Llama Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 Seriously considering a big router table... Wanted to get some input here first before buying. Other than being bigger, what are the advantages of a large router table over the benchtop models? Who has a smaller one and likes it? Which one do you have? Thanks! Quote
Llama Posted March 18, 2014 Author Report Posted March 18, 2014 What are you calling big? The standalone tables. Like the Jessem and similar... Like this... http://www.jessemdirect.com/Mast_R_Lift_Excel_II_Router_Table_Package_p/09411.htm Quote
pghmyn Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 The standalone tables. Like the Jessem and similar... Like this... http://www.jessemdirect.com/Mast_R_Lift_Excel_II_Router_Table_Package_p/09411.htm For that price and size, I would heavily suggest PB's all-time suggestion, get a shaper. Quote
Llama Posted March 18, 2014 Author Report Posted March 18, 2014 I didn't expect that from you Sam. Quote
dwacker Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 The larger support area is nice to have. On another note any machine with a larger top surface adds addition safety just due to the fact your hands can be further away from the cutter. It doesn't matter if its a table saw, shaper or router table. Quote
pghmyn Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 I didn't expect that from you Sam. I have used routers free hand, and in tables. My dad has a little benchtop shaper unit, and I can even tell a difference when using that thing. I will buy a router one day, absolutely. But that will probably be for free hand work. But, for most "shaping" of pieces, I will get myself a shaper. 1 Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 My current, ~ 5 year old, setup is a Bench Dog cast iron top and basic fence, with a Woodpecker lift and Milwaukee motor, on a 16 year old, shop-built, basic MDF box. The box has held up three previous surfaces, and a smaller router. The price of this setup does approach a cheap or used shaper, but I'm really happy with it. The weight of the current table and solid build of the lift leave a very clean cut surface that requires little finishing prep.. A noticeable improvement over previous iterations, even with the same bits. I don't have an ultra fancy fence, as I don't do much joinery, like dovetails or box joints on my table. While a shaper would offer more power, reverse, and possibly a tilting arbor, I appreciate being able to own more cutter profiles within the shop budget, since router bits are often cheaper than shaper cutters. I end up doing a lot of edge work that some do with a handheld router on the table, as the table's dust collection saves me cleanup time, and it's often a lot easier to move the work over the machine, than hold down the work, then hand rout. Most of my handheld routing is now limited to stuff that can be done with a trim router, as almost everything else gets done on the table. I have access to shapers. It's not often that I take advantage of the access, but I don't often do stacks of raised panels, production runs, or large, single part moldings. 1 Quote
Llama Posted March 18, 2014 Author Report Posted March 18, 2014 Just a quick read about shapers vs router table... Most shapers spin at 10K where as routers spin faster leaving a better finish on the wood during the types of routing I see myself doing. The articles/blogs state the shaper is great for millwork when pushing hundreds of feet through the machine. But simply doesn't have the RPM to match up to a nice router/table. Quote
dwacker Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 Most folks that discuss their lack of need for a shaper really dont understand shapers. They are not production machines. The cutters are not more expensive. They are not made to run yards of big moldings. A shaper vs a router is more like comparing a router to a dremel mounted in a table. Like any other tool there is a learning curve and some myth busting needed. A bigger router table gives you the benefit of added safety and more work support but thats really about it. The drawback is that with a heavy router they are more likely to sag especially with smaller plates. If you can afford cast iron you get the benefit of having a smooth surface. For cutters like lock miters this is a great benefit for a 1/4" round over not so much. Quote
pghmyn Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 Just a quick read about shapers vs router table... Most shapers spin at 10K where as routers spin faster leaving a better finish on the wood during the types of routing I see myself doing. The articles/blogs state the shaper is great for millwork when pushing hundreds of feet through the machine. But simply doesn't have the RPM to match up to a nice router/table. It's been a little bit since I have been in rotational physics, so the formulas are sketchy coming off the top of my head. However, with a shaper, aren't the cutters larger? So, for example, a 1" radius bit in a router at 20,000 rpm is the same angular velocity of of a 2" cutter in a shaper at 10,000 rpm. I think that's how it came out. Quote
