Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Minwax - Fast drying polyurethane dries to white patches

Featured Replies

Hi All,

Recently purchased oak treads/risers from lumber liquidators for my stairs.  They are red oak, unfinished.

After measuring each one, cutting and sanding to size, I then stained them using Miniwax Cherry 235.

After letting them dry, started applying Miniwax Fast Drying Polyurethane, Clear Semi-Gloss.

It only take a few minutes, and white patches started appearing on some of the treads.  image is attached.

It is not a patch where you can scrape off with your finger nail, i have to sand down the poly, then sand down the white patch, clean it off, re-stain, let it dry, and then re-apply the poly.

I have been repeating this process multiple times, same results.

I have tried:

1. Bristle Brush and Foam Brush

2. New can of poly

3. applied a 50/50 mix of mineral spirts and poly

4. heated the room to 70F (we are located in NY)

5. cooled the room to 55F (let the window open slightly)

6. applied poly while the stain is still wet

7. applied the poly while the stain is completely dry

We continue to get white patches...to say the least, it is very frustrating.  I am ready to confirm that lumber liquidators provided us with some shady wood treads, or i messed something up when staining them.

Your thoughts, Please, and Thank you. 

Mike

OakStairs.jpeg

Some thing is off here.

It is the oil based poly right? Have you tried sanding the white off?

Did you mix the can well before using it? The solids tend to settle and can cause a problem similar to this.

  • Author

yes, Oil based poly.

First time I applied the stain, i did not stir it.  I tipped it end over end a few times, as I was hesitant to create those air bubbles people refer to.  Now I stir the can prior to use.   I just applied a coat to 5 of the treads that have been dry for about a week.  1 has slight white coming through...the other 4 seem to be holding...i will take a picture later this afternoon.

With regards to it drying too fast, I am unable to find anything other than the miniwax fast drying poly on the shelf. 

I do have some TSP in the shed BTW, and I agree it works great, we clean the pool filters with it.

Thanks for feedback...will post another pic on this next set shortly.

Mike

 

 

If this were me. Strip all the steps down with a chemical stripper. This will ensure even color of all the steps when you re-stain. 

 

After chemical stripping the steps. Wash down the steps with mineral spirits and let the steps dry for a week. In a warm 65 to 70 degrees. Then stain. MAKE SURE YOUR STAINED STEPS HAVE COMPLETELY DRIED. Give it a week in 65 to 70 degrees. Then apply your topcoat.

 

The white is the oil based stain still gassing off through the topcoat. If the stained steps were drying in a cool temp. That slows the drying time of the stain. It may feel dry to the touch but as Mike mentioned. The deep grain in oak acts like a pool and collects the stain. Thus taking longer to dry.

 

-Ace-

 

 

9 minutes ago, AceHoleInOne said:

If this were me. Strip all the steps down with a chemical stripper. This will ensure even color of all the steps when you re-stain. 

 

After chemical stripping the steps. Wash down the steps with mineral spirits and let the steps dry for a week. In a warm 65 to 70 degrees. Then stain. MAKE SURE YOUR STAINED STEPS HAVE COMPLETELY DRIED. Give it a week in 65 to 70 degrees. Then apply your topcoat.

 

The white is the oil based stain still gassing off through the topcoat. If the stained steps were drying in a cool temp. That slows the drying time of the stain. It may feel dry to the touch but as Mike mentioned. The deep grain in oak acts like a pool and collects the stain. Thus taking longer to dry.

 

-Ace-

 

 

I don't mean to contradict your good advice but how have i been able to top coat over stains after letting them dry for 4 hours in a 62 F basement? I use minwax oil stain and minwax fast dry same as OP. I just want to ask as well so the OP doesn't spend 2 weeks of dry time to have the same problem occur.

  • Author

I agree with maybe the wood stain was a little moist in some areas.  You can see it coming through the tread in certain places.  The only problem is that I let certain pieces dry out for 1-2 weeks before applying the poly...same results.  Then I got impatient and starting fast tracking it.

im going home right now to check on the previous set of treated treads.  stay posted! 

BTW i will not have the will power to strip down 12 treads and start over.  my last resort is going back to LL and purchasing pre-stained treads.

Thanks for all the feedback.  I was hesitant to post this problem online, but my brother told me about this website..and because the amount of work i was putting into these stairs made him feel uncomfortable i decided to put it out there...but after scouring the internet for days, i was amazed that no one else has had this problem. 

maybe i just didnt let stain dry enough. 

8 minutes ago, Mike. said:

Finishing is hard.  I have been doing it for a while and every 3rd project I run into some problem.  I have learned to fix most of them but folks underestimate how much can go wrong.  Its not like paint.  A drunk monkey can apply paint and get a good result. 

It took me a couple years to get to where I'm at now and Mike. just proved how incompetent i am still.

If your going to get to the point where your buying new pre-stained treads why not try just sanding off some of the minimally "damaged" ones to see if you can salvage them. Giving things a thorough stir is very important. Though shaking is bad for poly, I shake my stains then let the bubbles settle before i wipe it on.

Did you wipe off the excess stain?

Also it can't hurt to bring the treads to LL and politely ask for a refund or advice, if it is bad wood. They may have something to say.

1 hour ago, Chestnut said:

I don't mean to contradict your good advice but how have i been able to top coat over stains after letting them dry for 4 hours in a 62 F basement? I use minwax oil stain and minwax fast dry same as OP. I just want to ask as well so the OP doesn't spend 2 weeks of dry time to have the same problem occur.

You have been damn lucky my friend.

All woods take stain differently. Soft woods tend to pull wet stain deep into the fibers. Woods with deep grain pockets collect the stain in them. Woods sanded with higher grits say 220 will act like a sealer preventing the stain from pulling in, but rather sit on top of the wood.  

So think of it like a household sponge. The more water in a sponge the longer it takes to dry. The more coats of stain applied in one day really wets the wood. 

This problem will never happen if you let the stain dry, how could it...its dry!  

 

-Ace-

  • Author

Now that i think of it...you might be right Mike, when i first starting applying the stain...i did not mix it very well...in fact, i barely mixed it at all because at first coat...the stain was light in color...basically all oil.  then as i got to the bottom of the can..it darkened up because the color was at the bottom.  That has to be part of the problem. 

I have attached 2 more pictures.  The risers, which are really thin, still reacted to the last coat of poly.  These were definitely dry.

Of the 5 treads I am currently working on...4 seam to be holding the poly well...1 is still reacting.

Thank you all for the help.  Hopefully this post helps someone else.

IMO...I did not mix the stain properly, and did not let it dry for long enough.

I will continue to post pictures as I proceed through this. 

-Mike

LumberLiquidatorStairTreads_WhitePatches_030316.jpg

LumberLiquidator_Stair_Risers_030316.jpg

Ok...lets try this, how thick of an application were you applying the topcoat?

Did you wipe it back or lay it on thick to let it dry?

How may coats did you apply in one day?

It's interesting to me how the white is following the coarse grain. ;)

 

-Ace-

  • Author

not thick at all.  3" foam brush, not soaked in the poly.  nice even speed across the board, with the grain.

the picture above with the 4 risers, is the first coat today.  those 4 were standing in the corner, untouched for at least a week.

yes, it does follow the grain, which makes me think that the wood was still drying, as impossible that it seems. 

but the white color confuses me.  what i will do is wait a few hours...sand off, lightly, that section of white...re-stain, nice and even, and then let that dry, and then re-apply the poly.  stay posted if you like watching a train wreck!

  • Author

the treads came wrapped in plastic, nice and clean.  i wiped them down, cleaned the dust...and applied the stain.  They were already smooth.   Staining took place in the garage.  Temperature was cool, (50-60) that would be the only other possible problem other then me not mixing the stain well enough.

 

1 hour ago, DIYplease said:

I agree with maybe the wood stain was a little moist in some areas.  You can see it coming through the tread in certain places.  The only problem is that I let certain pieces dry out for 1-2 weeks before applying the poly...same results.  Then I got impatient and starting fast tracking it.

im going home right now to check on the previous set of treated treads.  stay posted! 

BTW i will not have the will power to strip down 12 treads and start over.  my last resort is going back to LL and purchasing pre-stained treads.

Thanks for all the feedback.  I was hesitant to post this problem online, but my brother told me about this website..and because the amount of work i was putting into these stairs made him feel uncomfortable i decided to put it out there...but after scouring the internet for days, i was amazed that no one else has had this problem. 

maybe i just didnt let stain dry enough. 

Funny you should mention that.  I have a brother who is from one of the northern states and he's been working on projects like this for some time.  Once he handles a hammer and begins projects he begins ranting online in colloquial manner. 

Carpentry is a skill that may only be mastered with patience and diligence.   Perhaps staining in such a contiguous manner is reason for fault and we should depose with the idea of blaming the application without reflecting on the applicator.

Wood work is an art and like the previous poster so eloquently stated, a monkey can paint though it takes intestinal fortitude to cruz to victory.

4 minutes ago, DIYplease said:

the treads came wrapped in plastic, nice and clean.  i wiped them down, cleaned the dust...and applied the stain.  They were already smooth.   Staining took place in the garage.  Temperature was cool, (50-60) that would be the only other possible problem other then me not mixing the stain well enough.

 

When you use plastic make sure that you keep it clean, i like to use soap and water and then dry using a hair dryer.  If the plastic is not completely free from toxins then don't use it.  Once the plastic has been clean free of any chemicals or byproducts, apply a thin  layer of tape to the outside surface.  2. When you wipe it down, it's only wood and its already dead so you don't have to treat it so nicely, just get it done.  Now, regarding that garage, what is the square foot area?  NOT the entire garage, but the usable area.  I've found that staining in an area that is not well suited and ventilated with at least 200 sq ft of usable area is a problem.  We need maximum air participation to allow for the wood to absorb efficiently and effectively.   

  • Author

Joe, appreciate your insight...not sure what you mean by the north.  I was sure to stain and poly all wood in the garage or family room.  This was not done in an open air barn with wild animals running around, by any means.  Area was clean, etc.  I will post pics soon...just re-sanded, and applied another layer of stain...so looking good. 

These stairs will be finished soon, I have no doubt.

Stay tuned, and thank you for the feedback. 

 

I just finished staining oak treads and used a water based poly that I was super pleased with ...just in case you want to change polys

I used a foam brush and no bubbles. It was my first time using a water based poly and it was much easier then the oil I have used in the past

246baeedf101dea23e65e4cbfebfb1f8.jpg955496b228dda393bf6b4167ad27ed7a.jpg

Actually I guess the poly is a waterborne oil modified poly. Drys in about an hour. I was able to do 3 coats in one day.

  • Author

Looks good logos.  I just re-stained the treads, and will give them a few days to dry, before trying the poly one last time. 

Once i start applying the poly, how long should I wait before re-applying additional coats?

 

Risers_030316.jpg

Treads_030316.jpg

2 hours ago, DIYplease said:

Looks good logos.  I just re-stained the treads, and will give them a few days to dry, before trying the poly one last time. 

Once i start applying the poly, how long should I wait before re-applying additional coats?

 

Risers_030316.jpg

Treads_030316.jpg

I usually do 8-24 hours. Long enough to be able to sand the surface with sand paper in between. Look into doing a coat of dewaxed shellac between stain and poly the results usually look the same and it's much faster. Zinsser seal coat can be purchased at most box stores. I helps level the surface out faster. Shellac is sand able in 1-2 hours and doesn't have as harsh of VoCs.

Those are going to look great. I would wait 24hrs and do a light sanding with 320grit. It's just what's worked for me in the past.

If you have not stripped all of the defective ones, I wonder what would happen if you gave it the duct tape test? It might reveal a little more clue to the issue. 

If stain is not properly dry under a finish it will act as a release agent. You can take duct tape, rub it onto the surface for a good bond and rip it off. 

If the finish is properly bonded to the surface, nothing will happen. If the stain was not dried properly, the tape will remove the finish. I learned this the hard way some years ago doing a couple of tables for a coffee shop. 

Most dry times stated on the product cans for stain and finish is based on 70°, but that is not just air temperature, you also have to account for surface temperature of the wood if it was kept out in a cold area and then brought into the shop. This all adds to the dry time of the stain. 

Attached are the tables for the coffee shop. I did not allow for any extra dry time for the stain with my shop being at 58°. I stained one day and finished the next.

It was only a few days later the coffee shop called and said the finish popped off in a couple of spots. I brought them back to the shop and gave it the duct tape test. I had to strip and finish the tables again. 

 

SV103415.jpg

SV103414.jpg

It just occurred to me, I was assuming that the product is rated for floor traffic.

But is it stated on the product label that it is rated for floor traffic?  

Not that it has anything to do with the cloudy finish issue, but just making sure it is the proper finish for the situation otherwise.  

Floor coatings are thinner so you can flow them on faster and they will level better. Remember a floor is like doing 20 table tops all put together. A gloss coating not polished is less slippery than a full satin. The flatters in a satin finish offer slip.  

If you think about it, they used shellac on floors in the old days. So not sure if any "Science" is in any floor finish to make them less slippery or harder or resistant to wear than say a table top finish. 

-Ace-

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Author

I am not sure if the Minwax is floor rated.  I have been letting these stairs sit for a while inside.  I re-applied using a combination of stain and poly, and voila, no white patches.  After that dried for about a week, i applied another coat of poly only, again, no white patches except for ONE.  I was happy with finally seeing some results, so continued on, and plan on installing the stairs this week.  

On a side note, I lost power in the garage, so I am planning on moving some benches into the workshop (my shed).  I would like a computer out there, so I can research without coming back into the home, and wanted to share with you guys a solution I found in order to link any two locations together, wirelessly, or connect the home network to my shop in my case.  It is called a "Wireless Bridge Kit", and allowed me to connect my shop computer, to the network inside the home, with no cat5e cables between the two.  Details here: GNS Wireless | Wireless Bridge Kit.  Depending on your distance, there are a few options, but they can assist further.  I used the GNS-1172N, which is one of the smallest antennas available, and they work great.

Will post pictures of the installation shortly...

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.