Recommended Posts

Posted

I have a question for anyone that has used the 100$ Freud Dado blade set they sell at home depot and whatnot.  I have had this for a few months and used it a few time with my table saw with very good results.  Other than the prescribed thickness being off the set performs very well for the price point.  However I recently acquired a Radial Arm Saw (Which I love) and have been using it to cut tenons and recess on a project I am doing.  It is producing an extremely rough cut.  I moved the chippers to every conceivable spot within the circumference of the blades and tried using the spacers.  I never had issues like this cutting dados or rabbits in plywood with it so my question is does anyone else have this issue?  I included a picture that hopefully helps out.

 

I can only assume it has to be the blade setup or these blades just always cut like this and I never noticed it before. 

IMG_6204.jpeg

Posted

Yea I'm not sure.  It does it on the way out or the way in.  I tried just pulling it out and going to the next cut pushing it in and the same results.  I've used it for crosscuts for a few weeks and never had an alignment issue with it.. I spent quite a bit of time squaring it up to the table and the fence..

Posted

I have the freud dado blade (SD208) and used it in my TS, i tried a couple cuts for a tenon and it was pretty smooth but i haven't done more than experiment. Makes me thing there is a very slight alignment issues that isn't showing up on a cross cut but this shows it more.

Posted

If there were an alignment issue wouldn't the size of the tenons be different from front to back?  These are exact dimensions on all edges but just very rough.  Hence why I was thinking more of the blade. 

Posted

I guess my ignorance is in the workings of a radial arm saw. If the blade is tilted left to right slightly it would make sense to me for the cut pictured. Have you tried the blade in a table saw or another saw to see if there is a difference?

Posted

I have but not recently.  And that was only with plywood.  Maybe tonight ill throw it in my table saw and see whats up.  Annoying because I had to cut these large so I can use a block plane to clean them up.  And the back half of this tenon will be showing...

Posted

I have that dado set and I get those ridges too. I figured "that's what you get" with a $100 dado set. It hardly matters for cutting tenons, but can come into play when you want a nice clean groove. It seems like I get less pronounced ridges when I use only the outer blades, without any chippers.

Let us know if you clear up the problem.

Posted

You know that is one thing I haven't tried.  Ill try with the chippers out.  I had to cut a 1/2 deep recess on the bottom of a trestle leg base that was about a foot long so I set it up to take as much material as I could.

Posted

All the stacked dado sets that I'm aware have some degree of top bevel on the teeth of the outside cutters.  Their purpose to reduce the tendency for tearout on cross-grain cuts.  In order for those beveled teeth to be effective, they have to protrude slightly above the flat raker teeth of the inside chippers, which leaves two deeper grooves along the outside edge of the cut commonly referred to as "bat ears".  Some of the better sets disguise this effect pretty convincingly, but the bat ears are there on every set that has beveled teeth on the cutters.  

Dado_channels_zpskpbcsc0p.jpg

 

Smaller bat ears:

Capture_zpslelazhyg.jpg

 

If you run a full stack, those bat ears will be farther apart....if you run a partial stack and they'll be closer together.  If you make multiple passes with a stacked set like for making long tenons, it'll leave two grooves for every pass....the thinner the stack is setup for, the more passes you'll need to make, therefore the more grooves there will be.  I can't say for sure whether your stack is leaving a rough cut, or if you're just experiencing the effect of the bat ears from multiple passes.  Same thing happens from multiple cuts with an ATB, Hi-ATB, ATB/R or TCG grind blade too.  It's pretty common....band saw marks are even worse....most folks just live with it or remove the marks.  Run out from the saw arbor can contribute too.  The best way to check your dado set is to make a single pass with a thick stack and check the overall cut.  Some lesser sets will leave some striping between the chippers as well as the outside cutters, which would show up a lot on multiple pass cuts.

An example of grooves from multiple dado stack passes

178HA-crosscut-sled-tenons_med.jpg

 


 

 

 

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Yeah like Scott said, all dado stacks will leave the bat wings because of the high ATB...which is what makes it possible to crosscut clean dadoes in plywood. But from the looks of that pic, there's something else going wrong because that's much rougher than a normal cut would produce. Probably flex in the RAS head or some other result of imprecision. I don't know what compels you to cut dadoes with a RAS anyway...that would scare the hell out of me.

  • Like 1
Posted

Well that makes a lot of sense

Actually. And I wasn't cutting Dados it was exactly what the guy is doing in that picture above. Cutting a tenon on a large trestle beam. Same size as in the picture actually haha. The cut looked exactly like that picture as well. The picture here is what it was for. The through tenon and will be wedged with a large Sapele wedge.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

af67f7393eb75a810cbcea49afb11ba9.jpg

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

I have the same set and I get those same marks from the bat ears on my Sawstop TS. Like Knotscott said, the thinner your stack, the more lines you will get, and if you overlap, you will get even more. Perhaps other sets don't leave these as much, but in my experience they will never be perfectly smooth because of the relative geometry between the outside blades and the chippers.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 64 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined