Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Tuning an old plane- and I suck at it

Featured Replies

So in my vast woodworking experience of oh...2 years or so...my hand tool usage has basically consisted of using a chisel for removing glue squeeze out and squaring rounded rabbets inside frames.  I intend on learning to incorporate hand tools much more.

I bought old (or I think they're old...) Stanley #4 and a Stanley block planes from FleaBay.  Both in really decent condition as is, but the soles needed flattened and each blade had a small chip.

Using sandpaper ranging from 220-1500 grits adhered to a thick piece of scrap lexan (I had some on hand, no glass or granite, which I know would be ideal) I went to work.  Youtube makes it look easy.  Youtube is sometimes a liar.  I've spent a good couple hours I think on the #4 alone.  The chip in the blade is just about out but I can't see any change in the sole at all.  The blade sharpness is...ok...but nothing to write home about.  I know 1500 isn't fine enough, but I thought it'd be close enough to learn on.  I was using a honing guide.

I gave up and put it back together.  Or tried.  For some reason I'm getting something, between the frog, blade and breaker, aligned wrong...the blade seems to be too far up in the throat of the body.  It cuts like crap, mainly because shavings are getting jammed in the too narrow throat opening.  It cut better before I touched it.

I'm strongly considering a Worksharp 3000 to solve the sharpening problem, but that won't help the sole flatness.

I've also considered getting rid of the old planes and getting new Sweetheart planes...(I simply can't justify Lie Nielsens)  The mid-priced new Sweethearts can't be that bad, especially for a bonehead like me, right?

Any thoughts? 

 

 

re: the clogging

Have you adjusted the mouth to open it up?

re: sharpening the blade

Have you watched any sharpening videos?  Assuming you started with the 220 did you feel a burr on the opposite side before moving on?

  • Author
5 minutes ago, sjk said:

re: the clogging

Have you adjusted the mouth to open it up?

re: sharpening the blade

Have you watched any sharpening videos?  Assuming you started with the 220 did you feel a burr on the opposite side before moving on?

It seems to me like the blade is coming out of the mouth in the wrong position...too far forward, and that is creating the narrow portion in the mouth.  If that is how the mouth is adjusted, I haven't figured out where the adjustment is.

I watched several sharpening videos.  I was removing the burr and was using a sharpee to show progress...realistically the sharpening was coming along OK, just way slower than it should have, and I realized while doing it that it was the most miserable thing I could possibly do in the shop, lol.

Can you post some close-up pictures of how the blade is sitting?

Your first sharpening on an old blade can take a while (to establish the bevel you're aiming for).  You'll spend a bunch of time at your coarse grit.  Once you've got that bevel angle, it shouldn't take too much time to move up through the grits, since all you have to do is remove the scratch pattern from the previous grit.  Each time you want to feel a new burr - that's how you know that you're actually reaching the edge.

1500 should be a fine serviceable edge.  You can get by with even lower grits.  It's all about getting to that burr.  Higher grits will give you a more refined edge, but you should still be able to make nice shavings at 1500.

After you've gotten the blade sharp, when it's time to resharpen you won't start at the coarse grit.  (unless you've nicked the blade or otherwise need to fix/change the bevel).  You'll just use your high grit to hone things.

For example - I use DMT diamond stones and a strop, and establishing a new bevel on an ebay find can take 5-10 minutes.  Then moving up through my finer grits can take another few minutes.  Resharpening is just 5-10 strokes on my 8000 stone and then 10-20 strokes on my strop.  A light resharpening (like in the middle of chopping dovetails) is just a few strokes on my strop.

2 hours ago, bleedinblue said:

It seems to me like the blade is coming out of the mouth in the wrong position...too far forward, and that is creating the narrow portion in the mouth.  If that is how the mouth is adjusted, I haven't figured out where the adjustment is.

I watched several sharpening videos.  I was removing the burr and was using a sharpee to show progress...realistically the sharpening was coming along OK, just way slower than it should have, and I realized while doing it that it was the most miserable thing I could possibly do in the shop, lol.

Sounds simple enough... The frog needs to slide toward the back of the plane to open the mouth.. It's a matter of touch.  It takes time to get the adjustment correct.  You may have to adjust the frog several times till it's where you need it. then it'll work better!  Check out Paul Sellers.com he has several videos on sharpening and tuning a plane!

Even new Sweethearts have problems. Persevere with the old ones first. I can also vouch for Paul Sellers tuning videos, Chris Schwarz articles or our own Graham's video as posted by Carus below -VV-.

When flattening a plane I use 80 grit on a granite slab. Gradually working up to 320. I think your Lexan sheet might not be as flat as it could be as it is acrylic (unless it's cast acrylic over 1" thick). We used to use Alcoa cast aluminium alloy tooling plate in our engineering toolrooms and that is flat as granite.

