Recommended Posts

Posted

So I've started to venture into the world of video.

 

Now, i understand there's a lot to know about it.  I also know enough to fill a thimble.  So obviously there's some holes in my knowledge base.  What I'm asking for is some general feedback on the editing of some video I've completed, whether it makes sense, flows, looks good, etc.  

 

I already know about some of the video quality issues... I didn't find our tripod until after the shoot, so you'll have to deal with the "breathing effect" of many of the videos.  Speaking of breathing, you can hear my coat creaking in the background, so I know sound is an issue.  (New microphones just arrived today; won't get to test them out until tomorrow.)  And I didn't have the press pass, so I couldn't set up in the section reserved for the wheelchairs and tripods (and didn't want to kneel in one spot for over an hour to rest the camera on the ledge)... so people walk in front of the video.

 

I ask because this video has been struggling to get completed for over a month.  The raw footage happens to be too large to email to our other campus, so I've tackled it.  (I need to learn anyway.)  But I'm not in any classes for video production.

 

Am I on the right track?  Do I need to change anything specific?  General?  (Do I need to fire the camera man?)

 

I know, not having the whole raw footage available makes it difficult to compare the video results to what it started from.  I'm deliberately asking about just the final results, though, to see if this is a worthwhile approach.

 

(I'm including the link to the article I've written, rather than the individual links for the video.  One link instead of four.  If you want to read the article, be my guest... but it's not a requirement.)

 

http://www.cccvoice.com/2014/03/20/award-winning-author-starts-carol-s-franklin-social-science-speaker-series/

  • 1 month later...
Posted

J, for the 5 minute woodworker there is not even 5 seconds of woodworking on there ;-0  Just kidding, but seriously, flip flops in snow and salt? What gives bro... As for the the other videos of the speaker, he is very well spoken and insightful on the civil rights movement era. I also liked his answer on Obama - not to inflame political debates, but I like how he puts it that it was inevitable. LOL, I guess my votes against him were wasted, huh? Anyway, as for editing, the only editing that I noticed were the opening screen shots, and the cut away for the questions asked that were not audible. What else did you do that I didn't pick up? The breathing effect wasn't bad and I am surprised that the camera didn't compensate for it? Most cameras in the last 5 years or so have automatic stabilizers of some sort. I too have used wondershare, but wasn't a fan of the watermark... Have you found other freeware for editing? Or will you eventually take the plunge with Adobe products?

Posted

Part of the problem is the paper equipment isn't set for a feed.  Aside from the built-in mic and the 1/8" jack, that's it.

 

The wondershare watermark I didn't realize would be that big when I agreed to it.  You get it with the trial version, but they give you the option to do without it for the paid version.  (Haven't upgraded yet.)

 

For these, I used iMovie on the office Macs.  The Wondershare was required because I hadn't set up the camera (Sony PowerShot) to the correct file type before attending.  I'm not a big fan of it, as it's really unnecessary if you set the file up correctly beforehand.  I was in a pinch, so I did a quick 20 minute search and found a couple of types to research before downloading the wondershare... and I haven't used it since.

 

Since my tenure as the Editor for the campus ends in just under two weeks, I won't have full access to everything, but I've agreed to help out the next editor (whoever that might be) over the summer as needed, and be a staff writer for the fall semester.  So I'll still have access to iMovie, Garage Band, and the (already acquired) FinalCut and Adobe fleet of products... which I have yet to test.

 

There were some other videos, hosted directly on the school paper site (small enough file size), with different editing approaches.  What I focused on was trying to find whole clips that covered the topics I wanted to touch on, rather than deal with splicing and all that.  (I'm still learning, after all.)  On the Wondershare/ Open Forum, I was listening to the feed on the computer speaker, which is below the desk.  Even fully turned up, I lose most of the sound.  I missed the topic when I did the clip selection, so I thought it was dealing with the health center.... Funny how you miss things after finalizing.  This camera did not have any options other than the built-in, so there's a lot of ambient that I didn't realize was there up front.

 

I've got four assignments due by midnight tonight, so I have to put off editing of the last video until tomorrow, which happens to be the deadline.  Mostly, I was worried that the spacing of where the clip started looked good (how do you catch someone mid gesture without getting them to look mid gesture?) and that the transition/title pages looked appropriate.  I'm also concerned the topics are valid topics to catch on film.  With the forum, I didn't have any way of scripting the process.  This one I grabbed in small chunks, so uploading time was easier... just more transitions.  The longer ones (especially with a tripod) give more options to jot down time indexes, so you can go right to that point when you edit.  I did that on the most recent one (still unedited), but they're going to be off because the battery died mid-filming, and I swapped the memory card back and forth between two cameras.  (Which is one final reason why I haven't started yet.)

 

In one of the Childers videos (on the school site, should pop up under the "suggested by" section) I tried some mid-clip editing, using a lens flare to disguise the jump within her response.  I'm hoping it lined up fine.  As for the printed question, three reasons.  First, most of the questioners were not miked, so they are harder to hear over the video.  Second, some of them took a long time to ask the question, and I summarized the question as best as I could.  Third, I didn't have releases from them to put their likeness or voice on the site, so I opted for the safer approach.  Should I have added some background noise or music?  Should I have tuned down the audience sounds during the intro/outcut scenes?  (I used the blue logo as either, and a podium shot from a later video.  I've also done both quiet and full volume clips, trying to figure out which was more appropriate.)

 

As for the sandals, well, that's how I roll, baby.  (at least, until they broke.  Haven't replaced them yet, but I want to.  I'm far more comfortable in sandals, even in snow.)  Yes, I have shoes, and yes, I have worn the sandals in the shop.  I don't like to when I'm working with power tools (not just for safety reasons), but for hand tools, I don't mind so much.  The sandals are also easy to throw on when I go out to the shop, and come off quick when I come inside.  

 

Woodworking videos should start appearing this summer, as I am not taking classes.  This means I finally get into the shop, and can film some of the work I'm attempting to do.  (The first video was 40 minutes of me looking for a tool - that happened to be sitting right in front of the camera.... not a blockbuster.)  I've got three planned, but I haven't acquired things like lumber, parts, or the camera yet.  (I'll certainly look into getting feeds from sound boards.) 

 

For home/shop use, do I need a sound board, or can I get away with a lavalier or wireless mic?  (I don't plan on doing a lot of speaking, but some explanation of what I'm looking for might be necessary.)  The plan also includes a picture in picture with a countdown timer running for some of those quicker 5 minute jobs... trying to be a true five minute video.

Posted

Something you might consider for the audio is to use a wearable recording device (like a smart phone) for the audio. Just mix it into the video during 'post processing'. That method gives you complete freedom to move around without fading out, and avoids the cost of a good wireless lapel mic. You just need a good marker at the beginning ( Hollywood style slap board) that lets you synch the audio to the video.

Posted

Question videos 2 & 3 begin with about 10 seconds of unnecessary footage. Otherwise it seems you were limited by the equipment available to you. There are methods of stabilizing a camera other than using a tripod but the movement wasn't particularly distracting. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 32 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,007
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    FurniCore
    Newest Member
    FurniCore
    Joined