Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm looking at purchasing a couple planes. However, price is restrictive, 250 dollars a piece will not work for me. I've thought about going the eBay route and refurbishing a couple general planes.

So the question is this(and forgive me if this has been written in volumes already): What to start out with? Ive ascertained that a #3ish bench plane, an jointer plane and a block plane are ideal, but using only these, as I don't have a jointed or planer, are these the best options?

I do plan on creating a jointing jig for the table saw, but that will only go so far.

Here's where the real problem lies...I've been "educated" solely through information available over the internet, TWW, RWW, MBW etc. This is fine and I enjoy every minute, but I don't have Powermatic or Veritas/Lie-Nielsen money.. and this is what I'm exposed to. I know not everyone is rocking $20,000 worth of equipment, so I would like to hear differences of opinion.

Thanks,

DJ

Posted

Norty,

I was a power only guy when I started out, but now I can't imagine woodworking without using hand tools. My first recommendation is stay way from eBay, when buying old or used hand tools. You really have to know what to look for and what questions to ask, to be sure you are getting what is being sold. I've been burned too many times trying to buy tools on eBay. I recommend buying from Joshua Clark over at http://www.hyperkitten.com/. He will ship the tool to you and let you look at it, before you pay for it. I've had really good interactions with Joshua, and will continure to buy from him.

Now if you are thinking about preparing lumber with hand tools, that is a large topic. I recommend heading over to the Neandertal Village and asking those questions over there. Also, Chris Schwarz has a couple really nice DVDs on using hand tools. Chris is my go to guy, when it comes to hand tools.

Mike

Posted

I use a healthy combination of power and hand tools myself, and I think the key question to ask yourself is how you want to prioritize your tool investments. It sounds like you have a table saw already, but it's not clear what else you have or what you plan on building. I will say that if you are purely weighing power tools versus hand tools for dimensioning rough-sawn lumber, your better bet is to have your distributor do the milling S3S for you for the nominal extra fee. This would allow you to invest in other tools that will really impact the quality and enjoyment of what you're building. If you do decide to go the hand plane route to do your own dimensioning, a jack (#5) and jointer (#7) are the best places to start. I'd then add a smoother (#3 or #4) and then a block (not needed for dimensioning, but a good all around plane to have). But for the kind of work I do and knowing I could outsource the dimensioning, I would personally invest in something like a band saw before all those planes as it's going to open a lot more woodworking doors for me. After all, nobody ever says "wow, you did a great job milling the lumber on that piece".

Posted

Here's where the real problem lies...I've been "educated" solely through information available over the internet, TWW, RWW, MBW etc. This is fine and I enjoy every minute, but I don't have Powermatic or Veritas/Lie-Nielsen money.. and this is what I'm exposed to. I know not everyone is rocking $20,000 worth of equipment, so I would like to hear differences of opinion.

Your budget is your budget, but you also don't need $20,000 for quality hand tools, either. I ran some numbers just for grins to see what you would need for milling boards, as that's the task you seem to be asking about. The goal: take a rough sawn piece of lumber and make it square and finish ready.

post-499-0-16721300-1310675265_thumb.jpg

I tried to pick reasonable tools. On the machinery side, you have a Grizzly 6" jointer, a Dewalt 13" lunchbox planer, and a Bosch ROS. On the hand plane side, a jack plane (#5), jointer plane (#7), and a smoothing plane (#4).

For milling a board, you could go all hand tools, and use the jack/jointer/smoothing planes. You could go all power tools, and use a jointer, planer, and ROS. Or you could go hybrid, in which case I would use a jack plane to roughly flatten the board, a powered planer to thickness it, and a smoother to get it ready for finish.

The first spreadsheet shows the budget for the tools if you go the eBay route to get hand planes. As it turns out, hand tools turn out to be the cheapest option of the three, then the hybrid approach, then all machines.

So let's go high class with the hand planes, which is the second spreadsheet. If you get all Lie-Nielsen planes, the tool budget actually are close to identical regardless of which way you go about prepping your boards. This was actually quite a surprise for me.

But of course you don't need to get all Lie-Nielsen planes. A more reasonable way to go is to go to eBay for the jack plane, since you don't need super high quality for that purpose, and go with Lie-Nielsen for the jointer and smoothing planes. This is represented in the third spreadsheet. Again, hand tool only is the cheapest, even though you are getting really high quality jointer and smoothing planes.

My bottom line is that I wouldn't sweat your tool budget too much. You need to think about it, of course, but at the end of the day, if your budget is really that tight as far as your tools go, you can't afford the wood you'll need to make your projects. You'll be surprised as to how quickly you can blow away money in waste wood.

More importantly, good tools will make your woodworking experience that much nicer, which will let you do better work. There's a quote that supposedly was said by Henry Ford which I can't confirm, but it's a great quote nonetheless: "If you need an expensive tool, buy it. After you do, tomorrow you won't miss the money. But if you don't buy the tool, tomorrow you will surely miss not having it."

Posted

For handplanes, I would recommend starting with a #4 and #6. I don't think you need a block plane. I've heard a lot of good things about the new Version 3 Woodriver planes which are reasonably priced, though restoring/tuning old planes is an option too. When tuning planes, it is really helpful to know what to expect from a well-tuned plane so it would be very helpful if you can try a tuned plane before tuning your own.

Posted

If you have access to machinery now, making your own planes may be a cost effective way of filling your toolbox. Hock Krenov style irons run about $50, you supply the wood for the body.

Otherwise, I completely agree with everything Wilbur said. Excellent response, Wilbur.

Posted

I was a machines only dude for 20 years before I started using handplanes. Sometimes even now I simply run stuff through my planer rather than handplane it. Sometimes I use my power planer to get stuff to the right dimension and then use the hand plane (4-1/2 LV smoother) to get the surface like glass. It depends on the project.

However, I will say that jointing boards is actually faster, quieter, cleaner, and often better with a number 7 (in truth mine's a number 8) then it is running the wood through my jointer. Don't get me wrong the power jointer is still very useful and I use it a lot. But no longer for simply jointing two boards. The handplane is better. So, in my opinion the jointer plane is the most irreplaceable plane in my shop. I have machines which will do the job of the number 4 or 4-1/2, I can find a scraper that will get me by without a blockplane. You can make a chisel plane to get around not having a shoulder plane. But it's hard to beat the jointer plane. I happen to have a LN #8 which I bought from Guild Member Bart.

So please feel free to disagree but I think the jointer plane is the most useful plane as it actually makes life easier and does things that no power tool can do. I welcome disagreement here, but my advice is get yourself a good jointer plane and you won’t be sorry.

Posted

I appreciate all the advice folks. I should say that I was being somewhat over the top on tool costs.

That said, I don't have a problem spending money on tools, I have a problem wasting money on tools. For example, when I first thought about trying a couple simple woodworking tasks, I went to harbor freight and bought four "bar" clamps of varying sizes. The first run out the gate, one completely broke, one has no clamping force and the other two flex under any strain. my thought was, hey, they're clamps. Apparently I was wrong. I would not buy many things from Harbor Freight, but I thought those would be a safe bet.

Within that, I did not know if buying a plane off of eBay would be a wasteful venture and end up costing more in the long run similar to my clamps. But, would a $250 plane be cost effective for me. I guess really only I can answer that... And whenever I'm faced with questions like these, my rule is to ask people that actually know and seperate the ice cream from the bs.

To everyone, great advice, and I thank you.

I originally posted this in a power tool section simply to get the opinions of non purists. I was born with an engineers mindset and not an artist. The finished product with functionality is more important than the artform to me.

Posted

I am also surprised that the clamps were so bad. I would expect them to at least work!

I don't think that you need to buy a premium plane, but if you do buy one premium plane, I would strongly suggest that it be the smoother which needs to be tuned the best.

Posted

I think Bois said it perfectly:

After all, nobody ever says "wow, you did a great job milling the lumber on that piece".

This may sound ironic coming from me, but you may want to think about going with more joinery focused hand tools. I find saws and chisels to be the most used tools in my shop. Milling by hand is a fundamental skill that we should all possess, but it is tiring and monotonous work. I have gotten to a happy place where I can turn up the radio and enter a zen like milling state and really enjoy myself. But I'm really weird. So many of my Hand Tool School members use power for milling and get the most reward from cutting and refining joints by hand. Many also learn a lot about their own skill strengths and weaknesses that can then be applied later with milling. I'm not sayi to skip the hand milling totally but it takes work and time to get it right and it can be a frustrating road. Joinery can be completed pretty quickly with more variety and will keep you engaged and rewarded more than milling.

Too many people have bought milling hand tools, and gotten frustrated and felt they "wasted" money. So as with anything it is a personal choice, but gleaning your personality from your posts tells me you might feel more satisfied if you went the joinery route to initially build your skills. Then you can visit the milling camp. In the meantime, get a thickness planer.

By the way, I have an iPod playlist titled "milling". It is the secret to my zen like state and the contents are proprietary and more closely guarded than the Colonel's chicken recipe.

Posted

Norty,

All I can do is share my experiences with the same set of issues. How do I get a good tool without breaking the bank? When I started out, I bought a simple Stanley block plane. I found it to do well, and as I used it, I found it's limitations. I then picked up an older Stanley #5, sharpened the blade, and was pleasantly surprised at how much utility it gave me.

Don't make the same mistake I did of buying cheap. I bought a Groz #4 smoother, and got what I paid for. Even with a new hock blade, this plane is severely lacking in the ability to give good and consistent results.

However, there seems to be a good solution available. I've been reading good reviews about the WoodRiver line of planes, and will replace the Groz with a new #4 from WoodRiver. I'll review it after a bit, but from what i am reading it seems to do the job nicely, seemilngly as well as the more expensive planes, with good adjustments , and at a more reasonable cost. I hope this is of help.

Gerry

Posted

Let me give you some perspective from a relatively new woodworker and new hand tool user. I decided to go the all hand tool route, I have all the hand tools for the milling process and let me tell you it's not very fun. I got so frustrated trying to mill a board by hand it was driving me crazy and I almost quit woodworking and was ready to sell all my tools. I took a step back and picked up a lunch box planer to assist with the milling. I have zero interest in thicknessing by hand and have no problems with with running it through the power planer. There is steep learning curve with hand tools that you don't really realize until you start using them. It's not just the mechanics behind using hand tools but also ensuring that your hand tools are properly tuned, which is also not intuitive. I recently discovered that for about .25 extra a BF my hardwood dealer will mill all my lumber for me. There is no doubt in my mind that I waste more than .25 BF trying to mill my lumber by hand. Bois said it best no one cares or notices that you milled it by hand or by power. I am now focusing on joinery and finishing and do a very minimal amount of milling by hand.

A note on purchasing tools. When I first went with hand tools I bought an old Stanley Bedrock no 5, which was a PITA to try and make useable mostly because I did not know what I was doing and it seemed like a waste of time. I eventually just bought all new planes and don't regret that choice. I would say get a nice jack plane with an extra blade (I would go BD), lunchbox planer, sanding blocks and some nice chisels. Some people might cringe when they see sanding blocks but I use them to help ensure an even finish. I am not great with my hand planes yet and my smoother leaves plane tracks but that's just me. Good luck!

James

Posted
By the way, I have an iPod playlist titled "milling". It is the secret to my zen like state and the contents are proprietary and more closely guarded than the Colonel's chicken recipe.

That's because the playlist is composed entirely of Katy Perry, Justin Bieber, Taylor Swift, and Selena Gomez. :lol:

Posted

No one ever says you did a great job milling, but they should. Every step depends on the accuracy of the last, and milling is the first and most important step.

If you're not in a hurry, buy used and wait for the tools to come to you at your price. I'm easily rocking $20K in machinery, my jointer alone is worth that new. Because I took my time, did my homework, and waited for the right machine at the right price I've been able to fill my shop with industrial grade tooling at Harbour Freight prices.

Posted

Slow and steady, now!!!

I am a poster child for having done everything (entering woodworking) the wrong way. I started buying equipment, table saw first, thinking that it was the answer to all my needs. You know, if every problem looks like a nail, grab a hammer. Only, the table saw wasn't a very functional hammer. That's when I discovered that I had "under" bought. As a complete newbie with little life experience to assist me in my newfound hobby, I had little real knowledge of the procedural steps by which to mill, join, and finish lumber.

The next phase following a few big purchases was subscribing to the woodworking magazines. This tremendously helped! Which, in turn, alerted me to these internet forums--even more helpful. Joining area clubs has helped even further. So now, several years later, I'm still buying equipment, just much more slowly and intentionally--AND (WAIT FOR IT) specifically to build a particular item. Yes, that's right: all that early advice to buy what you need for completing one project is really good counsel.

I'd much rather work with hand tools than with power. My work area is much quieter and the air less laden with saw dust, hence no dust collection system. Did I mention safer, too. Though any tool can cause a serious injury--just stick your boot out to stop a falling sharp chisel, there's typically far fewer stitches and rarely could one slice off an entire appendage with a chisel or hand saw. Power tools, used properly, are safe enough; hand tools are just safer. Respect your equipment--maintain it and never use it in a manner that it was not designed for!!!!! A good friend just lost 2 fingers, when tired and needing just one last cut, he shoved a piece of wood through the blade when it jammed. Be careful.

Good tools cost money to purchase and to maintain. Even if you don't buy a Forrest 10" TS blade, box store blades are just less expense than the Forrest--you still spend for replacements. Vintage rip and crosscut handsaws, back saws, coping saws, etc. make "one" cuts so much faster (unless you never have clutter on your always set up table saw). But they're not cheap. Good tools cost you! So, slow and steady. We're not in a race to see who can collect the most tools. Tuned hand tools typically leave finishes that far exceed their power cousins; power tools make repetitive cuts far faster (and truer) than hand tools.

In the end, you must decide: is it the journey or the finished product that you seek? Whichever, we look forward to your success.

Archie

near NOLA

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 48 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined