Tony Wilkins Posted May 2, 2012 Report Posted May 2, 2012 I have a Japanese bench chisel (oiire nomi) on the way with my first tool order. I'm thinking about trying a western one too as a comparison. One problem: I got the 'stuff' to go with my first chisel in Japanese style i.e. metal daruma hammer and water stones. So this leads me to a couple of questions... 1. should I try a paring chisel in Western to avoid the hammer thing (would I be able to make a fair comparison) or should I instead try a Western bench (or better for what I want to do next mortise) chisel with a hammer designed for it? BTW, why are a lot of them round? 2. do the waterstones I have (1000, 6000 grit) work when it would come to sharpen a western chisel? TIA, Tony Quote
ChrisG Posted May 2, 2012 Report Posted May 2, 2012 I'd just get a western bench chisel, if you are looking to compare. A paring chisel is a different animal. The waterstones will work fine on any run of the mill tool steel - their is no reason to use them exclusevly on japanese steel. The round mallets i believe originate from carvers mallets. Ideally you use a wood mallet on a wood chisel handle, but in reality if your not wailing away on it, the hammer your getting could be fine as long as its relatively light weight. Try it with the hammer you ordered and then decide if you need another right away. Of course, it is nice to have a selection of mallets, so ordering a wood one up front isn't going to be a waste. Quote
mlingenfelter Posted May 4, 2012 Report Posted May 4, 2012 I have some Lie-Nielsen chisels and they have Hornbeam handles. I use a metal hammer on them all of the time and I don't even see dents in them. Granted I'm not pounding like crazy on them. For their Mortise chisels I use a larger wooden mallet, but that's only because I need more "heft" for mortising. I've never tried other chisels, but LN chisels stand up to metal hammers. Mike Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted May 4, 2012 Author Report Posted May 4, 2012 In response to a looking for a mortise chisel over on LJ I was pointed towards the pig sticker, English style chisels that Tools for Working Wood has. Liked the looks of them. So I started looking for wooden mallet types. Found a hardwood infill brass mallet listed on Chris Schwartz's site. Pretty but jeez louise - $185 bucks. A little over my price range. Where does brass or rawhide fall in the continuum? Ask about rawhide because I found a hammer like that when I was searching for auto work BFH's. Quote
croessler Posted May 4, 2012 Report Posted May 4, 2012 I had a hard time finding a mallet that I liked so I mad my own. I posted them here over on LJ. or this one I made for my dad Quote
mlingenfelter Posted May 4, 2012 Report Posted May 4, 2012 Here are two other "Schwarz approved" mallets. I have both and used them when mortising, and other things. I like them both and they won't break the bank. http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=50229&cat=1,41504,43688 http://www.dlws.com/Striking-Tools/beech_joiner_mallet.htm I only just recently picked up some Ray Iles Mortise chisels from Tools for Working Wood. I haven't used them enough to comment yet. They are beefy chisels! I got them because I've been using some really hard Beech in a project. I was using my LN chisels, and I was needing to really pound of them, in this Beech. I was certain it was only matter time, before I broke the handles or even the blades on these chisels. Mike Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted May 7, 2012 Author Report Posted May 7, 2012 Reading Anarchist Tool Chest right now so I just read the section hammers and mallets. When I was looking for a hammer to do suspension work I found these hammers: http://www.hammersource.com/Soft_Face_Hammers/1_1/2_lb._Split_head_hammer_1_1/4_rawhide_face_11_wood_handle/ I was told the rawhide was for woodworking. Do these make good chisel hammers or construction and de-construction? Quote
mlingenfelter Posted May 7, 2012 Report Posted May 7, 2012 Reading Anarchist Tool Chest right now so I just read the section hammers and mallets. When I was looking for a hammer to do suspension work I found these hammers: http://www.hammersou...11_wood_handle/ I was told the rawhide was for woodworking. Do these make good chisel hammers or construction and de-construction? I like that hammer. It looks like the heads can be easily replaced. It also has a cool name ! Mike Quote
wilburpan Posted May 7, 2012 Report Posted May 7, 2012 1. should I try a paring chisel in Western to avoid the hammer thing (would I be able to make a fair comparison) or should I instead try a Western bench (or better for what I want to do next mortise) chisel with a hammer designed for it? BTW, why are a lot of them round? I'd just stick with your Japanese chisel for now and use it to get familiar with it before picking up a different chisel to compare it to. If you want to get a paring chisel, which I don't think you absolutely have to have right now, also get a Japanese one. It will help keep your sharpening practice consistent. 2. do the waterstones I have (1000, 6000 grit) work when it would come to sharpen a western chisel? Yes. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.