ottacat Posted October 30, 2015 Report Posted October 30, 2015 I've been reading the few threads lately regarding both the 'essential' FT tools as well as Mark's decisions to lighten his FT collection. In both cases I keep seeing the 150/3 or 150/5 being included.My question is what differentiates these sanders from more basic sanders such as ones from Rigid, DeWalt, Bosch and Porter-Cable? I personally have a Rigid connected to a CT-36 (I own a Domino) and it seems to do the job just fine. I use it pretty much exclusively for removing milling marks and prepping my projects for finishing.Is there something fundamental that I'm missing here? Can someone point out an objective reason why the FT ROS are better? Do they do the job faster?Do they leave a smoother finish?Are they more reliable?Dust collection - my Rigid connected to my CT-36 seems to leave no visible dust and my sanding disks last a long time - are the FT even better? (If so, how?)Are they smoother / more easily controlled? (if I just hold the DC hose of my Rigid, it still smoothly sands the wood without jumping or vibrating)Are they quieter?Do they have some accessories that I can't get for my Rigid?I am a hobby woodworker and probably put 10 hours a month on my sander. It has a lifetime warranty, the FT has a 3-year warranty. My Rigid cost me $99 CDN and the FT costs $450 CDN. So to me my current Rigid seems fine but I haven't tried a FT so I am genuinely curious. Quote
bgreenb Posted October 30, 2015 Report Posted October 30, 2015 Like Mike, I can't compared directly with the Ridgid. But I had a Bosch 6" ROS, pretty much the top of the line Bosch, which would be more directly comparable with the 150/5 (which I have now). The difference is night and day.The dust collection on the 150/5 with CT is markedly better than the Bosch with CT. Again, I have no experience with the Ridgid, but I would be shocked if the dust collection were as good, since part of the dust collection advantage of FT tools is that the tools themselves are optimized for dust collection (hole pattern that Mike mentioned being one example).Other than DC, the ergonomics and vibration are much better on the FT - ergonomics especially isn't even close. I also get a smoother finish more quickly with the FT - can't explain why, maybe it has to do with the stroke, but it's noticeable. Like I said, it's truly night and day. And if you're comparing a 5" model, it's going to be an even bigger difference.As a wise man named Eric. once said,"Sanding makes me want to quit woodworking. I will pay up for anything that makes sanding less miserable." 1 Quote
Pwk5017 Posted October 30, 2015 Report Posted October 30, 2015 I probably don't have the credentials to back this up, but my own empirical observations owning a 5" big box bosch and the 150/5:6" feels twice as large. I think the math works out to be 44% larger surface area?More surface area and power make it much faster through the grits than the bosch.I don't know the difference between strokes, because I haven't used the 150/3. Ive always been told to get the RO150 and the 150/3, or just get the 150/5 for the "cheap" alternative. Not as aggressive as the rotex, not as smooth as the 150/3, but a good all around sander. I rarely go above 220/320 anywaysI bought my 150/5 very gently used for $180-200ish. So far it is well worth that price for the 6-8 months I have owned it. I use my sander 2-3 hours a week. Quote
rodger. Posted October 30, 2015 Report Posted October 30, 2015 I did a review of the 150/3 a while ago. Check it out in the reviews section. Quote
BuilderBill Posted October 31, 2015 Report Posted October 31, 2015 Forget the Festool sanders, get a Mirka Ceros. Or a 3M or Mirka air sander and a monster compressor to run it. There is a difference and the big-box sanders don't come close in handling or performance. Even the Green ones. It's well worth the money.Yes Virginia, there is a Santa Clause and he'll bring you a yellow systainer if you've been really, really good. 1 Quote
Trip Posted October 31, 2015 Report Posted October 31, 2015 The 150/3's a nice inter-coat finish sander... The 150/5 is a decent mid-grit... The real advantage of the Mirka, 3M, etc are power, low-profile, ergonomics and efficiency. I'd be interested to try the new generation of FT sanders -- you may get more power, lower profile and longevity with the new format... If I were to have just one FT sander, it'd be the 150/3. The only real disadvantage to the pneumatics is the noise... Quote
ottacat Posted October 31, 2015 Author Report Posted October 31, 2015 I appreciate all the feedback, especially from those who had basic sanders and upgraded to the Festool line.Earlier this evening I decided the only way to know was to try one so I went to Lee Valley and picked up the new ETS EC 150/5. I gave it a bit of a go this evening and was quite impressed. I much prefer the physical format of the EC line as I prefer the lower profile.The sander indeed was much faster, smoother and quieter as others have said.I must say I still find the 150/5 vs. 150/3 debate to be confusing. I was more than satisfied with final finish after sanding to 220 grit. Does FT intend people to buy both or are there significant differences of which I'm not yet aware?The other confusing thing is all the sandpaper types FT offers - which ones do you all mostly use? Quote
Trip Posted October 31, 2015 Report Posted October 31, 2015 ==>^^^/5 = medium stroke = 5mm = mid-coat sanding/3 = fine stroke = 3mm = inter-coat sanding.5mm from around 100 to around 220;3mm from 180 and up. Quote
Eric. Posted October 31, 2015 Report Posted October 31, 2015 Trip will probably come along after this and contradict me...and he will surely be right and have facts and anecdotes and experience to back him up, but...I use my /5 to sand up to 320 grit with fine results. If I were to come along afterward and hit that same surface with the /3 with 320 grit, I would NOT be able to see any difference. And I have 20/20 vision. Same would be true for 220.I recently sold my /3 and I will not miss it. I don't power sand finishes though...if you do, you'll have different needs. Quote
Trip Posted October 31, 2015 Report Posted October 31, 2015 (edited) You CAN use a 5mm to 320, I do it all the time with the Mirka (but it's a lot smoother than FT's 5mm)... Of course, who's 320 (Abranet runs about one grade different from FT's paper). But 320's not within FT's guidance for the 5mm... BTW: the break point for the Mirka is 320/400 Abranet, which is about 280/320 FT paper. When I used the FT 5mm, I couldn't use it much past 220... I always got better results above 220 with the FT 3mm (which is what FT recommends)... Since you got equivalent results with the /3 and /5, I'd suspect one of two things: you have a singular specimen of the FT 5mm or you had a poor example of the 3mm... I wouldn't expect all builds of FT 5mm sanders to perform well at 320 and up... If you follow FT's guidance, the break point is 180-220. Edited October 31, 2015 by hhh Quote
rodger. Posted October 31, 2015 Report Posted October 31, 2015 I do the opposite as Eric and I get great results as well. I use a /3 for 120 grit up to 220. Quote
Trip Posted October 31, 2015 Report Posted October 31, 2015 ==>^^^You can certainly use a fine stroke sander for mid-sanding -- it will work just fine, but it'll just take a bit longer to remove the same amount of stock... Lot's of folks have just the 150/3 -- no problems...But keep in mind, mfg's make 8mm, 5mm and 3mm sanders for a reason: 8mm stroke removes stock quickly and is optimized for construction sanding (around 40/60-100/120). 3mm is a finish sander, say 180/220 and up... 5mm is the in-between case --- a mid-grit sander, say 80/120 - 180/220. Sort of like Jack, Smoother and Jointer planes -- optimized for different applications...There is certainly overlap in the ranges and you can use a sander optimized for one application to execute another -- and it'll work... But it won't work as well as the sander designed for that application... Unfortunately, to really see this in action you need the same sander in all three strokes... FT doesn't make an 8mm sander, so you need to look at Mirka, 3M, Dynabrade, etc (i.e. professional kit aimed for the automotive industry).If you line all three up with the same papers, you'll quickly see the difference. The 3mm can certainly use 40g to remove stock, but it'll do that rather slowly compared to the 8mm... The 8mm can use 320 for inter-coat, but you risk sand-through when compared to a 3mm and you have to have far better technique to avoid swirls... The 5mm sanders are a kind of an 'in-between' case...Just like their are very experienced craftsman who can use a 5 1/4 plane for everything, you can use a 5mm sander for everything -- but you need excellent technique... For the rest of us, you need more than one sander to cover the range of applications... How you do that is up to you... Quote
Strasberry Posted October 31, 2015 Report Posted October 31, 2015 Forget the Festool sanders, get a Mirka Ceros. Or a 3M or Mirka air sander and a monster compressor to run it. There is a difference and the big-box sanders don't come close in handling or performance. Even the Green ones. It's well worth the money.Yes Virginia, there is a Santa Clause and he'll bring you a yellow systainer if you've been really, really good. I'm with Bill! I'll stick with my air sander! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.