dwacker Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 Just a quick read about shapers vs router table... Most shapers spin at 10K where as routers spin faster leaving a better finish on the wood during the types of routing I see myself doing. The articles/blogs state the shaper is great for millwork when pushing hundreds of feet through the machine. But simply doesn't have the RPM to match up to a nice router/table. NO this is not true shapers leave a MUCH MUCH better finish speed has nothing to do with it its the cutter diameter. NO shapers are NOT good for millwork that is what a moulder is for. Shapers can't use a real out feed shoe so really they suck at mouldings compared to a moulder. Quote
Llama Posted March 18, 2014 Author Report Posted March 18, 2014 I am learning here, just what I read on several sites. As far as cut quality, if I'm running a rabbet on my router at a lower RPM, I get more tearout than with a higher RPM. Not sure if this translates to a shaper vs router table... Sam, If I use the collet for router bits, the bit would be the same diameter no matter which machine I use. I do understand bigger bits need to spin at a slower motor RPM. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 NO shapers are NOT good for millwork that is what a moulder is for. Good point! My molding guy uses a van-sized multi-axis machine, that also sands a bit. It can also create flooring and siding. One of the cost savings points, in my experience, is the ability to use a cutter in either the handheld router or table. Of course, this does not come into play with lock miters, panel raisers, etc... but with a lot of pattern and edge forming bits it does. Quote
pghmyn Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 I am learning here, just what I read on several sites. As far as cut quality, if I'm running a rabbet on my router at a lower RPM, I get more tearout than with a higher RPM. Not sure if this translates to a shaper vs router table... Sam, If I use the collet for router bits, the bit would be the same diameter no matter which machine I use. I do understand bigger bits need to spin at a slower motor RPM. I'm not sure of the cost, but you could invest in a few shaper cutters right off the bat, instead of using the router bit in the shaper. Quote
dwacker Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 I am learning here, just what I read on several sites. As far as cut quality, if I'm running a rabbet on my router at a lower RPM, I get more tearout than with a higher RPM. Not sure if this translates to a shaper vs router table... Sam, If I use the collet for router bits, the bit would be the same diameter no matter which machine I use. I do understand bigger bits need to spin at a slower motor RPM. No the reason you get more tear out is your bit is not cutting the wood at lower RPM's is breaking it off. The router bit diameter is to small to run at low speeds. The router bit is cutting at a steeper angle so will leave a poor surface quality compared to a shaper. Set your coffee cup and a coffee can on a line. Look at the difference in the arc of the cut. When it comes to cutters there are so many ways to go about things with a shaper. For example a single cutter can be a few different profiles. Like a 1/8 round over knife can have a 1/2" round over on the other end and a 1/2 bull nose in the center of a single cutter. A cope and stick or tongue and groove can have both cutters on a single cutter edge. The possibilities are endless and not limiting like a router table. It is nice to have a handheld router and a few bits for hand work but once you have a shaper most of the time the router just sits in the cabinet. 1 Quote
Llama Posted March 18, 2014 Author Report Posted March 18, 2014 This isn't a cost issue... Obviously I don't have $10,000 to spend on this, but I do have a realistic budget for either scenario. Honestly the Jessem or a table that I make is at the top of my list right now. Quote
Llama Posted March 18, 2014 Author Report Posted March 18, 2014 PB, is there anything the shaper can't do vs a router table? Obviously within reason.And which hp shaper is needed to really get good results. The one I'd buy if I bought a shaper is the Grizzly 1.5hp. Quote
Eric. Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 Mel, I'm not gonna get into the "what's best" and why argument...I'll just tell you that I like my router table for a lot of things...for the vast majority of basic operations in a hobby shop it's fine. But I do plan to get a shaper in the future for one major reason: to template route large (thick) pieces, like curved legs. I GOTTA have one of those Byrd pattern heads. And also for raising panels. I haven't encountered many other scenarios where I'm not perfectly happy with router table performance/capacity. 2 Quote
dwacker Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 PB, is there anything the shaper can't do vs a router table? Obviously within reason. And which hp shaper is needed to really get good results. The one I'd buy if I bought a shaper is the Grizzly 1.5hp. You can't run a dado far from the edge. The distance depends on the shaper. You cant do dovetails. I prefer to run most everything on 1 1/4 spindles but that being said I use a power feed 99% of the time. There are plenty of 3/4" spindle cutters and moulder heads to hold corrugated knives. with the smaller shapers you will be limited to about 3" tall heads and still be able to run a guide bearing. Reality is shapers take more education than routers but once you have it you will never look back. Routers are easy. I will add router tables are a good stepping stone to a shaper. If you dont have any router table experience a shaper may be a scary option. 1 Quote
Cochese Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 Mel, I'm not gonna get into the "what's best" and why argument...I'll just tell you that I like my router table for a lot of things...for the vast majority of basic operations in a hobby shop it's fine. But I do plan to get a shaper in the future for one major reason: to template route large (thick) pieces, like curved legs. I GOTTA have one of those Byrd pattern heads. And also for raising panels. I haven't encountered many other scenarios where I'm not perfectly happy with router table performance/capacity. Basically my feelings on it as well. Router tables can also be as bare-bones as you like it. Cheap as chips router bolted to the bottom of a piece of MDF. Mel, I'll also add this: I have everything I could ever want out of my router and table for $400. You decide what options you want. 1 Quote
dwacker Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 I think you should make a list of what you plan to do with a router table then weigh it all out. Just because one is great for one person it may not be good for you. The whole it works for me so it must be ok review doesn't really help. Quote
pghmyn Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 If you watch Frank Howarth's videos, he uses regular sized router bits in his small JET shaper. Presumably the same thing as the Grizzly you are looking at. He is pretty picky with results, so I think that is a good representation of how clean the bits cut in the machine. Quote
Guest Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 I have one of these bench dog router tables. I really don't like it for a few reasons. These are not things I would have anticipated going into my purchase (if I did I would have bought something else). This is my experience after using it for a few years. I find it difficult to square the fence to the cutter. Yes it is only two wing nuts to adjust but keeping a square around just for that purpose is a PITA. Geometry is not my thing, maybe there is a reason why you would want to orient the fence on an angle to the cutter head, but I have never seen the need. There are times it doesn't matter, but when you want it square, you really want it square. I'd prefer a fence that was self squaring. It is louder than hell. The plywood box basically becomes a resonant echo chamber, making the router louder and deeper in pitch (which is harder to muffle) than the the router sitting outside by itself. i will probably fill it up with insulation or some spray foam one day to deaden the sound. It is a PITA to keep the mounting plate flush to the table. Yes you can fix that by having a thin sheet of ply or MDF go over the whole thing but then the fence and miter slot are difficult to use. When routing a profile any little snag and you get chatter so you want as flush a surface as possible. The table top is too small. Working with any longer stock is dangerous and difficult (pretty much all I do). You have to open to door to turn the router on. Its just cumbersome. I know I can add an external switch and probably will one day, but the reason why I bought a ready made box is because I don't like fiddling around with shop gear. I like building real furniture. In terms of the good: It is well made, the miter slot is nice, and it is nice that the fence inserts are replaceable. That being said, I'd prefer a fence that would be easier to offset for jointing or edge profiling situations. Taping a piece of formica to the outfeed fence is the kind of improvistation I just don't like dealing with. For the work I do, a long infeed table and outfeed table with a square fence would be ideal. Basically a similar set up to a jointer or maybe stick it in my table saw wing. One day I will custom make something like that but until then I will just curse the thing I have now. All that being said I don't use the router table much so it is a low, but frustrating, priority. Quote
Eric. Posted March 18, 2014 Report Posted March 18, 2014 I find it difficult to square the fence to the cutter. Yes it is only two wing nuts to adjust but keeping a square around just for that purpose is a PITA. Geometry is not my thing, maybe there is a reason why you would want to orient the fence on an angle to the cutter head, but I have never seen the need. There are times it doesn't matter, but when you want it square, you really want it square. I'd prefer a fence that was self squaring. I'm not following you...a router table fence doesn't have to be "square" to the bit. Just like on a drill press...the cutting only happens at one point, so it doesn't matter if the fence is at an angle or not...depth and height of cut are the only two variables. Unless I misunderstand your complaint... Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.