pghmyn Posted February 6, 2014 Report Posted February 6, 2014 I started my 401k a little while ago, and had a pretty decent mix of things that my money was invested into. Company stock was one of my biggest, and they were doing quite well. Although, now my company stock is just getting lower and lower every day because of a security issue lately. So, my question is, should I keep putting money into the company stock as it keeps getting lower with the hopes that it will eventually get much higher? Or, should I take all investing now out of it, and when I feel they are about to start gaining value, throw my money back into that account to gain value? I'm not sure if that is how it would work, as I am not very savvy with this type of stuff. Any advice would be awesome. Right now I have a growing pension, 401k and Roth account, and 65-life life insurance with growing cash value. Any other things to consider for future endeavors? Quote
Popular Post ..Kev Posted February 6, 2014 Popular Post Report Posted February 6, 2014 With all due respect Sam, I wouldn't ask my financial adviser about wood working. I'm not too sure that you would get proper advice here for how to handle your money.. 4 Quote
pghmyn Posted February 6, 2014 Author Report Posted February 6, 2014 With all due respect Sam, I wouldn't ask my financial adviser about wood working. I'm not too sure that you would get proper advice here for how to handle your money.. No disrespect taken. It is a more generalized question of "what would you do" for a group of older individuals, presumably more experienced in personal financials than myself. I'm not fully intending to take any advice to heart, but just would like to see some ideas on scenarios. Maybe a past experience with the same type of situation. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted February 6, 2014 Report Posted February 6, 2014 I'm not an investment adviser, but I play one on WoodTalkOnline... 1) Don't invest your retirement in the company you work for. If your company goes south, you may need to fall back on your retirement, so keep them separate. Don't even invest heavily in the same sector where you earn your money. 2) You want to buy low and sell high. Selling losers and buying winners is a bad idea. You want to buy a broad range of investments, like a total stock market index fund, and just stick with it. If you keep your money balanced by dollar amount, then you will safely sell high and buy low. For example, If you invest 50% in fund A and 50% in fund B, and after a while you have $100K in A and $120K in Fund B, that means that B is high and A is low. So, you "rebalance" and move $10K from B to A. You are back at 50/50, with $110K in both, and you've sold high and bought low. In your situation, I'd gradually shift my investments away from the company I worked for. Not because it's low, but because I'd rather not put my salary and retirement eggs in the same basket. So, say you're going to retire in 10 years. Decide that in 5 years you no longer want to be invested in your company. my company Fund A Fund B Fund C 2014: 40% 20% 20% 20% 2015: 31% 23% 23% 23% 2016: 22% 26% 26% 26% 2017: 13% 29% 29% 29% 2018: 4% 32% 32% 32% 2019: 33.3% 33.3% 33.3% That said, TIODS had the right idea. Find one or two financial advisers and see what they say. You can always try sending your question to a show like Marketplace. 1 Quote
Tom Crawford Posted February 6, 2014 Report Posted February 6, 2014 Go see a Fee Only financial advisor - 1 Quote
Eric. Posted February 6, 2014 Report Posted February 6, 2014 I'm not a financial adviser and I won't even try to play one on WTO... But your scenario reminds me of when the market tanked in '08 and a ton of people lost huge chunks of their money...because they got freaked and pulled out. If they hadn't touched their investments, most of them would have rebounded to the recent record-highs we just experienced. So maybe that's something to consider. Ultimately I do agree with Chip, though...I wouldn't want too much investment in the same company I'm relying on for my pension. I might keep a little in there for fun and incentive to keep you working hard. Otherwise...diversify, as they say. 2 Quote
Rick A McQuay Posted February 6, 2014 Report Posted February 6, 2014 I'm fairly active with my IRA, the commonly touted buy and hold is a sucker's game. The one rule of investing is always buy low and sell high. When a stock or fund (or economy) starts to tank, smart investors want someone out there who will buy and those people are the middle class who every month like clockwork put a chunk of money into index funds (not a slam against index funds). They buy high, buy low, buy every month regardless. The theory being sold is that over time, things will even out but it doesn't, when the economy tanks like it did in the 90's and again several years ago you can lose 30 - 50 - or 70% of your gains and that money is gone forever. Some people don't get that, they think because they still own it their money will come back when the market comes back but that isn't how it works. Someday you might end up back where you started but the money you lost, is lost. Disclaimer, I know jack squat about investing so don't take my advice but hopefully it gets you thinking. Quote
sjeff70 Posted February 7, 2014 Report Posted February 7, 2014 Ha, ha...I just signed papers today with a new financial advisor (FA). This will be my 2nd since 2007. My advise is don't try to save money trying to do this yourself. It's worth paying a fee-based pro a measly 1-1.5% a year. It might be foolish to think you can do as well as a pro on a year-to-date bases (minus 1-1.5%), while also working full time. Use market indices as an indicator of your FAs success. A portfolio should have some intra-year turn-over in it to keep up with the economy, performance, and money you allot on a monthly basis. Quote
chrisphr Posted February 7, 2014 Report Posted February 7, 2014 I have a graduate degree in finance and have successfully managed my own investments for many years. There are things that I both agree with and disagree with within this post. If investing is not your passion, then my best advice is to not trade on your own hunches or the hunches of others, and trying to time the market as a retail investor is extremely risky. Also, never invest money you can't afford to lose. Getting a financial advisor is good advice. One of the things they may discuss with you is your risk tolerance, and may suggest that in general your risk tolerance should decrease the closer you get to the point you need the money (ex: retirement). There are some DIY resources out there that are very good with lots of free, unbiased advise. My favorite is Motley Fool who provides all kinds of personal finance advice, and when you are ready for it, investing advice. Their investing philosophy is to find good companies and hold for the long term (5-10years+). The paid services at fool.com are outstanding. I know I just said don't take the advice on the hunches of others, but if this company with the security risk has a name that rhymes with Marget, I would be cautious about selling now, the market tends to over react to this kind of thing, and it coincided with a crappy Christmas retail selling season and also while the entire market is getting kicked in the teeth. Paraphrasing Warren Buffet, "be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful." 2 Quote
pghmyn Posted February 7, 2014 Author Report Posted February 7, 2014 I have some family that might have some financial advisor suggestions locally. I really want to have my money work for me, that is the goal. I guess the positive way to look at it is, I hope I at least come out even. Although, I really would like to come out $5,000,000 richer, that just wont happen! Thanks for the tips and advice on how to look at the situation. I want to start looking into stocks, but that is another thing I am nervous about going into without any advice. Maybe the financial advisor can help with that, too. Quote
Eric. Posted February 7, 2014 Report Posted February 7, 2014 I'm assuming you're in your early 20s, Sam? I gotta say, you got your head screwed on right. When I was your age, I was hitting the bars every night, skipping classes every day, working a part-time job that paid next to nothing, and putting my life on credit cards that I couldn't pay off until I was almost 30. You're a smart dude for thinking about your future now...it sneaks up on you with a quickness. 1 Quote
pghmyn Posted February 7, 2014 Author Report Posted February 7, 2014 I'm assuming you're in your early 20s, Sam? I gotta say, you got your head screwed on right. When I was your age, I was hitting the bars every night, skipping classes every day, working a part-time job that paid next to nothing, and putting my life on credit cards that I couldn't pay off until I was almost 30. You're a smart dude for thinking about your future now...it sneaks up on you with a quickness. Appreciate it. 23 as of Dec 1. I guess I just attribute it to me always telling myself, "I want that." I have a certain lifestyle I want to live, and it's not going to fall into my lap. I guess I'm lucky for the job I have. I make over $21/hour to to take a pallet out of a truck, scan it, label it, and put it aside for someone to store it in the warehouse. I didn't want to make that sound arrogant, incase it did. I try to put as much as I can aside after bills. Quote
chrisphr Posted February 7, 2014 Report Posted February 7, 2014 I guess the positive way to look at it is, I hope I at least come out even. Although, I really would like to come out $5,000,000 richer, that just wont happen Coming out even is unacceptable and at your age $5MM is totally doable by retirement. The power of compounding returns and time is in your favor. I'm with Eric on this one, thinking about this now gives you such an advantage. 1 Quote
..Kev Posted February 7, 2014 Report Posted February 7, 2014 At 23, if you only put 100 dollars a month in something earning 7% (I know, financial pros laugh at that number but, we gotta start somewhere) and you want to retire at 55.. Do the math, it's pretty amazing.. Now hiring a good FA may be well worth the money.. OMG, I really sound like my parents now! I didn't listen either.. Quote
wintersedge Posted February 11, 2014 Report Posted February 11, 2014 This is my personal opinion and I have no formal financial training other than reading and my own experience. Do not take this opinion as financial advice but more as a point to ask more questions. Money is money and everyone needs to be educated on it. With all education you are going to have bias, fanatics, points and counterpoints. The big question you have to navigate is finding the information that financially works for you and allows you to sleep at night. 1. At 23 you have to decide what kind of person you are(gambler, conservative, somewhere in the middle) and most importantly when do you think you want to retire and come up with an honest answer of when you think you can realistically retire. 2. I personally would talk to an accountant and get them to recommend a wealth manager that they know personally. You will want to get tax advice based on your current income and your projected retirement income. These numbers will change any random advice you are given. Ie.. if you are making good money now and expect that your retirement income will be less you are better off using a traditional IRA and 401k. If you think you are going to peak income anytime soon then a Roth IRA and Roth 401k will be a better investment vehicle. I am not knowledgable on self employment or government based retirement options. 3. Always put in the minimum amount to get the full match if your employer offers that. 4. Outside of 401k advice, payoff of your debt as your income is usually your biggest investment vehicle to begin with. 5. I personally use Fidelity and my wife invests with Vanguard. There are numerous funds that make investing doable via autopilot. There are target retirements funds based on age and also based on risk tolerance. You should read The Bogleheads’ Guide to Investing and read this website as thoroughly as you have time: http://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Main_Page I would also suggest this forum board: http://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance I personally used dollar cost averaging for the last 17 years. My portfolio has gone up and down numerous times but at the end of the day I have made money on what I have invested. I invested heavily in GE when I worked there. I followed the Buffet advice and went all in. Shares split a few times and I did well and then mid 2000 the stock tanked. GE has paid good dividends throughout the years and has treated me well. I should have sold but I stuck with the buy and hold. I would not recommend that now that I am much more active in managing my own portfolio. Long term I am not a fan of having a financial advisor. I hate paying for something I can learn and do myself. Again just a personal choice. If your time is more valuable then I suggest you consult with one. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.