...even then they're mediocre at best.

Posted

Do you mean Phish? or more like Pink Floyd?

 

In my world of music, prog rock involves a bunch of jam bands. There are a ton of new great bands, Tea leaf Green, etc.

 

Progressive rock...."you keep using that word, I do not think it means what you think if means."

Posted

First of all it's Foxtrot not Fotrot. :D

 

Second, I would recommend starting with Trespass since it's probably the most accessible (and probably best) pre-Collins Genesis album...you can let the insanity unfold however you like after you spin Trespass 20 times or so.

 

Third, while Genesis is certainly an influential prog rock band, they're hardly the inventors.  That honor goes to Pink Floyd and The Moody Blues, who were in outer space years before Genesis. :)

 

Agreed with Pink Floyd and Moody Blues!  I would also toss in some of the early RUSH as well.

Posted

Oh, I am just anti establishment in some ways. I do not like Floyd and rock used in the same sentence, personal hangup. The same with Moody, they are certainly progressive but rarely rock. Most of this is diversionary and more closely resembles the psychedelic than the progressive. Do not read dislike in that statement. The problem I have with Pepper's is that it is still pop format and is following on the heel's of the music coming out of the Doors among others. This makes it unoriginal in its progressiveness so you cannot say the album began the progressive trend. I also do not believe you can talk prog rock without honorable mention going to Queen. They did not start it but they certainly captured it.

  • Like 1
Posted

Agreed for the most part, Shaffer...it's hard to label music because it's all so different, but as humans, some general labels are the best we can do without bogging down our little brains with a million different terms.  I do agree though that Floyd and Moodies would be better classified as psychadelia, which they often are.  And your points about Pepper's are valid, too, but it is generally thought of as the first "prog rock" album, right or wrong...and whether I know what that word means or not :D ...everything in music is debatable.  My biggest beef with calling it the first prog rock album is that assumption excludes Pet Sounds, which came about a year before Pepper's and was enormously influential on the Beatles while making Pepper's.  So I personally give the title to Brian Wilson.

  • Like 1
Posted

Phew! You guys are some pretty deep connoisseurs of the music world :). I got to grips with "hot cross buns" on the recorder as a kid and it ended there.

I genuinely like such a wide spectrum, as long as it has an ear worm quality I'm hooked. I think my tastes would get to ripped to shreds in a moment.

I really like some trash from the 80's, some Neil Young wonderful and I can't listen to radio head. Embarrassingly for me I quite like Jason Derulo's "Talk Dirty", very distinctive and has the ear worm quality I like.

  • Like 1
Posted

I got to grips with "hot cross buns" on the recorder as a kid and it ended there.

 

LOL is so overused but I literally did on this one.  If I could like a post twice I would.

 

Neil Young

 

One of my all-time favorites.  I have every scrap of music he has ever released plus the bootlegs.  Lemme know if you're missing any essentials and I'll ship them over the pond for you.

Posted

Really kind Eric, glad to here our music is build from the same quality foundation :D . On Neil Young, because my interest is paper thin I don't know any more than "Heart Of Gold" & "Rockin' In The Free World", I think I should change that.

They get really over played on the radio station I listen to but I'm always pleased to listen to The Eagles over and over again. 

Posted

Really kind Eric, glad to here our music is build from the same quality foundation :D . On Neil Young, because my interest is paper thin I don't know any more than "Heart Of Gold" & "Rockin' In The Free World", I think I should change that.

They get really over played on the radio station I listen to but I'm always pleased to listen to The Eagles over and over again. 

 

Yeah you need to change that.  PM me your address.

Posted

post-9382-0-65427200-1381697876_thumb.jp

I can play Hot Cross Buns on almost every instrument made but these are my main artillery. I listen to almost everything except modern "country" music. That is not to say I do not occasionally compulsively toe tap to that genre. I have my thousand CDs, but they were boxed as soon as I found iTunes and ripped them into my digital library. I walk around every day with over 3000 tracks on my phone. On the spot I am expected to be able to teach a lesson in any genre and I try.... I currently gravitate frequently to early Muse and Blackmore's Night, with Loreena McKennit, The Wailin Jennies also in my Pandora Celtic Woman channel. The softer stuff helps me get school paperwork done. Classic and progressive rock help me do housework and are often on while I work wood. Classical styles and musicals/opera help me unwind and jazz I play more often than sit and listen. I sound kinda messed up

  • Like 1
Posted

With all this talk of progressive rock, I had to cue up Acid Rain from Liquid Tension Experiment, a side project from Dream Theater.  Here it is in the off chance you haven't heard it (or heard it enough):

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=edqH0ofRQrM

 

I also like all those Celtic bands so if you're messed up, so am I!

 

One of my favorite bands!  Thanks for the reminder that they are just that incredible!

 

They also do Pink Floyd better than Pink Floyd!  Hard for me to say as much as I really like David Gilmore's guitar work!

Posted

Hey Freddie, and everyone else :)

 

Check out the Insomnium album, Above the weeping world. Very good Melodic Metal with some very agressive vocals. One of my favorite songs on the album is called Killjoy. It's actually a love song... 

Posted

Shaffer, those look like some pretty nice horns.  The third one a Stradivarius?  I'm right with you on "messed up" musical tastes too.  I'm half Irish & half Russian (Lithuanian, actually) & I love the Celtic stuff as well.  And just about everything else... except for pop (and I consider modern 'country' pop as well).  Every once in a while I'll put the entire iPod on random instead of just the more genre specific playlists.  It'll really screw with a passenger's head.  Eric Clapton followed by Pennywise, Norah Jones, Pink Floyd, Dying Fetus & the London Symphonic Orchestra for example.

 

I played in a couple of bands, mostly punk/punk rock/death metal.  Unfortunately about 10 years ago jobs were pretty thin & a temp agency set me up in a small steel fabrication shop.  Long story short, due to no fault of my own, I'm now missing the tip of my left hand ring finger.  There was just enough nail bed left that the nail grew back (sort of), and is on a downward angle which makes it pretty much useless on the fretboard.  I retaught myself to play with my other 3 fingers & can do most of the chords, just in really unusual fingerings, and soloing is pretty much out the window.   So I really don't pick up the guitar too often anymore.  I was also a trumpet & sax player through high school, but I really don't have the desire to pick those back up again.

 

Fun video Mel.  Reminds me of an old friend.  His son was about that age & his favorite band was Cannibal Corpse.  That little guy could headbang with the best of em!

 

You guys are making me feel all nostalgic.  Let's talk about an end table.  I bet Sam's with me.

  • Like 1
Posted

I thought the 2nd one might be a Strad as well, but I've never seen that shortened, almost cornet, style before.  That Getzen is beautiful as well.  I still have one Strad & a cheapie brass Bach (TR300 I think, it's across the country at my folks house).  Haven't put air through them in years though.  Maybe someday.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 31 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,007
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    FurniCore
    Newest Member
    FurniCore
    Joined