Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust collection - no questions this time though

Featured Replies

After weeks of research & shopping I've finally ordered my dust collection system.  It consists of a 5HP Oneida V-5000 cyclone collector with a MERV 16+ HEPA filter.  I'm running 8", 26 ga spiral duct to each outlet (6 total) & then reducing down to a 6" blast gate & flex to the machine.  All the elbows are long sweep spiral wound 26 ga as well.  I got all the duct & fittings locally for under $1000, (blast gates & flex not included) which I was pretty happy about.

 

Now I've got to get a soundproof machine room built in the basement to put it in, along with the compressor & central vac for the house.  It'll be good to get those out of the garage/shop.

 

Good times!

 

 

Frank

  Good grief!  With that system sucking all the dust, you could live a long while without lung problems.  Great tool for you and anyone.

==>elbows are long sweep spiral

Expensive, but very nice --- helps reduce SP loss far more than most realize...

 

==>Oneida V-5000 cyclone collector

Bet it's positioned as their CV-1800 killer -- Similar specs, push pricing, and a conductive polimer resin... Same goes down the V-line... Interesting to see what happens next...

 

==>with the compressor

Emptying bins is a very dusty operation... Is you compressor intake ported somewhere else?

  • Author

HHH: The compressor has a good filter on the intake. I hope to mitigate the dusty bin emplying by using bag liners.

 

There were a couple of things that were deciding factors for the Oneida over Clearvue. The filter is better than even CV's optional HEPA upgrade filter, particularly in the .5 - .3 micron area, and the CV is just too high for my basement machine room.  

 

The CV seems to be a great machine, but the only fan curve available for the CV is so ridiculously optimistic that I don't even know why they released it.  I think they shot themselves in the foot with that one.

 

The Oneida V line is pretty nice for a hobbyist like myself.  Compared with the SDG line, it's a few hundred dollars cheaper, quieter, shorter, has the same filter, and Oneida assures me that fines separation is comparable.  The buying experience with Oneida has been top notch.  Time will tell how much I like using it.  I'll do a bit of a review once I have everything set up.

  • Author

Richard: I recently hosted a family building project involving a lot of MDF (yuck) over a 3 day weekend.  It took 2 hours to vacuum a big garbage bag of MDF dust from the shop.  That was the last straw!

==>using bag liners
I use bag liners and it does help... How ‘dusty’ bin emptying gets depends on you most recent shop operations… If I’m surface and/or thickness planing, they’ll be nice big chips in the bin so emptying it is a pretty clean operation… However, if I’ve spent the afternoon sanding, then I put on a dust mask prior to opening the bin release – it can be an instant dust storm…

 

Don’t know if you purchased a bag hold-down, but you can go low or high-tech… Low-tech is inexpensive, simple, reliable – a plastic cylinder that keeps the bag pressed against the wall of the bin… The high-tech approach is a vacuum pump that’s hooked to the mag switch… There are pros/cons to each… The plastic insert will never break or fail to do its job. However, if you’ve spent the day sanding, pulling to cylinder out of the bin is a messy operation… The vacuum approach tends to be less messy, but pumps can fail…

 

 

==>Oneida V line is pretty nice for a hobbyist like myself
After your post, I spent some time on Oneida’s site – had never seen the V-line… It’s a direct shot across CV’s bow… The V-lines’ specs line-up almost one-for one (except the better filter) against CV’s offerings and price competitive (which has always been Oneida’s Achilles heel)… The fancurve is realistic and folks researching the CV-1800 should look at the V-5000 fan curve as a baseline for CV-1800’s performance…

 

Did you go for the stand or wall bracket? If you still haven’t received the unit, I’d push for the wall bracket… Depending on how tight your utility closet is, changing bags could be a pain with the floor stand…

 

Since the unit’s opaque, I’d get a bin sensor… Overflowing the bin is a real mess…

 

==>The compressor has a good filter

I’d recommend you shut-off the compressor when changing the bag… If you create a dust storm and the compressor happens to kick-on, that filter is going to get quickly clogged…

 

 

==>I think they shot themselves in the foot with that one

That’s always been CV's issue… It’s one thing to use a test methodology that 'helps' your numbers, but you’ve got to keep the specs within the realm of possibility to maintain any sense of credibility…

 

==>filter is better than even CV's optional HEPA upgrade filter

That’s always been Oneida’s strong suit… They’ve been pushing HEPA for the better part of a decade… I also spent some time on CV’s site and noticed they’ve scaled-back their filter claims rather dramatically… References to 0.3, HEPA, MERV 15+, etc have been largely purged from their site… That, along with the repeated references to ‘independent’ testing and certification… If I had to guess, I bet Wynn’s legal staff pointed-out that there’s no such thing as MERV 15+ and having the filter’s manufacturer certify filter performance isn’t quite ‘independent’. Although I did notice some rather creative prose around dust safety and the developemnt if HEPA/IEST certifications – it’s just amazing just how often you can mention a safety spec, describe how it was created, imply your product exceeds a part of the spec’s requirements, then fail to mention that you don’t actually meet the spec or have the certification… But that’s just another day in Marketing…

 

Looking forward to seeing a photo of that bad boy install... Good luck...

I would check with your insurance company before sealing up in a dedicated room. Check your policy to make sure there is no exclusion for installations by the homeowner that don't meet code. If you plan on running a larger drum sander this can easily become a real concern.

==>sealing up in a dedicated room

Thanks... I've been sitting here in the midst of a senior moment -- I know I forgot to mention something, but couldn't remember what it was...

 

In my shop, we have a room with noise insulation, but we hung thick solid wood loovered doors for airflow... Obviously, we could have reduced db with insulated doors, but entirely sealing the room didn't sit well... I haden't even thought of the insurance angle... That's a good catch...

I would check with your insurance company before sealing up in a dedicated room. Check your policy to make sure there is no exclusion for installations by the homeowner that don't meet code. If you plan on running a larger drum sander this can easily become a real concern.

 

Better yet, ask your agent or broker to do it for you.

==>sealing up in a dedicated room

Thanks... I've been sitting here in the midst of a senior moment -- I know I forgot to mention something, but couldn't remember what it was...

 

In my shop, we have a room with noise insulation, but we hung thick solid wood loovered doors for airflow... Obviously, we could have reduced db with insulated doors, but entirely sealing the room didn't sit well... I haden't even thought of the insurance angle... That's a good catch...

 

If you play by the rules fixed cyclones have to be mounted outside unless they are small portable units in hobby only shops. Obviously anything with duct work is fixed even if the unit is on wheels.

==>have to be mounted outside

I know about that one... I believe it's pretty clear that the dust bin (and I believe the seperator) have to reside outside for OSHA/Fire/Safety compliance, but can't the mechanicals be inside if you use an airlock? Not applicable for folks on WTO, but I have to believe that someday it'll become manditory in California :)

==>have to be mounted outside

I know about that one... I believe it's pretty clear that the dust bin (and I believe the seperator) have to reside outside for OSHA/Fire/Safety compliance, but can't the mechanicals be inside if you use an airlock? Not applicable for folks on WTO, but I have to believe that someday it'll become manditory in California :)

 

Its mandatory everywhere in the good ol USA, its falls under the same regulation as a homeowner central vacuum even for hobby folks. No the airlock is for the return air. If you return air back to the shop to keep the heat or AC from being exhausted. My homeowners covers the stupidity of a licensed contractor but does not cover my own. When I cancelled the business insurance on my home shop I had to show the paperwork for the cyclone install and inspection to the homeowner company to get coverage.

  • Author

HHH: Good point about shutting off the compressor.  I was going to go the low tech route for the bag hold down & see how that goes.  I got the floor stand cause I didn't want to transfer noise to the structure.  I did order the bin sensor and filter gauge.

 

PB: I will check with insurance & codes re the closed room.  I haven't built anything yet so now's the time to get things right.  Thanks for the heads up on that.

 

 

==>didn't want to transfer noise to the structure.

I use this stuff a lot -- compressor mount, refrigerated dryer, cyclone, and some other stuff that I forget -- if it vibrates, gets bolted to the floor or wall, then I use isolators: http://www.mcmaster.com/#standard-vibration-damping-pads/=v3dk5w.

 

I'm not exactly sure what comes with the V-systems, but you can also get a db killer for the exhaust port -- it's 'included' in the larger units, maybe in yours as well... If you want to go wild, you can get a silencer -- but those can get expensive...

 

BTW: To test your ductwork install, you also need something like: http://www.mcmaster.com/#smoke-pens/=v3dnrc

  • Author

Some research from the Alberta Fire Code 2006:
To paraphrase, if a system has a capacity of greater than .5 cu. meters/sec (1060 CFM) then the collector has to be outside unless it is in a room with a 1 hour fire rating & equipped with explosion venting to the outside.  This only applies to a building where dust is produced in sufficient quantities or concentration to create an explosion or fire hazard.

 

I believe I'll be OK here because:

1) Using Oneida's fan curves, I've calculated that airflow at the closest outlet is just under 1000 CFM (lots of fittings & duct to get from the room to the shop)

2) The planned room will have a 3 hour fire rating (4 layers of 5/8 drywall, steel studs, mineral wool insulation.

3) A home hobby shop is not generally considered to be a hazardous location.

 

So, worst case, I may have to install a vent to the outside.  My head hurts now, but I'm glad the issue was brought up so it will get dealt with.

  • Author

HHH: The floor stand has 4 legs & it looks like access to the drum will be good.

Regarding insurance, Put the onus on your insurance broker or agent to handle. His job to make representations regarding your coverage and his liability if his misrepresents/ fails to disclose as such.

==>have a 3 hour fire rating (4 layers of 5/8 drywall, steel studs, mineral wool insulation.

Wow... That's better than my finishes/solvents closet (two layers)... I do have a solid door on that, but its got a fairly low fire rating... I'm glad there's someone else who goes over-the-top on occasion...

 

I moved the solvents/finishes/chemicals to a separate closet to get the stuff from the machines... A long time ago, I had a bandsaw catch fire... It wasn't a big deal -- the fire extinguisher is right at the shop entrance. It was only after things got under control that I noticed the rack of solvents were only a foot or two from the bandsaw --- after that, I built a separate storage closet...

 

==>it looks like access to the drum will be good.

It's probably fine -- I just try to keep things off the floor...

Some research from the Alberta Fire Code 2006:

To paraphrase, if a system has a capacity of greater than .5 cu. meters/sec (1060 CFM) then the collector has to be outside unless it is in a room with a 1 hour fire rating & equipped with explosion venting to the outside.  This only applies to a building where dust is produced in sufficient quantities or concentration to create an explosion or fire hazard.

 

I believe I'll be OK here because:

1) Using Oneida's fan curves, I've calculated that airflow at the closest outlet is just under 1000 CFM (lots of fittings & duct to get from the room to the shop)

2) The planned room will have a 3 hour fire rating (4 layers of 5/8 drywall, steel studs, mineral wool insulation.

3) A home hobby shop is not generally considered to be a hazardous location.

 

So, worst case, I may have to install a vent to the outside.  My head hurts now, but I'm glad the issue was brought up so it will get dealt with.

 

Thats just fire code. Here you have mechanical code to go along with it. For example your connections have to be two gauges thicker than the straight pipe. There are wall clearances and sweeps have to be no less than 45 degrees. Its a who's on first sort of thing. Pick a code and that code may address three other codes that address the first code. Its just a mess.

  • Author

HHH: The over the top wall construction is really for sound isolation.

PB: Sifting through the HVAC code is the next job.  It was the fire code that I was most worried about.

HHH: The over the top wall construction is really for sound isolation.

PB: Sifting through the HVAC code is the next job.  It was the fire code that I was most worried about.

 

Here we would use product conveying.

==>HHH: The over the top wall construction is really for sound isolation.
I don't know about your setup, but my compressor generates quite a bit of heat... If the room is tightly-sealed, you may run into issues...

 

<edit>

Actually, the more I think about this, the more I think it could be an issue... I don't know how you use your compressor or how well sealed you want to make the room, but if I spend the afternoon using stationary sanders, my compressor generates a lot of heat -- especially if the dryer is running... Not saying it's going to be an issue for you, but something to keep in the back of your mind...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.