Recommended Posts

Posted

If you watch Frank Howarth's videos, he uses regular sized router bits in his small JET shaper. Presumably the same thing as the Grizzly you are looking at. He is pretty picky with results, so I think that is a good representation of how clean the bits cut in the machine.

 

Ya its surprising. The reality is if you fire up your router at 15000 rpm when the bit hits the wood it falls on its face and may be turning at half that. With a shaper your not going to slow down a router bit just due to the induction motor power.

Posted

I'm not following you...a router table fence doesn't have to be "square" to the bit.  Just like on a drill press...the cutting only happens at one point, so it doesn't matter if the fence is at an angle or not...depth and height of cut are the only two variables.

 

Unless I misunderstand your complaint...

 

No you are not misunderstanding my complaint, most of the times it does not matter.  But there are some operations where it would be helfpul.  Like what Freddie said, if I am using my miter gauge and want to use the fence to register my cut like you would on a table saw.  It might seem like a minor nit but it happens enough to be annoying. 

 

Its also annoying because in order for the dust collection to work, there needs to be a gap between the infeed and outfeed sections of the fence, this is where the dust escapes.  But this is also where you would want to measure the distance between the fence and your point of contact on the router bit.   So I need to slide the infeed and outfeed sections of the fence into each other, take my measurements, and then open them back up.  It just adds another step.   

 

All that  being said I just ordered a dado stack for my table saw so my router table will get even less use.  It will mostly be for profile and pattern work and the guide bearing is all you need for that.  I can take the fence is toss it at that point. 

Posted

As a note, I am currently building a new router table, at close to 32"x24", which is close to what a lot of the commercial tables are.  If I wasn't getting a lift, I could have a top and a basic stand built for under $100, with a basic plate and existing router.  My table, I am putting a few bells and whistles on it, including lift, while still using an existing router (just transplanting it from the old to the new), and cabinet as the stand.  Even with the lift, I will still be well under the cost of anything commercially made.

 

My current router table, I built it back in 2005, is 24"x21", and is pretty basic.  The top size is adequate for most operations, but there have been some times I wished I had a little bigger surface.

Posted

No you are not misunderstanding my complaint, most of the times it does not matter.  But there are some operations where it would be helfpul.  Like what Freddie said, if I am using my miter gauge and want to use the fence to register my cut like you would on a table saw.  It might seem like a minor nit but it happens enough to be annoying.

 

In this case I would actually prefer to have a non-"self-squaring" fence.  With a miter gauge it doesn't matter because you can just adjust the gauge head to complement the angle of the fence, or vice-versa.  So in that case it's moot.  But if you're using a jig or sled with a runner that's fixed in a single orientation...non-adjustable...you have to adjust your fence parallel to the miter track.  And while you can try to permanently dial your fence it to be perfectly parallel with the track the same way you do with your table saw, IMO it will never stay that way, so you'll have to fiddle with it anyway...and it's much easier if you can just slap your square against your jig and fence and be dialed in in a split second.  Not to mention, you don't have to worry about building your jigs dead nuts square...you just adjust accordingly with the fence.

 

Adjustments with fixed fences are more of a pain.  Anyway, that's my take on it.  All your other complaints I totally understand...I'm lucky to have the Incra and it pretty much addresses those other issues.

Posted

You can adjust a miter square to the fence, yah sure. But if the slot and fence arent parallel, good luck. I dont get down with the router table often so ive never needed to use this operation.

Posted

In this case I would actually prefer to have a non-"self-squaring" fence.  With a miter gauge it doesn't matter because you can just adjust the gauge head to complement the angle of the fence, or vice-versa.  So in that case it's moot.  But if you're using a jig or sled with a runner that's fixed in a single orientation...non-adjustable...you have to adjust your fence parallel to the miter track.  And while you can try to permanently dial your fence it to be perfectly parallel with the track the same way you do with your table saw, IMO it will never stay that way, so you'll have to fiddle with it anyway...and it's much easier if you can just slap your square against your jig and fence and be dialed in in a split second.  Not to mention, you don't have to worry about building your jigs dead nuts square...you just adjust accordingly with the fence.

 

Adjustments with fixed fences are more of a pain.  Anyway, that's my take on it.  All your other complaints I totally understand...I'm lucky to have the Incra and it pretty much addresses those other issues.

 

With that being said if you did that to make the cope cuts on a set of cabinet doors with a miter gauge for example you would make parallelograms instead of rectangles. If you are using any device that slides in the miter slot the work piece should be 90 degrees to the miter slot for 90 degree cuts. If your using your fence as a stop and can't get it parallel to the miter slot mark a spot on the fence as your reference and toe the fence out on the out feed side. You also can't square off your fence if its not parallel to the miter slot and use a jig that moves in the miter slot. Some fences like the incra that move in and out from the center are easy as are most shapers that move from the center.

