adambaum Posted August 6, 2012 Report Posted August 6, 2012 I'm thinking of getting one of those oscillating cutting tools that everyone is coming out with now that Fein's patent has expired. I have an immediate need for the flush cut capability, but not for anything other feature. Can't say that I won't "grow" into any of the other features...just don't have an immediate need for them. While Fein is the Festool of the category, I can't seem justify the price. How about other brands? Anyone use the Bosch, Dremel, or Rigid versions? Adam Quote
Vic Posted August 6, 2012 Report Posted August 6, 2012 I know a contractor/fine woodworker who adores his Bosch. I have a very old Fein. I can't justify a tool change, but would love to upgrade to tool less blade changes. (null) Quote
wdwerker Posted August 7, 2012 Report Posted August 7, 2012 I love my Fein. I ran it non-stop for 3 days once, it got hot as hell and went thru 4 blades but we got the job done! I have seen other guys on job sites stall out their tools and the Fein just keeps going. Imperial makes good blades at a much better price. The sander works in strange spots where nothing else will reach. The carbide grit blade cuts tile and grout like butter. I had a Ryobi it was garbage. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted August 7, 2012 Report Posted August 7, 2012 I love my Fein, as well. Be aware that they are very specialized tools. You may not ever need it, but in some cases, one of these tools can be priceless. In my opinion, nothing strips caulk, undercuts doors, removes bad grout, or cuts buried brads and disassembles woodwork, or sands corners better, with less mess to clean up. Quote
adambaum Posted August 7, 2012 Author Report Posted August 7, 2012 So I hear one vote for Bosch...I'm also considering the $17 cheapie at HF since I only need it for one instance. I usually like to buy on the upper end of the scale, but being a hobbyist, I only do a few projects a year. Sometime hard to justify more than $20 for a tool that I only need for an hour. Then again, once I use it I may find other uses....Decisions, decisions, decisions. Adam Quote
Dave's Not Here Posted August 7, 2012 Report Posted August 7, 2012 Don't sell the HF version short. I've had one for a couple of years now and it's done the job each time its been called on. Not an everyday use tool for sure but the half a dozen or so times I've used it I can't imagine another brand performing any better than the HF. I have found that the Bosch blades last longer than their HF counterparts do. Quote
Carl Olsen Posted August 7, 2012 Report Posted August 7, 2012 I got a cordless Bosch sunday, It does cut really good so far, the vibration is a bit intense at speed 6 (max), peoples say that the Fein doesnt vibrate that much in your hand. It come with 2 batteries (30 min to recharge) and a battery should last 15minutes or so. You are probably good to run it non-stop if needed. It also come with an universal adaptor, some models only accept blades and stuff from their own model, so it might become more costly in the long run. For canadian users: Costco Canada is doing a cleareance on the Bosch Multi-X PS50-2A, 79.97$ (instead of 135$ like amazon). in the Montreal area Anjou had them but no others Costco. Item number 314188 if you want to call. Quote
adambaum Posted August 7, 2012 Author Report Posted August 7, 2012 The cheapest Bosch on Amazon I can find is $137. Pretty hard to not try the HF given the price difference. I know there are probably more accessories in the Bosch kit, but I think I am going to start with the HF just because of immediate one-time need and price. I don't feel bad not maximizing my $20. If I find the tool really useful, then something better can be purchased later. But I would hate to spend over $100 and find I don't use the tool that much. Adam Quote
Indy Cindy Posted August 7, 2012 Report Posted August 7, 2012 I'm laying some flooring and thought of getting one of these tools to undercut door frames. Then I tried a tool I already had on hand, a Japanese flush cut handsaw. The blade is flexible so that I can bend it down flush and easily cut the door frames without scraping my knuckles. Cheap, works well, and has many other uses. Quote
PaulMarcel Posted August 8, 2012 Report Posted August 8, 2012 Like Cindy, I use a Japanese flush cut saw (Shark). You'll find it useful elsewhere. Not to say the HF version isn't going to be well worth the $20, but an option. Quote
wdwerker Posted August 8, 2012 Report Posted August 8, 2012 If you go at it lightly and carefully the HF $20 saw will probably be ok. If you push that kind of tool hard it will die pretty quickly. For a one time use it makes sense to start out on the cheap. Good luck! Quote
Danny Hellyar Posted August 8, 2012 Report Posted August 8, 2012 Seriously I've used the HF one for a few years now and it works much better than I thought it would. I've probably used it on 20 or more jobs now and it hasn't failed me yet. I purchase blades for it on Amazon as I found the HF , Chicago brand ones didn't hold up well at all. I've actually had really good experiences with other HF tools as well . I stick with the Chicago brand tools as they are better quality. And besides for the price you can buy 15 of these things for the price of a Fein. Quote
Rick LoDico Posted August 8, 2012 Report Posted August 8, 2012 I just bought the Ridgid. I needed that pointy sander thing for my current project and so far I like it for 129.00. For a one time job I'd definitely go with the HF. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 8, 2012 Report Posted August 8, 2012 The Harbor Freight multi-tool got on to one of the " lists (the lists of HF tools that are actually pretty good). I looked around and found some reviews: here, here, Quote
adambaum Posted August 8, 2012 Author Report Posted August 8, 2012 Bought the HF. Did its one job admirably, but with some heat buildup. Think I'll try it on another task. The $17 special came with a single blade and nothing else. Not sure I want some of the other attachments as I have similar small tools that can perform just as well. Thought about using the Japanese saw. Maybe a comparison on my part is needed. One thing I like about the HF is that it is small in comparison to my HF tools. As for using a small flushcut saw, they are too flexible. I needed something fairly stiff to stay on the line. Adam Quote
Indy Cindy Posted August 10, 2012 Report Posted August 10, 2012 Bought the HF. Did its one job admirably, but with some heat buildup. Think I'll try it on another task. The $17 special came with a single blade and nothing else. Not sure I want some of the other attachments as I have similar small tools that can perform just as well. Thought about using the Japanese saw. Maybe a comparison on my part is needed. One thing I like about the HF is that it is small in comparison to my HF tools. As for using a small flushcut saw, they are too flexible. I needed something fairly stiff to stay on the line. Adam Good to know the HF tool worked for you. After doing my flooring project with my Japanese handsaw to undercut the door frames, and chisels to clean it out and get into the corners, I can see the advantage of one of the oscillating tools. Especially if I had very many to do. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.