Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey all. Wondering if anyone could give me advice on getting good results from my jointer. I think I finally have it adjusted right. Had a hell of a time doing that but that's another story. I'm struggling with how perfect my boards need to be. Example: I'm milling 4/4 boards to build a sitting bench top and want to keep them about 3/4". Again, I think the jointer is all dialed in. One board has a slight cup length wise (it's about 3' long). I mark the bottom, run it through cup down, until marks are gone. Looks great to eye. Put my 4' lee valley straight edge on it and see a small cup is still there (maybe 1/32 at center). Don't want to run it through much more to save thickness. Seems the board is flexing slightly as I apply pressure through cut and that no matter how many passes, that slight cup will still be there.

So, is this somewhat normal with longish/flat stock? Am I overthinking this and should just run with it? Also, assuming my machine is set up right, is there a technique problem here? I can probably post some pictures if that would help.

Thanks!

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

1/32" dip over 36" length, I'd be fine with that. But not everyone here would be. If you are consistent thickness across the board, any joinery will be fine. I don't know your design, but I'll be willing to assume that small cup can be pulled straight with the slightest of pressure.

Post some pics of your design and progress. Would love to see them.

Posted

Seems the board is flexing slightly as I apply pressure through cut and that no matter how many passes, that slight cup will still be there.

 

 

There's your answer...apply less pressure.  The thinner the board, the more sensitive you have to be about that.  If you compress the board down into the bed, you're not gonna get a flat board...it's gonna spring back to original shape like you're experiencing, since you're not taking meat off of just the ends, but the entire length of the board.  For 8/4 you don't have to think about it.  You should only be applying enough pressure so that you have control over the board.  Wax your beds, that will help.

 

If your jointer is dialed in dead nuts, you should be able to get a board dead nuts flat.  That doesn't mean it'll stay that way for more than five minutes, but you should be able to achieve it initially at least.

  • Like 1
Posted

Thanks guys. Guess I just need to practice and hope my setup is good. If I have to tweek with it one more time I'm gonna end up taking a sledge hammer to it!

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

My question: are you having fun? 3/4 material 3' long and 1/32" bow on the face? Send her through the planer and check on Saturday. It might be straight, it might be worse. Look into metalworking if you can't get happy with wood. Wood is not perfect. Projects aren't perfect. But in the end it all works. We aren't making parts for the international space station. Relax and enjoy the craft. It's a process.

Posted

Maybe I am reading the question wrong but I think Jharry is referring to cup. To me cup is when the center of a board is higher than the edges across the width, not the length. When I am trying to joint cup out of a board I put the concave side down on the bed not the cupped side. If you put the cupped side down the center of the board can rock. 

Posted

I think he is referring to bow which is hard if not impossible to remove in limp boards that press down. Hence the reference to the pencil marks being removed. Cup as you define bit would leave pencil marks.

You're probably right, just thought I would throw that in just in case, trying to help a brother.

  • Like 1
Posted

Look into metalworking if you can't get happy with wood. Wood is not perfect. Projects aren't perfect. But in the end it all works. We aren't making parts for the international space station. Relax and enjoy the craft. It's a process.

Thanks for the responses guys. I was referring to the lengthwise direction, just didn't know how to explain it other than cup.

Here's a longwinded answer or response to t-astragal's question (so stop reading here if you better things to do;)

There was really more to my question than just being anal. First off, I realize wood is not perfect. Just so you know where I'm coming from, this is the first time I've used a jointer and the milling I was doing was to check accuracy. After countless hours of adjustment including a full take apart, cleaning, and reassembly, I'm trying to convince myself the machine is nuts on. I'd like it to be, at least to begin with. So it sounds like if I can run an 8/4 board through or I'd also think, edge joint a board, perfectly straight, it should be good to go.

Secondly, I'm very much a beginner at woodworking, and definitely so with this jointer and my planer. I guess you could criticize why I have the tools in the first place if I'm such a noob. My only argument is that I've really wanted to start woodworking for a long time and got a great deal on them. Anyways, to answer your question about if I'm having fun. I'd so no, not at the moment, but I feel getting my tools dailed in at the beginning will make things more fun and rewarding when I actually start milling stuff for real projects. Finally, just try to think about when you were first starting out. There's tons of questions you have about how things should be done and how accurate they need to be.

Places like this are a great resource for us beginners so it's good to know I don't need to sweat over 1/32. Again though, the question was really related to setup accuracy and whether the technique might be to blame over the machine.

Thank you all again

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

Thanks for the responses guys. I was referring to the lengthwise direction, just didn't know how to explain it other than cup.

Here's a longwinded answer or response to t-astragal's question (so stop reading here if you better things to do;)

There was really more to my question than just being anal. First off, I realize wood is not perfect. Just so you know where I'm coming from, this is the first time I've used a jointer and the milling I was doing was to check accuracy. After countless hours of adjustment including a full take apart, cleaning, and reassembly, I'm trying to convince myself the machine is nuts on. I'd like it to be, at least to begin with. So it sounds like if I can run an 8/4 board through or I'd also think, edge joint a board, perfectly straight, it should be good to go.

Secondly, I'm very much a beginner at woodworking, and definitely so with this jointer and my planer. I guess you could criticize why I have the tools in the first place if I'm such a noob. My only argument is that I've really wanted to start woodworking for a long time and got a great deal on them. Anyways, to answer your question about if I'm having fun. I'd so no, not at the moment, but I feel getting my tools dailed in at the beginning will make things more fun and rewarding when I actually start milling stuff for real projects. Finally, just try to think about when you were first starting out. There's tons of questions you have about how things should be done and how accurate they need to be.

Places like this are a great resource for us beginners so it's good to know I don't need to sweat over 1/32. Again though, the question was really related to setup accuracy and whether the technique might be to blame over the machine.

Thank you all again

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Everyone has to start somewhere. There are some incredibly talented people here, but their technique didn't come to them overnight. As long as you keep an open mind and are open to correcting mistakes, you will have fun. It's the continuous pursuit to do better that makes woodworking challenging and fun.

If you can relate this 1/32" of gap to technique, work on fixing it. If you can narrow it down to a bit of machine error or wood movement, I'd live with it for now. But I wouldn't forget about it! When time permits, I would go to the machine and learn how to make proper adjustments.

Good luck in your endeavors, and welcome to the community!

Posted

I'm very new and have many tools that are smarter/more accurate than me....  LOL I've learned so much from everyone here because I needed to know when good enough in my eyes is actually great and vise versa. I have a huge tendency to over think the process. For me I enjoy the tuning of my machines it relaxes me and lets me be the tech I used to be. Now sharpening that's an acquired enjoyment!!!!  LOL

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 60 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined