TerryMcK Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 I like the shape of F but with the Shoji doors E. Leave it open in the centre for equipment and it will look fantastic in a dark wood. Quote
Trip Posted December 29, 2015 Author Report Posted December 29, 2015 ==>I'm pumped to see a Trip journal. Not sure how much of a 'journal' it's going to be -- it's a pretty straight-forward build and there would be no point in covering the also-ran stuff... The only unique points will be removable real panels (access to connections), internal airflow (low-noise German fans), laminated aprons (weight) and maybe Shoji doors (just because I've always wanted to do some). I'll post something on those... Note: I know some like the through joinery. The aprons will be Cherry lams, so unless I go faux through-tenons, there won't be an opportunity for exposed joinery... I've promised someone to cover airbrushing sap in Cherry, so I'll post something on that... Although I've pulled the stock for the build and there appears to be no sap in the lot... If there's no sap in the build, I'll find a stick with some sap and demo on that... 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 Trip, for legs and aprons, I like A, but the rest of the design will surely influence those choices. Quote
Guest Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 A, E and F are my favorites. C&D seem like fake, soul patch Steven Seagal asian to me. Like what a white guy comes up with when he wants to do Asian. Or what an Asian guy does when he wants to sell to white people. (my wife is Korean so I can say stuff like that. She would call it a Banana - yellow on the outside, white in the middle). Overall I like F the most, but on F the top muntin/lead should be moved down to conceal the top shelf. I think they teach that in Design 201. Quote
wareaglewoodworker Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 I like D the best with F coming in a close second. One thing to keep in mind. AV components will need some air movement to keep cool. Quote
shaneymack Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 Note: I know some like the through joinery. The aprons will be Cherry lams, so unless I go faux through-tenons, there won't be an opportunity for exposed joinery... Trip you could still do through tenons with a lamination if you glue a piece of solid stock to the ends and then cover it all with your last lamination so you don't see the joint. Check out the latest issue of Fine Woodworking #252. The article by Stewart Wurtz entitled," Solid Method for Curved Drawers." Seems like a great method to cut joinery on the ends of laminations. Sent from my SGH-I337M using Tapatalk Quote
Trip Posted December 29, 2015 Author Report Posted December 29, 2015 ==>the rest of the design will surely influence those choices. Got that -- one of the weaknesses of my crowdsourcing strategy... After selecting the leg and lower apron, I'll bake those in and build from there on doors, shoji, top, accents, etc... Of course, the better half always has veto power So I may come back with a design that's not been presented at all... As we move through the design, I'll start building in sketchup and post updated drawings as design elements solidify... It's kind of interesting to read through the responses so far -- there are certainly design clusters... It's making this an interesting exercise... ==>AV components will need some air movement to keep cool. Yea, The shelves will have inlet high-quality silent-running fans with honeycombing to facilitate circulation -- that's part of the design decisions that have already been made and 'baked-in'... It's one reason I'm considering keeping the central bay 'open' -- I've got some fairly hefty amps that throw serious heat... ==>Solid Method for Curved Drawers Read that... It's interesting and would work well for drawers, but less so for exposed joinery -- you've got to chamfer through-tenons. ==>I like the little "heavier" look given the fact that is going to be over 7ft long There quite some truth to that... And the crux of my design indecision is over the legs... We've got a sideboard [Thomas Moser] with excellent proportions and was planning to copy the leg dimensions from that... Obviously, it's not a small piece, but I'm trying to avoid the 'heavy' look -- that's why I'm going lam on the aprons... Here's the piece I pulled the initial dimensions: My other inclination is to make a design 'statement' with legs like D, E or F... I kind of like F, but worried that I may grow to 'un-love' it, then I'm stuck... ==>Leave it open in the centre for equipment and it will look fantastic in a dark wood. I would leave it all open (as in the equipment rack [Thomas Moser] in my man-cave), but this is a public space in a female-occupied (read as dominated) home -- so I can't push the 'gear look'... All the other furniture in the target room is Thomas Moser executed in Cherry, so a toned-down 'A' would 'fit' the best, but don't want it to fit-in too much... The sideboard pictured above converted to equipment bays would 'fit' the rest of the set, but I'm not sure I want everything to look like a 'set' if you know what I mean -- hence the crowdsourcing... ==>on F the top muntin/lead should be moved down to conceal the top shelf. I think they teach that in Design 201. I suspect the upper shelf's adjustable, hence the faux pas... One of the dangers of combining adjustable shelves and glass doors... One of the reasons I'm looking at Shoji... I plan for the uppers shelves to be adjustable in my final design. OK, let me admit my preferences: the gentle arched lower apron from A or F... But the busy grain pattern in A's apron is too distracting -- I'd go straight-grained... As for leg shape, C is the only one I don't really like... I'm rather taken with the leg/apron combination in F, but worried that I may grow to not like it... I'm rather taken with the Shoji doors on knife hinges in E, but not those pulls. I've ordered a couple books on Shoji, so we'll see how that goes... Quote
shaneymack Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 24 minutes ago, hhh said: ==>Solid Method for Curved Drawers Read that... It's interesting and would work well for drawers, but less so for exposed joinery -- you've got to chamfer through-tenons. So if you cut your tenon out of solid stock that you have glued to the ends, what is the problem with chamfering it? Quote
bgreenb Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 36 minutes ago, hhh said: ==>I like the little "heavier" look given the fact that is going to be over 7ft long There quite some truth to that... And the crux of my design indecision over the legs... We've got a sideboard [Thomas Moser] with excellent proportions and was planning to copy the leg dimensions from that... Obviously, it's not a small piece, but I'm trying to avoid the 'heavy' look -- that's why I'm going lam on the aprons... I'm sure I'm missing something obvious, but can you please explain the decision to go with laminations and what that has to do with weight? Quote
Guest Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 Shoji doors on F would be a big improvement. Personally I don't like the arched doors on F much, I think it is too much with the legs and apron. straight lines on Shoji with the long overhang of the top would be sweet. Quote
shaneymack Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 2 minutes ago, bgreenb said: I'm sure I'm missing something obvious, but can you please explain the decision to go with laminations and what that has to do with weight? I think he wants to make the aprons as small as possible and a lamination will be stronger than a thin solid apron. Quote
bgreenb Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 15 minutes ago, shaneymack said: So if you cut your tenon out of solid stock that you have glued to the ends, what is the problem with chamfering it? Because using the method outlined in the magazine, the end of the board isn't solid - it consists of a sandwich of the end block plus the two veneers glued to the front and back. It's not that noticeable in a drawer because you only really ever see the reveal on the pinboard, but if you were looking at the whole thing chamfered, it would be obvious unless you were very very careful with grain matching. Quote
shaneymack Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 4 minutes ago, bgreenb said: Because using the method outlined in the magazine, the end of the board isn't solid - it consists of a sandwich of the end block plus the two veneers glued to the front and back. It's not that noticeable in a drawer because you only really ever see the reveal on the pinboard, but if you were looking at the whole thing chamfered, it would be obvious unless you were very very careful with grain matching. If the veneers are from the same board as the solid end pieces and it is a small chamfer i dont think it would be noticeable. I could be picturing it all wrong on my head though, but i cant see it being a problem. Quote
Trip Posted December 29, 2015 Author Report Posted December 29, 2015 ==>laminations and what that has to do with weight? Lams are much stronger than solid wood for a given size... I've got some heavy gear... So I could make really beefy aprons (which would look strange), or get the same strength in a much smaller size by going lam... ==>unless you were very very careful with grain matching exactly.. that plus the glue line... ==>cant see it being a problem The decision is just an experience thing... Trust me, you'd never get it to align to pass even cursory scrutiny... that plus the glue line... 1 Quote
bgreenb Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 7 minutes ago, hhh said: ==>laminations and what that has to do with weight? Lams are much stronger than solid wood for a given size... I've got some heavy gear... So I could make really beefy aprons (which would look strange), or get the same strength in a much smaller size by going lam... Ahh, of course. Just like in framing. So you just laminate a few layers of 1/8? 3/32? Do you just take a solid piece, slice it into veneers, and then glue it all back together again? Is there a rule of thumb for thickness of each lam? Quote
Trip Posted December 29, 2015 Author Report Posted December 29, 2015 ==>solid piece, slice it into veneers, and then glue it all back together again? Bingo! Resaw a 5/4 stick into 3/16 strips, drum sand them to final thickness, UF adhesive and vacuum press it back together... final mill to size... ==>Is there a rule of thumb for thickness of each lam? depends on species and bending radius... No bending here, so I'll shoot for 3/16"... 1 Quote
bgreenb Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 I know you've said you don't wanna do a journal, but man would I (and, I'm sure, others) appreciate it. Even just a few pics of each major step in the build. Reason being that your workflow is so foreign to mine (and I bet most of the other hobbyists here) it would be interesting to see. Consider it another gentle request Even if not - I still look forward to the airbrushing tutorial. Quote
Trip Posted December 29, 2015 Author Report Posted December 29, 2015 Ahhh. You're the airbrush request... Got it... ==>your workflow is so foreign to mine Don't be so sure... It's not like I'm bringing a gun to a knife fight -- I'm bringing a machete.. The workflow itself will likely be 99% identical, just my toys may be a bit bigger, heavier and 3p... A jointer is a jointer, a planer a planer and a #4 is a #4... Now if Wilbur was building this, you see some different tools... And of course, if Don were doing it, you'd see shaper-based everything -- well maybe not shaper-based finishing, but I bet's he's working on it... But point taken -- I'll post a pic or two on the more unusual items -- I suspect the cabinet airflow may be the most interesting item -- most other things will be M/T (just with lams), shelving (just with integral fans) and Shoji (actually, I've got to stop saying that -- or I'll end-up taking myself into something that I may not want to do)... 1 Quote
Dknapp34 Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 2 hours ago, hhh said: OK, let me admit my preferences: the gentle arched lower apron from A or F... But the busy grain pattern in A's apron is too distracting -- I'd go straight-grained... As for leg shape, C is the only one I don't really like... I'm rather taken with the leg/apron combination in F, but worried that I may grow to not like it... I'm rather taken with the Shoji doors on knife hinges in E, but not those pulls. I've ordered a couple books on Shoji, so we'll see how that goes... I agree with your preference for the legs. I'm not a big fan of heavy looking legs, so I don't like the ones that taper out towards the bottom. I really like the idea of shoji screens, but mostly because I want to read you post about making them. If you do the shoji screens, I would stay away from too many other asian elements, as it's easy to go overboard with stuff like that. I also agree on straight grain for the aprons; especially if you are doing shoji screens, because those are going to be the focal point. Quote
Trip Posted December 30, 2015 Author Report Posted December 30, 2015 I haven't tallied the responses yet -- I'll do that today and report back... However, the Designer in Chief (aka SWMBO) has issued several proclamations (I mean guidance... yea, that's it): First: curved lower apron as seen in A, C, D, F. Second: curved or flared legs as seen in D, E, F... She would normally select straight legs, but want's flared to offset this piece from the pieces already in place -- i.e. she wants something that looks 'different'. Not radically different, just different. So I suspect F maybe out... We'll see... Third: the boss likes the shoji doors -- she wants the gear 'hidden'... However, she is sensitive to the heat issue and may permit the central bay to be open shelving... but we are getting ahead of ourselves... Worst case, she can open the doors when the system is in use... ==>I really like the idea of shoji screens, but mostly because I want to read you post about making them Hummmmm. It looks like you may get your wish... Quote
Popular Post Trip Posted January 12, 2016 Author Popular Post Report Posted January 12, 2016 I’ve tallied the responses, incorporated input from SWAMBO and accounted for some critical dimensions on equipment sizing, center channel height and monitor positioning... There are response clusters around three basic looks: Shaker – straight legs w/ small taper and straight lower rail Moser -- straight legs w/ curved apron Curved - flared legs w/ curved apron Several like the shoji, but I get the feeling that it has as much to do with aesthetics as having someone do a project, then pick their brains... SWAMBO prefers the Shaker look, but wants a Curved piece to break up the monotony... As stated above, she likes the shoji, so it looks as if some of you are going to get your way... The Shoji is in... And the Shaker/Moser is out... That leaves us with something along the lines of D, E or F. E is better suited for a smaller case piece... So we have something closer to D or F... D. F. Adding some room and gear constraints means we are looking at something closer to F or finding a way to get D a bit closer to the ground without killing the look... The height issue is driven by the center channel... Unfortunately, it's around 13" tall without stand... That limits the total case height to 32" or so... So the D case as it's drawn would be too high... So, we've got flared legs, curved lower rail and shoji doors... I'm not going to flare the legs too much -- I suspect it would be too much of a good thing... Maybe like F, but not quite as much swoop... I suspect I'll prototype it... Let me layer-on a few other details that have been fixed by physical constraints (subject to some change): 66l, 32h, 20d (case dimensions), legs/top extra Three equipment bays, center bay sans door, left & right bays with shoji doors. So imagine D and F with black amplifiers instead of drawers, the shoji doors of E and all in Cherry... Solid Cherry throughout, some Ebony accents, not much... Post and Panel case construction (last project was solid-wood case, so want something different this time). High equipment weight precludes frame and panel... So that decision is made... Rear panels to be removable and incorporate access for cabling and ventilation -- there may be a poll on how to accomplish that little trick... Bottom shelf hidden by front rail. Take a look at the lower shelf on D and compare to F to see what I'm getting at... It adds a good deal of build complexity, but increases case rigidity... Three shelves (including bottom) per bay... Total of nine equipment bays and nine shelves (including bottom shelves)... All shelves incorporate 12"x12" honeycomb grid (centered) for ventilation. All joinery pinned (just something I always do) -- one of our future polls will be which pins in Ebony and which in Cherry... Next step will be a little Sketchup and try the updated ray tracing function in SU2016... I'll post an updated model along with our next poll... On the physical front, I've sorted the stock... Looking good... I've got to prototype the shelving grid and develop a reasonable workflow... 3 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.