Brian VanVreede Posted February 27, 2012 Report Posted February 27, 2012 I'm looking into making hand cut dovetails but do not currently own any tools to do so. I'm looking at the veritas hand cut dovetail kit for 149$. It comes with the saw, a dual marking gauge, and 3 different saddles. Is this worth buying? What other tools will I need besides what comes with this kit? Quote
mattvan Posted February 27, 2012 Report Posted February 27, 2012 Sounds like a nice kit, but other than the dovetail saw and a good marking gauge, the only other tool(s) you'll need are some chisels and a mallet to clear the waste (unless you prefer to use a coping saw like many of us...but you'll still need the chisels to clean the waste). The saddles are a nice tool to have around, but they can be shop made too. After a while you may even choose not to use anything to layout the lines, just eyeball it. Quote
Bob Rozaieski Posted February 27, 2012 Report Posted February 27, 2012 What Matt said. The only thing you need to cut dovetails is a saw, a chisel, a marking gauge, a pencil and a mallet. At WIA, Mike Siemsen brings his "dovetail kit" to the hand tool olympics. It consists of an old hacksaw, a sharpened screwdriver, a piece of 2x4 (for a mallet), a scrap block of wood with a drywall screw in it (marking gauge), and a pencil. As a demo, we cut dovetails with that kit that are every bit as good and tight as any made with hundreds of dollars worth of saws and chisels and marking gizmos. My recommendation to you is to get a decent saw. A well sharpened saw is a pleasure to use. A poorly sharpened (or unsharpened) saw is a lesson in frustration. A good saw doesn't have to cost a lot, but it has to be sharp. My friend has the Crown gents saw that he paid $10 for. It sucks out of the box, but he removed most of the set and refiled the teeth from crosscut to rip and now it is a fine dovetail saw. If you don't have any hand saw at all, you might not want to get a dovetail saw first. It's a one trick pony and won't really be very useful for anything but dovetails. A slightly larger saw, like the Veritas rip carcass saw, will be more useful for other tasks (e.g. small tenon cheeks, joinery crosscuts, etc.) and will still be a great saw for dovetailing. In addition to the saw, you'll need a chisel. Get one or two chisels. You don't need to start with a whole set. These can be old or new depending upon your budget and personal taste. Old ones can be had for $5 or less at yard sales and flea markets. The most important thing here is that you can get it very sharp. Straight sided or bevel edged doesn't matter. They all work. Sharp matters, nothing more. To mark the baseline, you need a marking gauge. You can make a simple one by putting a drywall screw in a scrap piece of wood and filing the flat face a little to make the head kind of sharp, like the cutter on a round gauge. Screw it in to make the setting for narrower stock, screw it out for thicker stock. The piece of wood is the fence. You can also buy a gauge of course, and you will eventually need a real gauge anyway if you intend to stick with hand tools. A cutoff piece of 2x4, or just about any wood for that matter, makes a decent enough mallet. And a pencil or pen I'm sure you can find laying around your house. That's it. You can always upgrade your tools later if you want, but you might find you don't need to once you develop the skill. More expensive tools may be more of a pleasure to use for some folks, but they won't make your dovetails any better. Only practice will do that. You don't need expensive tools to practice with. While it may not look like it, my dovetail and carcass saws are made from old drywall taping knives that I cut up and added backs and handles to. I still use them and have never felt the need to upgrade. They cut just fine for me. Quote
rmac Posted February 27, 2012 Report Posted February 27, 2012 To mark the baseline, you need a marking gauge. Actually, all you really need is a saw and a chisel. This video shows how to easily and quickly mark the baseline at the exact correct position without a marking gauge. It's one of those "Why didn't I think of that?" things. -- Russ 1 Quote
jwatson Posted February 27, 2012 Report Posted February 27, 2012 very clever way to mark the wood depth by using the piece with a chisel. i liked that method pretty easy, he also could have skipped using a marking knife by taking the saw in against the tail and dragging it back to mark the pins. i found it entertaining that the video is subtitled in english and the guy speaks english. Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted February 28, 2012 Author Report Posted February 28, 2012 Thanks guys. After thinking about it a little bit more, I dont think I will buy this kit. Im just going to buy a saw and I like the idea of buying one larger than the dovetail saw, so that I can make it more versitile. I already own a nice set of Bacho chisels, I have a mallet, (other than the one i recently made) and I own a coping saw. Im still going to go with a Lee Valley because it seems like a good tool for that price ($70). Im also planing on taking a 2 day course at the Philadelphia Furniture Workshop on March 10th and 11th, on hand cutting dovetails. Im getting excited about this and after watching Rob Cosman cut them in just over 3 minutes, how hard could it be? Im just kidding of course.. Quote
ChrisG Posted February 28, 2012 Report Posted February 28, 2012 Im getting excited about this and after watching Rob Cosman cut them in just over 3 minutes, how hard could it be? Im just kidding of course.. If you are willing to spend more than 3 minutes - not nearly as hard as you think. It's all about taking your time following a series of steps and more than anything else being able to saw to a line. If no one told you dovetails were hard you probably would't think they were. I bet by the end of the first day of your class you'll have cut a decent or possibley even very good set of dovetails. BTW, I think your saw choice sounds like a good one! Quote
DaBear Posted February 28, 2012 Report Posted February 28, 2012 +1 on the choice of a good saw plus some hands on classes.. Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted February 29, 2012 Author Report Posted February 29, 2012 So if I was only going to buy one saw from Lee valley that would be able to cut both dovetails and tennons which one should I go with? Standard DT 14 TPI Fine DT 20 TPI Small crosscut 16 TPI Carcass crosscut 14 TPI I'm thinking the small crosscut 16 TPI would be the best at multitasking... Quote
justinh Posted February 29, 2012 Report Posted February 29, 2012 I have both of the Veritas carcass saws and they are great saws. I haven't used them a lot (haven't had them that long) but from what I have, they seem to work great. Rip saws are normally used more for dovetails and the majority of tenon cutting is rip as well. Therefore, I think the rip cut carcass saw (12tpi) might be a good fit for what you're wanting to do. I welcome any objections, I'm just an apprentice myself. Quote
ChrisG Posted February 29, 2012 Report Posted February 29, 2012 You definitely want a rip filed saw. Its easier to xcut with a rip saw than rip with a xcut. With small toothed, thin plate saws like the ones your talking about its actually very easy to get good xcut results with a rip filed saw. For maximum versatiliy, I agree with Justin 12ppi rip carcass It will work great for dovetails and small tenons. The 15ppi rip filed DT saw would certainley be a good choice as well, but don't let anyone tell you need a dinky 15ppi+ toothed saw for dovetailing.YMMV Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted February 29, 2012 Author Report Posted February 29, 2012 The funny thing is, is that I didn't include the 12TPI rip because I assumed, being the largest saw with the least amount of TPI, that I would have the least amount of control cutting Joinery. I'm not looking to dimension any lumber, only Joinery. Will I loose anything in my Joinery going with the bigger saw? Quote
Bob Rozaieski Posted February 29, 2012 Report Posted February 29, 2012 You want the 12 TPI rip filed carcass saw. http://www.leevalley...1,42884&p=66066 Anything finer than 12 TPI isn't really going to be useful for anything but cutting dovetails. The smaller teeth on the finer toothed saws will clog up with sawdust in tenon cuts and the saw will bog down in the cut and be very slow and may be difficult to saw to a line. Ditto for anything filed crosscut. Cutting dovetails and tenon cheeks is a ripping operation, so you want a rip filed saw. Dovetail saws are fine toothed because they are designed only for cutting dovetails in stock up to only about 3/4" thick or thinner. So if you cut a 1" wide or wider tenon, you're over taxing the saw. The gullets will clog and it will be frustrating. Like I said earlier, if you want to get a single saw that can do multiple tasks, skip anything called a dovetail saw because the teeth will be too fine for anything but dovetailing. Go with a slightly larger saw with slightly larger teeth. Honestly, the 12 TPI rip filed carcass saw could be the only joinery saw you will ever need. And to answer your most recent question, 12 TPI IS a joinery saw, so no, you won't lose anything. In fact, you'll gain a lot. So get that first. I make saws and the most popular configuration for dedicated tenon saws that I make for other people is 10 TPI. My personal tenon saw is 11 TPI and sometimes I would like it to be 10 TPI for wider tenons. My dovetail saw is 14 TPI and it is a specialized saw made for only cutting dovetails. A saw at 12 TPI will be the perfect balance between a dedicated dovetail saw (which will be slightly finer toothed) and a dedicated tenon saw (which will be slightly coarser toothed). So I really think the 12 TPI saw is going to be better for multitasking. Really, 12 TPI are still fairly small teeth. A rip saw for dimensioning lumber would be about 4-5 TPI and a crosscut for dimensioning lumber would be about 6-7 TPI. So I'd highly recommend going with the 12TPI carcass saw for a first joinery saw. It's a great balance between a dedicated dovetail saw and a dedicated tenon saw. If you ever get into doing a lot of dovetails in thin stock, like 1/2" and thinner, then add a dovetail saw with about 15 TPI to your arsenal. But by no means should a saw with teeth that fine be your first saw. It's just too specialized of a tool. 2 Quote
ChrisG Posted February 29, 2012 Report Posted February 29, 2012 What Bob said!!!! You best heed his wisdom! Also to add to what Bob said (as if anything could really be added) - even when cutting dovetails in 1/2" stock the extra length and slightly bigger teeth can be really nice. Why? Because things go a lot faster if you gang the tail boards together and cut two sets of tails at one time (if you happen to be a "tails-first" dovetailer). If you gang the board togeher you are then cutting 1" thickness of material, and IMHO in such a case a longer plate will give you more accuracy. An 11" 12tpi/13pp sawi is still fairly fine joinery saw and Lee Valley files there saw with a pretty relaxed rake, which means they'll be a tad less agressive and easier to start anyway. Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted February 29, 2012 Author Report Posted February 29, 2012 So I just placed an order for the Veritas 12 tpi rip saw! Thank you everyone, for your input! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.