If you have a kitchen counter top manufacturer in the vicinity you may be able to get a 12" square offcut. I have also seen 5/8" thick granite tiles in home centres so try there too.

You don't really need to flatten the sole on a block plane as it isn't a finish plane. Just a few passes on granite to remove any rust or pitting is ok.

Edited by TerryMcK
Added Carus' link to Grahams video

Have to ignore this guy's dreadful accent? Depending on the plane, you may not have the third screw he addresses. Then some careful taps with a brass tack hammer or trial and error can work.

Cast sole flatten easily unless they are flawed, so like Terry I question the Lexan. It is also important to note that a well set up shop would use a grinder or maybe even a file to get rid of a chip going to honing after a clean bevel is established  

 

Would flatten your soul I usually start at 60 or 80 grit that takes off everything you need and then advance to higher grits to smooth the soul. For the problem of the mouth thing too small that means that the frog needs to be slid back there are two screws underneath and iron that can be loosened allowing the frog to slide back. Learning how to tune a plane is not something that can be done once it takes doing it over and over and over again to really learn how to do well

  • Author

I'll get some pictures tonight after work.  That video helps a lot though, the plane is identical.

As far as flattening the sole, I wasn't being nearly aggressive enough apparently.  I don't think I went any courser than 220 before I got frustrated.  I'll work on sourcing some granite, too.

 

  • Author

No real need to upload pictures, that video cleared up real quick how to adjust the throat.  Thanks!

I also just found and thought this article to be quite helpful.  I think the plane is real close, the only problem as far as the adjustment/assembly I can tell right now is that even when the depth is backed out all the way, the blade still seems to be coming out just a veeeery tiny bit.  Only enough to be an issue if I take another shot at flattening the sole...but after reading that article I may not even bother.  It's very close to flat, afterall.

The chip breaker and the iron aren't mating up perfectly, the bevel angles are different and the gap between them is certainly enough for chips to get jammed up.  I'll fix that when I take another shot at sharpening the blade tomorrow.

Thanks for the tips guys.

With regard to the iron not retracting through the sole...

If we are still talking about the number four, the depth of cut is registered in the cap iron/chipbreaker. If the cap and iron are original to the plane, you likely have the cap set too far from the cutting edge. I am rushing for school right now-YouTube is a good friend. 

If you are talking about a block plane, they often have multiple notches on the back. When a setup is new to me, I will run the adjustment all the way deep and then set the iron on so that it is as close to the heaviest cut I would imagine as possible. Usually this puts all the extra motion at the back rather than the front. 

On 1/11/2016 at 0:39 AM, bleedinblue said:

The chip breaker and the iron aren't mating up perfectly, the bevel angles are different and the gap between them is certainly enough for chips to get jammed up.  I'll fix that when I take another shot at sharpening the blade tomorrow.

 

I think a picture would help here, because its hard to tell what the issue is from your description. This article gives some good info on setting up a chipbreaker.

In regards to sole flattening - I would leave it alone for now. Get the blade, chip breaker and frog set up so you can take some shavings, then see if the sole is an issue at all.

 

 

 

Why does it feel like, you've neglected the frog in these adjustments.

  • Author

I was definitely neglecting the frog.  That adjustment screw?  I didn't know it was an adjustment screw and had cranked it tight.  Ooooops!  All is well now.  I'm going to give the iron some more attention, it can be sharper, but I'm certainly more comfortable with how the plane functions now.

Bleed:  I've tuned literally dozens and dozens of bench planes, so without sounding like my ego is bigger than the internet, let me tell you a few things that will improve the performance of the plane.

First, it seems you had a frog adjustment issue you worked out.  However, do this:  where the frog adjustment screw mates with the frog there is that little "U" shaped clip screwed to the frog.  Loosen up the screw holding the U clip and the two frog screws, align the front of the frog about 1/8" away from the sole's mouth so that it is even, then carefully tighten down the frog screws firmly, not overly tight, then tighten the screw of the U clip.  Now you have proper alignment of the frog.

Next, take off the chipbreaker, and file the mating portion (pay attention to the mating angle) of the breaker so it is flat, testing it against the iron so that no light shows between the breaker and the back of the iron; remember, the angle is important as the breaker has to mate such that the front of the breaker is flush with the back of the iron.  Then adjust the breaker such that it is no more than 1/16" (1/32" might be better, but let's not guild a lilly here) and then don't over tighten the screw that holds down the lever cap, if you do it makes it hard to adjust depth with the depth adjustment wheel. 

Third, get the iron sharp, really sharp.

Now, don't worry all that much about the flatness of the sole right now; the point is to get the plane to work as it was supposed to; you can bugger up a plane sole by trying to flatten it if you are not careful, so be careful.

Remember, when you advance the depth of the iron, if you have to back off, back off more than necessary and then creep forward with the iron adjustment such that the depth adjustment wheel is always being tightened; this removes the "slop" from the yoke mechanism.

 

Have fun.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.