Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been looking at 18" bandsaws.  It's almost like information overload.  One that has caught my interest is the Laguna LT 18 HD bandsaw.  I looked at one today at Tool Crib and was impressed by how it was built.  Seemed really solid, liked the ceramic guides, Rack and Pinion assembly, and adjustments.  I was a little surprised though that the LT18 HD only has one 4" dust port where the less expensive ones have two.  Also that the Laguna web site says it has a 5 HP Leeson motor where the tool crib web site says it has a 4.5 HP Baldor.  Both good motors, just surprised that the HP was different.  When looking at the Laguna web site under the LT 18 HD and clicking on videos, it shows the 3000 series band saws that appear different then the LT 18 HD band saw.  Dual dust ports and two miter slots were a couple things.  I found that curious.  Looking at all of the bandsaws on their site, I didn't see anything that pointed to 3000 at all.  Does anyone know anything?  Is this a new model or something?

Anyway, I'm looking for some advice, or opinions.  It's always good to see what others think about a product before purchase.  If anyone has this saw or one similar in the 18" size, please let me know what you think.

 

Thanks.

TeaMan

Posted

The Hd is a heavy built saw much more then the 3000 LT. I wouldn't be too concerned about the dust ports just make sure you have the recommended cfm to the saw.They are always changing motors between the two brands both are plenty good or equal in my mind.

The HD is a better saw in my opinion. Probably cost more too.

Aj

Posted

Pretty easy to add a 4" port under the table near the lower guides. I have the 20LT which also only has a 4" port in the lower corner. I added a second 4" port with a bit of plywood, 4" hose coupler, and a spring clamp. So far collection has been pretty good. 

Posted

Thanks for the replies.  Dust and myself don't get a long very well.  I visited Tool Crib and looked at the saw there that has two ports.  The one on top was on the side, at about a 45 degree angle, welded on.  I have seen dust ports for sale online and thought the same thing you suggested Pwk5017, easy to add one.  I have a very large cyclone and 6" collection lines in my shop.  Two 4" are close to one 6".  It really helps.  I think that would be a fairly easy addition.

Pwk5017, it seems like the saw you have is pretty much the same saw, just a little bigger.  What do you think of it?  What do you like about it?  What don't you like.  Would you buy it again if you had the chance?

 

Thanks.

Posted

The trouble I see with bandsaw dust ports is that they aren't designed to pull air across the blade.  I've planned on adding one on the lower corner, under the spine,  of my 24", where dust accumulates past the main port, and adding a grill on the opposite side of the blade, so that it would pull air across the blade.   I'm sure it would help, but haven't gotten around to it.  I think if you moved enough air right across the blade, that it would take care of it.  I've never seen one designed like that to start with though.

Posted

I agree Tom.  Pulling air across the blade is the only way to keep the dust off the table or out of the air.  The problem that I see is the gap between the bottom section where the dust ports are and the throat plate and table.  With the way the table tilts, it's difficult to get the table.  I like your thought.  I'll have to study it a bit myself and see if there may be a way to pull the air down and not get in the way of tilting the table.  The only issue I see with a grille above the table which is what I think you may be suggesting is getting in the way while moving wood on the table.  I've seen plastic dust ports that one could cut into from the side maybe and pull the dust down.  One would have to find a way to mount it, and keep it from getting in the way.  I think maybe a 2" hat could be tied into a 4" via a Wye fitting.  I did something similar on a router table with a 4" under the router and 2" in the fence.

Definitely a good idea...

Posted

No.   I was talking about down near the bottom of the machine.  In the corner under the spine, at the bottom.  My 24" accumulates sawdust there, and I was thinking if I can draw it out of the machine, that would be a good place.  It gets carried around the top wheel, and comes out in multiple places.  On my 14", I can just put the open end of a 6" hose under the table, anywhere near the blade, and it cleans that one up nicely, but that's with a 3 hp DC just dedicated to that job.  The 24" generates a lot more sawdust when we're pushing it hard.

Posted

I had the lt18 3000 and I now own the lt18 hd.  The 3000 wasn't really comparable. The 3000 is made in China and the HD is made in Italy. 

There is nothing I dislike about the Lt18hd. It has done everything I have ever asked of it, with ease. I have a 1" resaw king blade on there and resawing is a dream. I really enjoy that saw. 

Posted

Yeah, you really want the port on top of the lower guides if you can manage it. I run a 7" main to the saw with a reducer to 6" with a few feet of leftover 6" hose that Y's into two 4" flexhose lines. It was cobbled together using leftover stuff from other machine hookups. I cant remember running it with only the one OEM supplied dust port. If you do a heavy bevel, the table eventually interferes with a 4" port by the lower guides. If you are really into dust collection, i would consider modifying the actual cabinet and creating an internal chute. I want to say the newer Minimax saws use a zero clearance type insert immediately below the blade with dust collection port directly below that. It look like a very effective design for a tool that is inherently inefficient to collect from. For a lazy guy like me, the 2 minute mod I did works well enough.

 

i wish i could tell you ive used 10 different saws and my surname is snodgrass, but i cant. I went from a 14" jet to the 20" acm saw. There was a 20-24" make in my university's shop, but i only remember using it a handful of times. One of which was resawing pieces of trex decking for this materials class. Anyways, I bought my saw used and its maybe 10 years old? I forget, but so far i am very pleased. With a resaw king, it rips and resaws very well. I cant see myself moving away from the ceramic guides. They adjust very easily and show no signs of wearing out anytime soon. It seems to be a great overall saw from doing mild curves up to resawing. I forget the smallest blade it can do, but ive had 3/8-1/2" on it and thats as small as i need to go. I think my last resaw was about 8-10" of figured hard maple. Went through it with little problem and at a good pace. I just picked up some walnut crotches that i will resaw at some point. That will be a good test, because ill be resawing 15"+/-. The saw goes to 19-20", which is pretty intimidating to see that much blade exposed, but it is nice to have the capacity. Im sure performance goes downhill over 12", but its better to be able to do something inefficiently than not at all. 

Posted

Thanks again everyone.  This has been a great discussion and helped me with my research.  I've decided on the Laguna LT18 with the mobility kit and a few blades of different sizes.  They are on sale today at ToolCrib at 10% off.  I'll be pulling the trigger today.

I'll do an update after I get it and do some work with it.  From what I've read so far, it seems like a good choice.

Again, thanks.

Posted

 

10 hours ago, TeaMan said:

 I've decided on the Laguna LT18 with the mobility kit and a few blades of different sizes.  They are on sale today at ToolCrib at 10% off.  I'll be pulling the trigger today.

Were you getting Laguna blades?  If so Woodcraft will have them at 20% off this Fri Sat Sun & Mon.  Most Laguna power tools will also be 10% off.  I don't know about your specfic model.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 38 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined