Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Spray guns~Siphon or Gravity?

Featured Replies

I recently got a Fuji Semi-Pro 2 with a gravity gun. I wanted to have separate guns for lacquer and for "other" so I got a siphon style gun for my second.

Is there any distinct advantage of one style over the other?

The gravity gun has a 400ml cup and the siphon has a quart-sized cup. Would the extra capacity have an advantage with a particular finish?

I think I'm going to end up shooting lacquer, maybe shellac, maybe poly or other varnish. If I move over to water borne finishes I'll probably get a third gun. Which gun would you use for which finish?

And for bonus points, what kind of lacquer do you spray? I'm confused about the pre-cat and post-cat stuff and what a hobby shop should go with. I have a Sherwin Williams in the are but not much else beyond your average hardware stores like Ace or True Value, so I would probably have to order online.

I use a precat waterbourne  in my siphon HVLP gun. And I use a small gravity gun for shading and toning when spraying stains.

Not sure why you think you need so many guns? But hey that's not my boogie! All you have to do is purchase different needle and nozzle sets for one gun for the variety of finishes. A ton of info is out already about this so let google be a friend.

Like Wdwerker, I have the small gravity compressed air gun for little things as Wdwerker mentioned. I like the gravity guns because that's what I like. Larger the cup the better on gravity feed (compressed air gun's) cause more fluid weight pushes out the finish for a better delivery onto the wood.   

For the life of me, with all the great water-based finishes on the market. Begs the question, why spray anything other than water-based, yeah I get solvent shellac, but solvent lacquer is just nasty and the gun cleanup and disposal of solvent lacquer STUFF, ugh! But if you live in the sticks...that's not a problem then is it;). Oh yeah, if you have neighbors like I do, they will just love the sweet smell of lacquer blowing in their windows. :P

 

-Ace-

 

  

You can use the same gun for a variety of finishes with no problem if you can just change out the needle size to accommodate the material. For example latex requires a larger needle than lacquer. 

Cleaning a gun out is easy, but hoses can be a different matter. I would not run latex through a hose fed gun and then use the same hose for lacquer. 

I have an HVLP setup that came with both a siphon feed and a gravity feed gun. I use them as wdwerker does. 

Don't overlook the value of your local Sherwin Williams store. They sell great finishes that you can easily walk in and purchase at any time. Plus they should be pretty knowledgable on all their products and can give you a wealth of information.

Also you can ask about any seminars that they might have you can attend. At my location they have a couple of contractor shows where they have all the new tools on display, free hamburgers, and the reps give classes on the products. If you ask about when they have one, nobody is going to ask you for a contractor license to verify you can attend. Just tell them you want to get in on any classes they have.  

If you are a woodworker and you go in on a regular occasion, getting the pro discount shouldn't be difficult to get. I know local woodworkers that get the same pro discount that I do because they are regular customers. 

 

Oh man - I just noticed you are in Jackson! I was juried into the Western Design Conference a few years ago. Have you gone to the the WDC? You need to check out the design lectures they have. Great stuff from all across the creative spectrum: architecture, art, furniture making, leather workers, metal workers, jewelers, etc. 

Up until about 2000 I used to come down with friends who have a raft and we would run the Snake 6 - 8 times in a day. Did some climbing too. 

Sorry to get off track. Just got all excited you were in Jackson;)

  • Author
On 3/15/2016 at 5:36 PM, wdwerker said:

I use a precat waterbourne  in my siphon HVLP gun. And I use a small gravity gun for shading and toning when spraying stains.

Thanks Steve. Good to know.

19 hours ago, AceHoleInOne said:

Not sure why you think you need so many guns? But hey that's not my boogie! All you have to do is purchase different needle and nozzle sets for one gun for the variety of finishes. A ton of info is out already about this so let google be a friend.

Like Wdwerker, I have the small gravity compressed air gun for little things as Wdwerker mentioned. I like the gravity guns because that's what I like. Larger the cup the better on gravity feed (compressed air gun's) cause more fluid weight pushes out the finish for a better delivery onto the wood.   

For the life of me, with all the great water-based finishes on the market. Begs the question, why spray anything other than water-based, yeah I get solvent shellac, but solvent lacquer is just nasty and the gun cleanup and disposal of solvent lacquer STUFF, ugh! But if you live in the sticks...that's not a problem then is it;). Oh yeah, if you have neighbors like I do, they will just love the sweet smell of lacquer blowing in their windows. :P

 

-Ace-

 

  

Actually I thought that it was sort of standard practice to dedicate a gun to a certain solvent as a matter of convenience. I heard it on Marc's episode 155. I figured it made sense to not spray water-based out of a gun that had previously been used for oil-based. I should have asked before I plunked down the 200 beans for a second gun.

As for spraying lacquer instead of water based...I'm open to using water based, it's just that my experience is limited. I like the look of lacquer so I was going to go with lacquer. What water based top coat do you recommend?

Yeah, I live in the sticks. No neighbors near enough to complain about spraying, but I still follow safe disposal practices. 

2 hours ago, toddclippinger said:

You can use the same gun for a variety of finishes with no problem if you can just change out the needle size to accommodate the material. For example latex requires a larger needle than lacquer. 

Cleaning a gun out is easy, but hoses can be a different matter. I would not run latex through a hose fed gun and then use the same hose for lacquer. 

I have an HVLP setup that came with both a siphon feed and a gravity feed gun. I use them as wdwerker does. 

Don't overlook the value of your local Sherwin Williams store. They sell great finishes that you can easily walk in and purchase at any time. Plus they should be pretty knowledgable on all their products and can give you a wealth of information.

Also you can ask about any seminars that they might have you can attend. At my location they have a couple of contractor shows where they have all the new tools on display, free hamburgers, and the reps give classes on the products. If you ask about when they have one, nobody is going to ask you for a contractor license to verify you can attend. Just tell them you want to get in on any classes they have.  

If you are a woodworker and you go in on a regular occasion, getting the pro discount shouldn't be difficult to get. I know local woodworkers that get the same pro discount that I do because they are regular customers. 

 

Thanks Todd. I'll check out Sherwin on some topcoats, see what they have. I've been in there before but just for brushes and PPE items.

1 hour ago, toddclippinger said:

Oh man - I just noticed you are in Jackson! I was juried into the Western Design Conference a few years ago. Have you gone to the the WDC? You need to check out the design lectures they have. Great stuff from all across the creative spectrum: architecture, art, furniture making, leather workers, metal workers, jewelers, etc. 

Up until about 2000 I used to come down with friends who have a raft and we would run the Snake 6 - 8 times in a day. Did some climbing too. 

Sorry to get off track. Just got all excited you were in Jackson;)

Yeah, I noticed that you were "local". I got my bandsaw from a Craig's listing in Billings.

I can't tell you all the fun I've had in Montana over the years. Worked in Yellowstone for a couple of years. Did a lot of rock climbing in Hyalite and Gallatin Canyons. I climbed Granite Peak in 1989. Mountain biking the Morrison Jeep Trail in the Bear Tooths was a memorable experience. I have friends who lived at Big Sky, Belgrade, and Bozeman. My in-laws live in Absarokee.

We run the Snake all the time; from Wison to South Park usually. The Snake through Jackson Hole and down the canyon is one of those great rivers where you can get on or off every 14-20 miles(or less). You can take on as much as you have time for and the regulations are pretty friendly.

I've not been to the WDC but it sounds like I'll have to try it out this summer!

The pre cat waterbourne I spray is usually only sold to pro shops. I have heard good things about General Finishes water Bourne interior and exterior coatings.

Dave - I don't think you will regret having 2 guns in the long run. There have been many times I had paint in the siphon cup gun and Zinnser Bullseye shellac based primer in the gravity feed as I was finishing a project and had different parts in different stages  of painting. 

I don't think you wasted your money. 

Been to Hyalite and bagged Granite 10X including a 1 day summit in & out. Was at the snow bridge guiding a friend up and he was puking all over the place and a snowstorm was moving in (in August) so I had to pull off tapping the summit for #11 to get him back out to lower elevation. 

If I get back down to Jackson I will get in touch so we can meet up. 

 

I like General Finishes products Dave.

One tip I can give you. Make for sure you keep your guns clean. I hear so many guys how they leave finish in the cup for hours or even day's. Solvents not so bad but water-based can really gum up your gun and passage ways. If you don't, you'll be using that other gun sooner that later. All good, happy spraying!! You'll take your finishing to a higher level!!

 

-Ace-

  • Author
6 hours ago, toddclippinger said:

Dave - I don't think you will regret having 2 guns in the long run. There have been many times I had paint in the siphon cup gun and Zinnser Bullseye shellac based primer in the gravity feed as I was finishing a project and had different parts in different stages  of painting. 

I don't think you wasted your money. 

Been to Hyalite and bagged Granite 10X including a 1 day summit in & out. Was at the snow bridge guiding a friend up and he was puking all over the place and a snowstorm was moving in (in August) so I had to pull off tapping the summit for #11 to get him back out to lower elevation. 

If I get back down to Jackson I will get in touch so we can meet up. 

 

That would be great Todd. Definitely get in touch if you're in town.

6 hours ago, AceHoleInOne said:

I like General Finishes products Dave.

One tip I can give you. Make for sure you keep your guns clean. I hear so many guys how they leave finish in the cup for hours or even day's. Solvents not so bad but water-based can really gum up your gun and passage ways. If you don't, you'll be using that other gun sooner that later. All good, happy spraying!! You'll take your finishing to a higher level!!

 

-Ace-

 

1 hour ago, wdwerker said:

After cleaning a gun from spraying waterbournes you can flush the gun with denatured alcohol .

Thanks for the tips guys! I'm looking forward to being able to spray my finishes during summer months. For me the finishing often is more difficult and takes longer than building the project.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.