Posted

This is why I don't use a miter gauge on my router table. :wacko:   Maybe it's just the stuff I happen to build or I'm missing opportunities, but I never find the need.

Posted

Some fences like the incra that move in and out from the center are easy as are most shapers that move from the center.

 

Bingo... that is the problem with the bench dog design.  the fence does not move out from the center, it has a slot on the infeed and a slot on the outfeed.  So any time you move either end of the fence you also move the center a little bt.  even after you get the fence where you want it relative to the router bit at the center, just tightening down the wing nuts on either end tend to shift it a little bit at the center.  Classic case of chasing your tail.   Its not the end of the world just one more annoying thing to deal with on a machine that is already cumbersome to set up.  If I want to cut a groove 2" from the edge of a board on a tablesaw I just move the fence over and lock it down at 2 inches.  if I want to do it on a router table it takes a lot more work to dial in and keep it there.  It is doable  there is just nothing fun about it.   But part of the problem, for me, stems from using it for grooves and dados when a dado stack in my table saw would be easier.  Since that is on the way my router table will basically just be used for small profiles, not for joinery. 

Posted

Take a tri-square set it in relation to the bit and, miter slot where the location of the fence should be using the tri-square set one end of the fence than set other side of fence re check first side of fence to make sure it didn't pivot on you.

Posted

I would say use the fence when its appropriate and use the miter when its appropriate. Its never appropriate to use them together unless the fence is just a stop. Even then the fence should be toed out or a proper spacer block used just like a table saw. 

Posted

Bingo... that is the problem with the bench dog design.  the fence does not move out from the center, it has a slot on the infeed and a slot on the outfeed.  So any time you move either end of the fence you also move the center a little bt.  even after you get the fence where you want it relative to the router bit at the center, just tightening down the wing nuts on either end tend to shift it a little bit at the center.  Classic case of chasing your tail.   Its not the end of the world just one more annoying thing to deal with on a machine that is already cumbersome to set up.  If I want to cut a groove 2" from the edge of a board on a tablesaw I just move the fence over and lock it down at 2 inches.  if I want to do it on a router table it takes a lot more work to dial in and keep it there.  It is doable  there is just nothing fun about it.   But part of the problem, for me, stems from using it for grooves and dados when a dado stack in my table saw would be easier.  Since that is on the way my router table will basically just be used for small profiles, not for joinery. 

 

 

Again...you're talking about in conjunction with a miter gauge?  For adjustments when performing regular operations without a gauge or a jig, say if you wanted to nibble off another 1/16" of a rabbet or something, or make a chamfer slightly more pronounced...all you have to is nudge one end of the fence back, not both ends.

Posted

The only time I use the fence and the miter gauge together is as a stop, like you would on a table saw. 

 

I know how to adjust the thing and get the result I need.  Its just a lot more cumbersome than setting a fence my table saw or jointer, that is all.  didn't mean to spin the conversation out of control.  But I am comparing apples to oranges.  My table saw and jointer are machines. My router table is a toy in comparison and performs as such.   It sounds like there are better fence designs out there, like you have on the Incra, I will have to look into that. 

Posted

Obviously you'd know better than me since I've never owned that unit...I went straight from shop-made monstrosity to Incra paradise.  But on the one I built, the fence was similar with the two adjustment points...and all I had to do was nudge one end back a bit and I was done.  I never messed with moving both ends of the fence.  There was nothing micro-adjustable about it, but I didn't find it that difficult or frustrating...I'd use a combo square and tap tap tap until I was at my desired depth.

 

Just trying to get to the bottom of your problem, and making sure I understood what it actually was. :)

  • Like 1
Posted

The only time I use the fence and the miter gauge together is as a stop, like you would on a table saw.

 

You do use a stand-off at the table saw for through cuts, right?   Bad juju crosscutting when the stock is trapped between the blade, fence and miter gauge.

 

I have the larger, cast-iron table version of the same fence.  If you want to use a stop with the miter gauge, skip the fence and clamp a reference block to the table or far end of the infeed fence.  Slide your stock against the stop, hold it in place on the miter gauge and slide forward, along the miter slot, through the cutter.  

 

If you're fine tuning the fence, when not using the miter gauge, you only need to tap ONE end to adjust the cut.  Each move in relation to the cutter is only half of the distance you've moved one end.  It's surprisingly precise when setting up to a mark.  You can then clamp a stop behind one end of the fence, and pull it forward to make multi-pass cuts in difficult stock or deep profiles.  The final cut is made when the fence hits the stop again.   This is much easier when only one end is moving.

Posted

You do use a stand-off at the table saw for through cuts, right?   Bad juju crosscutting when the stock is trapped between the blade, fence and miter gauge.

 

 

Yes, I learned that lesson a long long long time ago.  :)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.