Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Finishing Maple Floors

Featured Replies

Hi, I am brand new here, but have been a woodworking hobbyist for several years, making small projects like toys, puzzles, treasure chests, etc. However, I am about to undertake my biggest project yet, installing hardwood floors. I have some experience installing tongue and groove floors, but not with the finishing of them. Now for the twist.

I work for a large cabinet manufacturer, and was able to get a bunch of "scrap" wood when somebody set up the moulder wrong and ran multiple loads that were out of spec and not salvageable for any other part. So, everything is of uniform width and thickness, varying lengths, and should install pretty easily. Planning to drill and screw everything, putty the screw holes, then sand and finish. This is where I am realizing it might be more difficult than I anticipated. The wood is a mix of hard and soft maple, both light and dark, so I am figuring on a more rustic look because of the color variations. My wife wants the finished color to be something like a "warm oak". Now I know it won't look like oak because of the grain, but that's the color she would like. 

I need finishing to be a fairly simple and quick project, since we are living in the home. Planing to knock it out in one extended weekend, hopefully. So, can someone please help me out with recommendations for what products to use to get the color my wife wants without a lengthy process. I understand that maple can be tricky to get colored evenly. I was hoping that I could use a water based polyurethane with color in it. Is that possible? 

Please tell me I haven't bitten off more than I can chew. I will have a crew of 5 or 6 other "experienced" and resourceful men helping me.

I'll be surprised if you can get what you want with the two different woods, even if they are both Maple.

First of all, don't use a MinWax stain.   Some of it is stain, and some of it is really a dye, and some of it is a combination, and it doesn't easily give you an even job on a floor.

Find a supplier to professional floor finishers.  Your location would help with advice.

I'd suggest to stick with Bona products.  You can buy it online, but if you are anywhere near a pro floor store, you can find plenty of samples before spending your money on guess work.  Find a Bona stain that you like.   There are a LOT of choices in finish.   I like Bona Traffic HD, but haven't done a floor in a few years, and they change the product names fairly frequently, so they might have something newer than I've had my hands in.  

How many square feet are you talking about?    Personally, I wouldn't want to do a floor without a buffer to run sanding screens between coats, and for final finish.  I like the Norton disks, but most of the pro suppliers that sell them only sell full boxes, and they aren't cheap.  I put stain on, in the rare times that I might stain a floor, with the buffer, and piece of carpet.  There should be plenty of videos on youtube.

  • Author

Thanks for the advice. 

I am in central Virginia, between Charlottesville and Culpeper, if that helps with advice for a good supply source. We are ok with a more "rustic" look, so hopefully mixing the two types and having both light and dark maple will turn out looking ok. The kitchen and laundry are adjoined, about 320 square feet or so.

I am also going to be doing the dining room in cherry, with a dark, rich color. About 140 square feet.

Thanks for the advice. 

I am in central Virginia, between Charlottesville and Culpeper, if that helps with advice for a good supply source. We are ok with a more "rustic" look, so hopefully mixing the two types and having both light and dark maple will turn out looking ok.

I am also going to be doing the dining room in cherry, with a dark, rich color. About 140 square feet.

The Varathane floor sanding, giant random orbit sander, machines that Lowes rents work pretty good.  They usually have them in the paint section.  I wouldn't want to use one on a whole house, but a few hundred square feet is very doable with one of those.

  • Author

Thank you again for the help

 I'll check out the place in Richmond, maybe they can recommend something more local to me. And Lowe's too.

Drill and screw & putty ? Did you mean plugs ? Test the stain on any putty it may take stain much differently. Putty over a screw head might take awhile to dry and it could shrink and need a second coat. Your tackling a lot of work for one weekend.

You can rent a floor nailer that nails through the tongue.

Staining maple is hard.  A lot of flooring guys around here won't even do it - they will only do natural maple.  You need to sand them perfectly to get good color.  Sand them too much and the color won't absorb.  Sand them too little and you will get blotch and see the sanding marks.  I'd stick with natural maple or find something a shade or two darker.   Don't try to change the color too much. 

  • Author
On 5/14/2017 at 10:15 PM, Tom King said:

The Varathane floor sanding, giant random orbit sander, machines that Lowes rents work pretty good.  They usually have them in the paint section.  I wouldn't want to use one on a whole house, but a few hundred square feet is very doable with one of those.

Tom, there is a lumber supplier close to me that rents out a drum sander with and edger attachment. Would that be better than the random orbit sander? I have no experience with a drum sander. 

I talked to someone at work who used to work in one of the finishing plants in another state. He said that as long as you sand the maple evenly, it should stain pretty evenly. They don't have any problems with blotchiness except when the sanding is uneven, usually caused by the difference between a new sanding pad and an old one, so sand lightly and evenly and make sure the pad doesn't wear to much. 

A drum sander is faster, but not better.  You have to absolutely keep if moving all the time, with no hesitation, and ease the drum down and up.   If it's the kind with a lever on the handle to lift and lower the drum, I'd advise trying it.   If it's the kind you have to lift and lower with the handle alone, I'll strongly advise to go rent the random orbit sander.

I owned a good drum sander for a couple of decades, but the first time I saw someone use one of the German belt sanders, I sold the drum sander pretty quickly, and paid the buck a foot to get the guys with the fancy belt sanders to do the rough sanding for me.   I finished with the buffer.

  • Author

Tom, I just want to say thank you for all the advise and especially the recommendation to Horizon Forest. I called them, got great help and advice and even found out that Better Living Building Supply in Charlottesville is one of their distributors, so I made a 40 minute drive instead of the 1.5 + hour drive to Richmond. 

I am still debating on which sander to use...

Yeah, I've done business with that company since the early 1970's when it was Long Floor Supply, and have followed them to their now fourth location in Richmond.  Buy the 1" scrapers they sell to do inside the corners.  

I've used all of the floor sanding machines.  Depending on how much you have to cut the floor down to level it, would make the difference in deciding on the sander.  You might even need both.  If there is a lot of variation on the levelness of the boards relative to each other, the drum sander would be the tool for the job.  If it's as even as commercial flooring is to start with, I'd go with the RO.  I'm almost as good as the guys who sand floors every day, and I won't use one of the non lever controlled drum sanders unless I really need to.  If you have a lot to cut down, rent the drum sander with coarse sandpaper for half a day, and carry it back when the floor is leveled.  Then follow it with the RO sander.   It's easy to gouge a floor with a drum sander, and virtually impossible to screw one up with the RO sander.

I would only use a drum sander if I had to cut an old finish off of a floor, or level one out.  The RO works great on smooth surfaced bare wood.

The Varathane RO sander that Lowes rents weighs at least 150 lb., and has three 6" hook and loop sander heads under it.  You can follow the recommendation for the number of disks to buy on the back of the disk packages almost exactly, but if you get too many, you can take them back for a refund at Lowes.   It's what I use on commercial flooring if we just have a few hundred square feet to do.  I used it in our house for Oak flooring in a 16x 32 foot part of an addition that had wood flooring.  

http://www.rustoleum.com/product-catalog/consumer-brands/varathane/ezv-sander/   Make sure you get one that has a complete skirt around the perimeter at the bottom, and that the machine disks are in good shape.  The dust collection works decently with a complete skirt, or very poorly with a skirt missing parts.   The skirt is pretty fragile, and renters don't usually take care of stuff.

If you have a thousand feet or more to do, pay a pro to come sand it for you.

When you get ready to finish it, I can save you some head scratching, and probably your back and knees too.

  • Author

Sounds like the RO sander is the one for me then. These boards are all the same thickness. They are all the same part, came out of the same moulder machine on the same shift, so there shouldn't be more than a few thousandths difference in the thickness, plus, most of them are already very smooth, just ready for a finish sanding. Plus I have a hand sander that has the second triangular head that we can use for the corners and edges, so I think it should go pretty smoothly, ;) 

As for the finish, I am doing DuraSeal stains and Loba sealer, Woodwise wood patch for the screw holes and any open knots. Stuff isn't cheap, but sounds like it is worth it. Funny thing is I noticed on the DuraSeal website that their products are manufactured by Minwax. Interesting......
Just have to get good stain brushes yet, and should be all set. 

Sorry I missed the last response.   Scraping will go faster, and less mess than a sander in the corners.  Just keep it sharp with an 8" mill file, also sold by Horizon.  The 1" scrapers they sell have a no name wooden handle, and use Red Devil blades.   All floor pros scrape the corners.  Push down hard over the blade with one hand, and pull with the other.  They also sell larger scrapers, but I get along faster with a smaller one that will cut deeper on each stroke.

I put floor stain on with a buffer, which will stain a whole house in about 10 minutes, but if you don't have access to one of those, I guess you'll need knee pads.  Cheap is not on the list of qualities for good floor finishes.

With the RO machine, you just walk it along very slowly.  It's easy to operate once you get it in the house.  Don't let the dust bag fill all the way up before emptying.  It will get very close to the edges.  If you don't have shoe molding down already, you won't need to use anything else on the edges.

Does the Loba flood on with a T-bar applicator?

edited to add:   I looked at the Loba stuff.   I was impressed.   I'll probably try it the next time I do a floor.  

If you'd like tips on applying it, I'll be glad to add my 2 cents. I do things a bit different than probably anyone else.  One thing I do is use a plastic watering can with a long, thin spout to have a helper pour the finish ahead of the applicator.  Most just pour it out of the jug it comes in, but I like to do each line in one push, keeping a small wave rolled to the dry side.  I don't like to have a puddle to push around.  I like lines to keep the wave rolling right along, and can put the finish on the floor about as fast as I can walk.  I don't brush or pad anything, including the edges and corners.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.