Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been thinking about a cyclone from JDS Tools. I went to their website today and every dust collector they sell is showing out of stock. This seems a little weird and now I'm concerned about the stability of the company. It could be nothing but I can't imagine a company being out of every model of a product line. Has anyone heard any news about the company having troubles? It could be just a part shortage. Seems like they have been around for a number of years...

Does anyone have one of the JDS cyclones and are you happy with it? I'm looking at the 2100-CKV and 3100-CK. I find a lot of posts about CV, Grizzly, Oneida, and even Harbor Frieight. Not much about JDS but it seems like a good product. The price for features seem good compared to other brands and of course everyone claims their measurement for CFM and SP is better than every competitor. 

Thoughts and opinions?

Posted

Do not know how JDS Tools are but as far as everything showing out of stock. It could be as simple as they are updating there web site and you just tried to access it at the wrong time............

Posted

I would double-check the height of the cyclone body. If I remember correctly, they offer shorter cyclones, which are good for people with short ceilings(me in a basement); however, shorter cyclone body typically equates to poor separate performance. The whole reason to own a cyclone is to separate as much debris as possible before it goes to the filter. Trust me, cleaning a pleated filter SUCKS. I just took mine apart over the weekend and spent 2 hours blowing it out with a compressor and vaccing the inside. I drum sand a ton, and would be toast without an efficient cyclone--heck, I wish it was more efficient. I have the grizzly model, which appears to do decently. You want the cyclone body to have a neutral vane, air ramp, and be as tall/long as possible. All those design aspects lend themselves to greater separation efficiency.

 

I own the JDS Airtech HP air cleaner and really like the thing. I think they make top notch products, but I cant say if their cyclone designs are the best. Why not stick to the big two(maybe three) players?

Posted
15 minutes ago, Pwk5017 said:

I would double-check the height of the cyclone body. If I remember correctly, they offer shorter cyclones, which are good for people with short ceilings(me in a basement); however, shorter cyclone body typically equates to poor separate performance. The whole reason to own a cyclone is to separate as much debris as possible before it goes to the filter. Trust me, cleaning a pleated filter SUCKS. I just took mine apart over the weekend and spent 2 hours blowing it out with a compressor and vaccing the inside. I drum sand a ton, and would be toast without an efficient cyclone--heck, I wish it was more efficient. I have the grizzly model, which appears to do decently. You want the cyclone body to have a neutral vane, air ramp, and be as tall/long as possible. All those design aspects lend themselves to greater separation efficiency.

 

I own the JDS Airtech HP air cleaner and really like the thing. I think they make top notch products, but I cant say if their cyclone designs are the best. Why not stick to the big two(maybe three) players?

Your Grizzly doesn't have the handles and filter cleaning brush? 

Posted

Mike,

It does and I typically use the brush once every 2 weeks or so. I also got into the habit of going at the outside with my air compressor at 50psi or so. You woudlnt believe how much powder hides in those pleats after a year and a half of heavy hobbyist use. I gave it a deep clean outside over the weekend and it was miserable. However, the increased air flow is insane now. I think I forgot how powerful that machine was brand new. 

 

OP, where you at? I have my sights on a used JDS 3hp cyclone. 

Posted

Thanks for the comments. I didn't mean to post and drop off the face of the Earth. Busy week at work...

The Grizzly G0441 and JDS 3100 CK seem similar. Both 3HP, 18" impeller, 8" inlet, single pleated filter, 55 gallon drum, remote, close on the CFM and SP. The difference I see is Grizz charges extra for the stand and it's built in to the JDS. With the stand they cost about the same. The Grizzly has a taller cyclone and I'm hearing that might make a big difference. I looked at Oneida and the 3HP Super Dust Gorilla doesn't seem to be that different. When I add the stand, 55 gallon fiber drum, remote and all that to compare apples to apples it seems to be < $200 more. 

I was expecting there to be a big difference in price and I'm seeing 10% to 12% so a sale or some sort of shipping deal and a man could come out better with any of the 3. I think Clearvue wins on price if you want to spend some time building parts like the housing and filter box. JDS has a different fan design they claim is better. Seems everything I read is based on a personal love hate relationship with the brand. 

Hmmm decisions decisions... Maybe it comes down to color. Nah. I'm putting this under my shop space so size, color, noise are not really factors. I will build a closet and send some return air back because my shop space is heated/cooled. I'll probably just put some furnace filters in a floor register(s) and I expect any of these will do a good job.

I like to mull things over so I'll wait a few weeks to make a decision (while waiting on Uncle Sam to give me some of my cash back). If anybody has additional advice I'm still listening. 

 

Posted

I was going through this decision late last year.  I watched the great video series by the Down To Earth woodworking guy around this topic.  The videos are a bit lengthy, but he goes into good detail around selection of and setting up a DC system.  Based on his decision matrix idea that I did for my own space, I was looking at the JDS cyclone he bought or an Oneida cyclone. 

I found very little info on JDS, so I tried calling them... a few times over the course of a week or 2 with no answer.  I sent an email, left a voicemail and simply never heard back from them at all.  I was just trying to answer some basic questions and was left with nothing.

So, I called up Oneida, was instantly connected to a tech guy who listened carefully to my rambling and answered all my questions in impressive detail.

Guess who got my business?  Yes, the Oneida was a few hundred more than the JDS, but it was on sale at the time and I felt much better about the purchase given the support they offered.  They also included a DC system design for free, at least they did at the time, not sure if that is a standard thing or not.  I didn't purchase the full duct system (just connecting 1 machine at a time right now) but nice to have the plan laid out if I want to go there.

So far the Oneida is exactly what I had hoped - an efficient, smaller footprint cyclone (portable dust gorilla). Bonus it is made in the US.

Only complaint re: Oneida is their shipping costs are very high, especially if you live across the country from them like I do.  Other than that, nothing but good things to say about them.

  • Like 2
  • 1 year later...
Posted

I just called company headquarters for JDS in South Carolina and was told that their entire line of cyclone dust collectors has been pulled off the market. Additionally they don't expect to reenter the market. I was just ready to buy a JDS 3 horsepower and was inquiring about free. Maybe we'll have to go to California?

 

Misspelling

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.