kbrunco Posted November 8, 2011 Report Posted November 8, 2011 Hey all, When in the building process does one use a Smoothing Plane? Thanks, Quin Quote
derekcohen Posted November 9, 2011 Report Posted November 9, 2011 At the end. Regards from Perth Derek Quote
kbrunco Posted November 9, 2011 Author Report Posted November 9, 2011 At the end? Gee thanks for the insight. hahaha Do you use it after the piece is assembled? Or do you use one just before assembly? Quin Quote
derekcohen Posted November 9, 2011 Report Posted November 9, 2011 Hi Quin Sorry - couldn't resist that The smoother can be used during construction or at the end. It just depends on what is convenient. Keep in mind the obvious, that is, a smoother is a finishing plane, and that means it is not for shaping a piece, just adding the final finish. The shavings it removes are very fine, and so fine that using this plane should not alter the dimensions. If you need to use a coarser set plane, it is not really a smoother (although it still can be if used for unseen areas). For example, a jack plane is intended to remove stock faster, and a jointer has the aim of flattening a board. Regards from Perth Derek Quote
Mark Reuten Posted November 9, 2011 Report Posted November 9, 2011 Hi Quin, The smoothing plane has a variety of applications but when to use it depends on the goal at hand and the type of woodworking you do. If your goal is to flatten a broad surface such as a table top, and you are working in the pure hand tool tradition, you would use it following a scrub plane to bring the surface from a rough, choppy condition to an essentially smooth one, hence the name. However, depending on your desired level of accuracy, you may continue on to use a jack or fore-plane next. If you were working with a panel glued up with machined stock which had protruding joints or crowns due to cupping, it would be a good choice to start with again. If you are trimming a carcase joint and a block plane is too small for the job, the smoothing plane may be your next best choice In dressing an edge, it is very useful when working with curved forms as the short sole length will ride into deeper valleys and will be easier to control on the convex surfaces. My primary occupation is building wooden boats so it is the number two plane in my shop next to a block plane. Aside from its use on curves, I also find myself planing vertical surfaces allot, so the lower weight of a smoothing plane is much appreciated. I even keep a few wood bodied models on hand for this very purpose. Any time a shorter sole length works to your advantage is when the smoothing plane is used. I hope that clears things up for you. Mark Reuten www.nomadboatbilding.com Quote
Mark Reuten Posted November 10, 2011 Report Posted November 10, 2011 I see from Derek's post that perhaps we have a conflict of terminology. I was referring to the #4 or 4 1/2 smoothing plane, one size down from the Jack Plane (ie: #5 Stanley). Judging from his description of use, I think that Derek may have been referring to a scraper plane which sometimes uses a hooked blade mounted vertically in a heavy cast iron body. These sometimes have all the adjustability of a standard plane. Sometimes they are just a glorified cabinet scraper holder. A different tool entirely. Mark. Quote
Darnell Hagen Posted November 10, 2011 Report Posted November 10, 2011 Think of a smoothing plane as sandpaper. As to when it's used, you need to strategize. If I were making an apron/ leg assembly, the apron and inside of the leg would need to be prepped before glueup, as parts of them would be inaccessible to the plane afterward. The outside of the leg would be done after glueup, to remove clamp marks. A general rule would be to put off using the smoothing plane as long as you can, there's no point in smoothing, cutting joinery, smoothing again to remove clamp marks, shaping, smoothing again to remove clamp marks, dry fit, smoothing to remove bruises, assembly, and smoothing again. Quote
derekcohen Posted November 11, 2011 Report Posted November 11, 2011 I see from Derek's post that perhaps we have a conflict of terminology. I was referring to the #4 or 4 1/2 smoothing plane, one size down from the Jack Plane (ie: #5 Stanley). Judging from his description of use, I think that Derek may have been referring to a scraper plane which sometimes uses a hooked blade mounted vertically in a heavy cast iron body. These sometimes have all the adjustability of a standard plane. Sometimes they are just a glorified cabinet scraper holder. A different tool entirely. Mark. Hi Mark As I referred to earlier, a smoother is a finishing plane. A scraper plane may also be a finishing plane, however it is a different appliclication of a cutting surface to achieve the same result - scraping rather than planing. The OP asked about a smoothing plane. In Stanley terms, a smoother is a #4 1/2, #4, #3, #2, and #1. In traditional terms, a smoother is a short plane, generally 6 1/2" - 7 1/2" long. A #5 1/2 is not a smoother - in spite of David Charlesworth popularising it as a "Super Smoother". This only works if you are working with flat boards, such as off a power jointer. A smoother needs to be short so that it follows the line of the board and remove as little thickness as possible. Longer planes need to flatten before they smooth, and they remove thickness to do this. Here are two of my favourite smoothers, the new Small BU Smoother by LV, and the LN #3 .. I have a review of the SBUS here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/TheVeritasSmallBUSmoother.html A scraper plane is only useful for hardwoods with interlocked grain. It is not indicated for soft woods. I have a couple of these planes, including a Stanley #112 and this LV Small Scraper Plane ... I generally prefer a high cutting angle in a smoother to control interlocked grain, but I will use scraper for areas where a plane may cause spelching (breakout), such as with a dovetailed carcase. In this case I preferred a cabinet (card) scraper ... fantastic tool! Regards from Perth Derek Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.