Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been woodworking for a while and have been in my house now for 2 years, so my 2 car garage is my legit shop without using other people's spaces. I haven't run any ductwork yet as I'm unsure if my current dust collector is going to be sufficient. I have a JDS DustForce 1.5HP with 1 micro top bag with 42 gallon bag for dust. I find I fill that big up real quick, especially if I'm milling wood, cleaning the dust collector is a gigantic pain because I take the bag out, empty it into a contractor bag, turn the filter bag inside out and hit it with compressed air, and then reassemble the collector takes about 60 minutes to get it all cleaned up.

 

Current DC specs

Specifications
 
Motor
1.5 HP TEFC
Max CFM
1250
Max Static Pressure
12"
Filter Type
1 Micron
Length
33"
Width
21"
Height
76"
Impeller Size
11"
Impeller Material
Steel
Inlet Diameter
One 6" / Two 4"
Bag Capacity
42 gallons
Decibels
67-77 dB

Electrical

110V

 

I'd ideally like to stop connecting and disconnecting hoses to each machine as I work with it. I have the following machines which I would be hooking the collector to:

 

Jet JTAS-10XL-1 3HP Cabinet saw

Performax 10-20 Drum Sander

Grizzly G5093 8" Jointer

Dewalt 735X 13" Planer

Rikon 14-325 Deluxe 14" Bandsaw

Jet 1642 EVS Lathe (via dust chute)

Kreg router table with Porter Cable 7518

The remainder of my machines are smaller sanders, OSS, miter saw, drill press, etc, those I'd hook up as needed to my Shop-Vac with Oneida Dust Deputy. 

 

I'd like to go with a cyclone system of some kind, for the benefit of keeping the filter cleaner and emptying must quicker. I do have 220v available. I've done a ton of research, however I don't know what I truly need to run 1 machine at a time and be able to have enough power and suction at the end of the ducting.

 

Thanks 

 

 

Posted

Your unit will probably work with a ducted system and an aftermarket cyclone...poorly.  I have a ducted system in a two car garage with similar sized tools.  I use a 2HP Grizzly blower with an Oneida Super Dust Deputy cyclone.  It yields mediocre results.  It pulls the bigger chips well from the jointer and planer, works pretty good on the drum sander and router table, fair to poor collection on the bandsaws, terrible on the table saw (and I've tried every trick in the book aside from overhead collection...which is on the to-do list).  For skim cuts I may as well not have anything hooked up...worthless.

 

So if I were you, I'd go ahead and duct your system, but be prepared for fairly disappointing results and the possibility you'll want (or need) to upgrade your unit.

 

My main priority with DC is picking up the bulk of the mess...and mine does that, so I'm pretty satisfied with that objective.  If you're one of those people who's all freaked out about having perfectly clean air, you'll find it unacceptable.  I do plan to upgrade to a bigger unit eventually, but it's far from a priority at the moment.

Posted

Try using a plastic collection bag to save a step emptying the cloth bag. Also, don't clean the filter bag quite so thoroughly. A light coating if dust actually helps filter more particulates, although it does restrict air flow a bit. I just give mine a few whacks with a stick, like beating a rug, before removing the lower bag.

Posted

I used plastic collector bags at the bottom, it'd be nice to just toss them when full, however at 30 bucks for 5 bags, It's way to expensive and I can easily fill 2 in a weekend.

I dump the plastic bag into a yard and waste bag (brown paper). Then the city collects it with yard waste/ compost on collection day. I have been using the same 5 plastic bags for 2 years.

Posted

I have put my cyclone onto a brute heavy duty trash can on wheels. Their lids are air tight. The regular brute trash can collapsed but the heavy duty doesn't. I still have the regular brute can but put a steel trash can in as a liner.  Both are the 1.5 cu yd models. Adding aluminum to my system helped a lot too. Sealing up extra gaps on the different tools helped too. 

Posted

I may as well go hard or go home if I'm gonna do it. I've invested as much in my stationary machines as I kind of planned on doing. There are really no tasks or builds that I can't do with the tools I currently have. if 1.5 HP dust collection isn't gonna cut it with the 1 micron bag up top that gets dirty real fast and is messy to clean, I may as well just upgrade right? Nobody ever said woodworking was cheap. I have 3 220 circuits in my garage. Right now I have my table saw on one and on the opposite side my jointer on the other, and a dedicated hardwired heater. While I could rearrange the shop and put the dust collector on the side where the jointer is, that will move it to the other side of the garage and further away from the tools which isn't always the best.

 

I kind of narrowed it down to 3 choices.

 

Clearvue 1800 with filters $1695 (however it seems you need to buy the electrical box $250, wall brackets $45, clean out $35 and it's a 30 Amp break which I'd prefer not to dedicate to a DC as I only have 60Amp into my garage and I'm not changing that wire and redoing the electricity again. Plus it's a pretty permanent install, so it better be in the right spot once installed.)

http://www.clearvuecyclones.com/9-cv1800-series

 

 

JDS  3HP Cyclone 3100-CK 2300 CFM Dust Collector

http://jdstools.com/3hpcyclone3100-ck2300cfmdustcollector.aspx

 

Laguna 3HP Cyclone 

http://www.lagunatools.com/accessories/dustcollectors/dustcollector-cyclone3m

Posted

If I had it to do over again I would never do another little cyclone. My 5hp unit has never been worth the money. If I was going to start over I'd buy the felder hang on the wall units. They are about $1350 for a two bag unit and pull 1800cfm and I think the 1800 is not an exaggerated number like most. My neighbor has one in his little shop and it easily outperforms my 5hp grizzly cyclone rated at about 2200cfm.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 53 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined