Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

How Do You Get Rid of Suckers?

Featured Replies

I've got a maple tree on our terrace that keeps shooting out suckers. I've tried trimmed em back to the trunk several times and they keep growin back. We have other maples and they don't do this. Any help would be appreciated.

When a mature tree sends out a ton of suckers it's usually a sign of stress or illness.  It's telling you that part of the tree is lacking vigor so it's trying to compensate by creating vigor somewhere else.  Aside from getting the tree back in good health, there's not much you can do aside from continuing to prune them off.

 

Was the tree improperly pruned recently? i.e...topped?  It's also possible the tree has root issues.  Poor soil or drainage?  Drought?  Nearby digging, etc?

  • Author

The tree hasn't been pruned. The city decided that we needed more trees and went around town and planted soft maples on the terraces in different neighborhoods.  It's been there for about 6-7 years. Probably wasn't planted properly. Since it's on city property I'm not supposed to touch it, but I can't stand the suckers so I go out when no ones around and cut them off. Thanks for the info. I guess if it dies I'll try and plant a decent tree before they get a chance too plant some other junk tree.

Does that advice go for relatives and friends as well? They too lack vigor and I've tried to prune them off!

Does that advice go for relatives and friends as well? They too lack vigor and I've tried to prune them off!

You have it backwards. They act as suckers if You lack vigor.

The tree hasn't been pruned. The city decided that we needed more trees and went around town and planted soft maples on the terraces in different neighborhoods.  It's been there for about 6-7 years. Probably wasn't planted properly. Since it's on city property I'm not supposed to touch it, but I can't stand the suckers so I go out when no ones around and cut them off. Thanks for the info. I guess if it dies I'll try and plant a decent tree before they get a chance too plant some other junk tree.

 

I'd do a little research on this, but a product like Preen might prevent new sprouts from shooting if you apply after you trim.   Also, in my town, the village will replace diseased parkway trees at no charge.  Since your village planted it, they might replace it.  If they don't deem it sick enough, I am sure you can find a way to speed up its demise.....

  • Author

I'd do a little research on this, but a product like Preen might prevent new sprouts from shooting if you apply after you trim.   Also, in my town, the village will replace diseased parkway trees at no charge.  Since your village planted it, they might replace it.  If they don't deem it sick enough, I am sure you can find a way to speed up its demise.....

If I were sure they would remove it after it died I would ring it and blame it on the squirrels. There's a black walnut across the street I've threatened to ring as well. Damn squirrels run around all fall planting walnuts and every one of them grows. Flower beds, gardens and even my wife's 1/2 whiskey barrels. I would love the lumber but it's such a scraggly tree I doubt it would yield anything worth wasting my time on. I'll try the Preen. Thanks 

Several things.

 

Preen is a pre-emergent weed controller--it stops seed germination.  Slightly different animal than sucker growth.

 

Products like "Sucker Stopper RTU" are more for what you're talking about.  You prune some sucker branches, and you want to keep them from regrowing, so you spray the cut areas with this solution.  It's basically a hormonal growth regulator that's suspended in a waxy vehicle to keep it where it's needed.  The problem is it's not 100% effective.  Soft maples that have issues will continue to pump out suckers.  Not as many after being sprayed, but it will still happen. You have to be willing to prune.

 

The city planted it 6-7 years ago you say.  Well, that was what 2008 or so?  That was before the financial meltdown when cities had, or thought they had, boatloads of cash. Things have probably changed in your city's budget. This translates into possible changes in "what will happen vs what would have happened".  Now, just to get it out of the way: if a 6-7 year old soft maple (probably a "silver maple") is really pumping out suckers, there's something wrong with the tree.  Just saying.

 

When a city has the budgetary means to be engaging in mass plantings, they also have funds for people to drive around and monitor the health of their trees.  If a tree dies, it gets replaced. If a tree is damaged--say by a lightening strike, or insects, or whatever, it gets pruned or replaced.  But, if the city is strapped for cash, these kinds of things fall way down on the priority list.

 

As far as the city owning the tree--yes they do.  And if they have the means, they'll protect the status quo, even if the status quo is counterproductive.  A case in point: me, and those before me.

 

I have a lot of experience with trees.  A few years before I bought my current house, there was a tree in the front yard that was struck by lightening, damaged considerably, and removed.  The city planted a red oak tree in place of what had been there.  The owners of the house at the time decided they'd swap the red oak in the front yard with a sweet gum they had growing in the side yard.  The city noticed the switch, and cited them and forced them to put things back where they were.

 

I bought the house shortly thereafter.  My issue was that this oak tree had lots of branches close to the ground--as in 3-8 feet off the ground.  This would end up being a problem as the branches grew, because of the shade to the underlying lawn, and the imposition of the sidewalk, which lots of neighborhood kids traversed on their way to school.  I waited for the city to trim these branches.  They didn't.  And I look at it like this:  the longer you let a branch grow, the bigger it gets in diameter at the trunk face.  And thus, the bigger the wound to the tree gets when you ultimately prune it.

 

So, I started pruning the tree. I continued to do so for 4-5 years.  One day, a city employee showed up, knocked on my door, and wanted to talk to me about "their" tree.  They had noticed that the tree had been pruned, and their records indicated that they weren't the pruners.  I admitted that I had been pruning the tree as it grew, in an effort to head off difficulties or unnecessary stresses.  He told me that I had no business doing what I had done and that I could have harmed the tree.  I said, okay, show me where I've harmed the tree.  He said that it appeared that I hadn't as yet, but intimated that it was just luck that I hadn't, and if I did harm the tree there would be fines and I would be responsible for the cost of replacement. 

 

That was years ago. Since that time I bought the property next door, which has an old hard maple on "city land", and said tree had lots of issues. I immediately after purchasing the property pruned a number of large branches out of said tree. LARGE BRANCHES.  I never heard a word about it.  I have continued pruning all of "my" trees--whether the city owns them or not, and I've never heard another word.  My trees are healthy and beautifully shaped, and they fit the spaces provided for them, and don't have branches in the way of street traffic, or sidewalk traffic, or power lines.

 

So, back to your situation.  You have to know your own limitations.  Are you confident that you know what you're doing?  If not, you shouldn't be doing it. What is your city's financial status--i.e. will you get caught?, or has the budget for tree inspections dried up?  Are your neighbors "tattle tales", or do they tend to mind their own business?

 

If the city is strapped for cash and the tree dies, it may take forever to get it replaced.  If you replace it yourself, without express and written city permission, they can AND WILL, ultimately notice it and they'll make you remove it--whatever it is--because they didn't plant it.  My neighbors, and the previous owners of my house ran into this truth. 

 

So, what I'm saying is, if you know what you're doing, and you therefore know that your actions will make the tree stronger, not weaker, and you have the experience, or knowledge, to be able to defend yourself,  then do it.  But you need to be able to legally defend yourself to the city.  If you're not sure, don't do it. You'll cost yourself money.  In which case, just make yourself a nuisance by calling the city on a regular basis, complaining about the health of their tree, and the problems you're facing as a result of their negligence.  And document your calls: when, who, what, etc.  It's amazing how complicated something simple can become, but it can, and it does, and it will.  Fix it if you can.  If you can't, make it painful for someone else.

 

 

Several things.

Preen is a pre-emergent weed controller--it stops seed germination. Slightly different animal than sucker growth.

Products like "Sucker Stopper RTU" are more for what you're talking about. You prune some sucker branches, and you want to keep them from regrowing, so you spray the cut areas with this solution. It's basically a hormonal growth regulator that's suspended in a waxy vehicle to keep it where it's needed. The problem is it's not 100% effective. Soft maples that have issues will continue to pump out suckers. Not as many after being sprayed, but it will still happen. You have to be willing to prune.

The city planted it 6-7 years ago you say. Well, that was what 2008 or so? That was before the financial meltdown when cities had, or thought they had, boatloads of cash. Things have probably changed in your city's budget. This translates into possible changes in "what will happen vs what would have happened". Now, just to get it out of the way: if a 6-7 year old soft maple (probably a "silver maple") is really pumping out suckers, there's something wrong with the tree. Just saying.

When a city has the budgetary means to be engaging in mass plantings, they also have funds for people to drive around and monitor the health of their trees. If a tree dies, it gets replaced. If a tree is damaged--say by a lightening strike, or insects, or whatever, it gets pruned or replaced. But, if the city is strapped for cash, these kinds of things fall way down on the priority list.

As far as the city owning the tree--yes they do. And if they have the means, they'll protect the status quo, even if the status quo is counterproductive. A case in point: me, and those before me.

I have a lot of experience with trees. A few years before I bought my current house, there was a tree in the front yard that was struck by lightening, damaged considerably, and removed. The city planted a red oak tree in place of what had been there. The owners of the house at the time decided they'd swap the red oak in the front yard with a sweet gum they had growing in the side yard. The city noticed the switch, and cited them and forced them to put things back where they were.

I bought the house shortly thereafter. My issue was that this oak tree had lots of branches close to the ground--as in 3-8 feet off the ground. This would end up being a problem as the branches grew, because of the shade to the underlying lawn, and the imposition of the sidewalk, which lots of neighborhood kids traversed on their way to school. I waited for the city to trim these branches. They didn't. And I look at it like this: the longer you let a branch grow, the bigger it gets in diameter at the trunk face. And thus, the bigger the wound to the tree gets when you ultimately prune it.

So, I started pruning the tree. I continued to do so for 4-5 years. One day, a city employee showed up, knocked on my door, and wanted to talk to me about "their" tree. They had noticed that the tree had been pruned, and their records indicated that they weren't the pruners. I admitted that I had been pruning the tree as it grew, in an effort to head off difficulties or unnecessary stresses. He told me that I had no business doing what I had done and that I could have harmed the tree. I said, okay, show me where I've harmed the tree. He said that it appeared that I hadn't as yet, but intimated that it was just luck that I hadn't, and if I did harm the tree there would be fines and I would be responsible for the cost of replacement.

That was years ago. Since that time I bought the property next door, which has an old hard maple on "city land", and said tree had lots of issues. I immediately after purchasing the property pruned a number of large branches out of said tree. LARGE BRANCHES. I never heard a word about it. I have continued pruning all of "my" trees--whether the city owns them or not, and I've never heard another word. My trees are healthy and beautifully shaped, and they fit the spaces provided for them, and don't have branches in the way of street traffic, or sidewalk traffic, or power lines.

So, back to your situation. You have to know your own limitations. Are you confident that you know what you're doing? If not, you shouldn't be doing it. What is your city's financial status--i.e. will you get caught?, or has the budget for tree inspections dried up? Are your neighbors "tattle tales", or do they tend to mind their own business?

If the city is strapped for cash and the tree dies, it may take forever to get it replaced. If you replace it yourself, without express and written city permission, they can AND WILL, ultimately notice it and they'll make you remove it--whatever it is--because they didn't plant it. My neighbors, and the previous owners of my house ran into this truth.

So, what I'm saying is, if you know what you're doing, and you therefore know that your actions will make the tree stronger, not weaker, and you have the experience, or knowledge, to be able to defend yourself, then do it. But you need to be able to legally defend yourself to the city. If you're not sure, don't do it. You'll cost yourself money. In which case, just make yourself a nuisance by calling the city on a regular basis, complaining about the health of their tree, and the problems you're facing as a result of their negligence. And document your calls: when, who, what, etc. It's amazing how complicated something simple can become, but it can, and it does, and it will. Fix it if you can. If you can't, make it painful for someone else.

ah the joys of the goverment bureaucracy!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.