Strongly considering drinking the Festool kool-aid. where to start


Recommended Posts

Posted

Brief overview - My wife and I bought our home a little over a year ago. The previous owners were hoarders. Not "we have a ton of stuff" hoarders, I'm talking like the TV show. 8 dumpsters later the basement and 3rd floor is finally empty. Now it's time for the garage (FINALLY). Our 24'x24' 2 car garage is my workshop. We don't park cars in it. Only about 2/3's is usable now because the corners are packed with junk. Once empty, I am going to removate it. Updated electrical, cover the rafters with drywall or beadboard, and install some sort flooring over the concrete. I am a neat freak and want to get serious about dust collection. I just about every tool I want so I don't need anything festool, but I want the superior dust collection. For me, there are two tools that suck at dust collection no matter how hard I try - sanders and routers. I think this will be my jumping off point for Festool. My questions are - which ones?

Sanders - I have a few 5" RO. A Milwaukee, PC, and a Bosch. All acceptable, the Milwaukee is the best of the bunch. Where do I begin with festool? I mostly do furniture work (aside from turning)

Routers - This is a tough decision because I have several. In the table, I love my PC7518, I have a craftsman professional model 27680 (don't knock it til you try it, best hand held router I have ever used and nothing like any other craftsman model) fixed/plunge hand held router and a dewalt trim router. I do a lot of routing both in a table and free hand. I know festool is expensive and I am ok with that, but I don't think I want to buy more than one festool router. Is the of2200 overkill for hand held use? I'm not sure I am going to replace the 7518 in the table.

Posted

Festool RO sanders: You're looking at either the ETS or the Rotex. Which one and which size greatly depends on your needs. The Rotex not only can do random orbit, but it can switch to a rotary mode to hog out an insane amount of material (sort of like a belt sander). So a two-in-one deal, but not so fast...the Rotex requires two hands, has a bit of a learning curve and one can easily lose control of it if not holding it right. The ETS sanders are lighter, works in one hand, but only a random orbit sander. One other note: the Rotex 90 is kind of a three-in-one, as it has the ability to sand in corners, but the trade off there is that it has the smallest sanding area of all.

Regardless of the ETS or Rotex, you have to decide on a size. Going to do a lot of decks and very large surfaces frequently? Get a 6". If not, you'd be fine with a 5" and they're a little easier to hold / control. I personally chose the RO125 (5") as I don't do a whole lot of big surfaces, and even on the odd occasion I did, it wouldn't be a big deal to spend a little more time with the 5".

As for the routers, many adore the OF1010 but it's biggest weakness is that it can't take half-inch bits, so if you already have a bunch of those, it's a deal killer. Nothing wrong with the 2200, but I went with the OF1400 as I felt it was the midrange option, lighter and better in the hand and could use all the router bits I already had. Go to a Festool dealer, hold all of them in the hand and see what feels right to you.

And yes, I wouldn't bother using the Festool routers in a router table and keep your existing router in there, unless we're talking about that CMS table (a whole other expensive can of worms).

Don't forget to include a dust collector in all the above costs, of course. Festool has a bit of a discount when many of their tools are purchased with a CT dust collector.

Posted

I've drooled over them at my local woodcraft, they are nice. No matter tool I buy, the CT36 will be purchased along with it. My dust deputy will be a good accompaniment to it. The Rotex looks like a good option. I do enjoy making end grain cutting boards and don't have a drum sander, so rotary mode sounds awesome. 5" is really the largest i want to go. I need to use 1/2" bits and require a decent amount of power. I use free hand routers quite a bit for dado's and with a router plane (again, end grain cutting boards and large table tops that won't fit in the planer). Is the 1400 powerful enough to handle that? Also do you find the metric measurements annoying? I used to do a lot of automotive work so I am fairly comfortable with metric measurements, but haven't done a lot of it in woodworking. I haven't seen the pricing on the CMS yet, but it looks pretty nice.

Either way, santa is bringing me a KS120 so the CT36 will come in handy for that too

Posted

OF1400 is plenty powerful for dados and most routing needs, I've never found myself lacking or wanting for more.

Don't find metric annoying at all, I prefer it to the imperial system and I use it when I can. Either way, the measurement rulers on these tools shouldn't always be the final word when it comes to fitting and measuring something in a project, so it doesn't impact things much.

Posted

I started with the 5" ETS 125EQ and the CT26. From there is was a slippery slope. I now have the TS55 tracksaw and a 6" ETS 150/5. I love all of them. Great products. I did have to exchange my 5" because there was something wrong with it. But other than that they all have been great. But the tools are just one part. They really hit you with the accessories. I plan on getting a router at some point, and that will be the OF1400. I dont need the huge one because I dont plan on using it in a table and I will be getting a Woodpecker lift plate and table at some point.

You mention that you are getting the CT36, is there a reason why you are getting that one? The only difference between the 26 and 36 is the volume of the bags. Once i knew that, I got the 26. I just dont have the need for the larger bag. Just a heads up in case you want to save a few bucks.

Posted

I have the Rotex and when you put it in the aggressive mode it's a monster at removing wood. It's a good motion purpose machine. I also have the 1400. I had the big one but it's massive and way to big for my kind of work. It's a great router with plenty of power. I did all the mortises for my roubo build with it. Check out festoolownersgroup.com. You will find a ton of info including some good guidance on the sanders and sandpaper options.

Posted

I don't know, I can't imagine drinking the Kool-Aid for the DC alone. I guess I'm just not as uptight about it as others. If you have a garage shop, what's the big deal? Woodshops get dirty and dusty, no way around it. It's part of the fun for me in a sick, twisted way. Wear a respirator when you're sanding. Open the doors. Blow out the dust at the end of the day with a handheld blower.

Don't get me wrong, I LOVE all of my Festools, and the DC IS great, better than all of my other tools. But if I already had a comprehensive tool collection, I'm not sure I'd be replacing anything except for reasons of performance or functionality. If a tool shoots craps, then I'd look at Festool. If I had a shop inside my house, then I'd look at Festool. If I were a contractor working in customers' homes, then Festool. Or I guess if I was a paranoid dustlusional, I'd look at Festool. :)

I have the 1400 router, ETS 150/3 sander, Kapex, and jigsaw. Planning to add a Rotex, TS55, Domino and Midi Vac. They're fantastic tools. And that's why I bought them. The DC for me was just a bonus.

Posted

You mention that you are getting the CT36, is there a reason why you are getting that one? The only difference between the 26 and 36 is the volume of the bags.

To add something to this, someone in the letters section of a recent issue Fine Woodworking had a good idea for recycling CT bags (or nearly any vacuum bag), claiming to still be on their first bag after many years. Take two sized plastic tubes (1/2" and 3/4"), cut half of the bigger tube to make a C-clamp. Cut off the end of the vacuum bag, then the tubes can be used to strongly clamp and hold the open end shut. If you've seen those plastic tubes in stores that slip inside one another to close off potato chip bags, it's the exact same idea.

If purchasing the bigger CT is simply to avoid having to replace bags more often, the above may be of interest.

Posted

Well this sucks. Looks like I am going to have to set aside a little more discretionary income for a while. Yesterday I picked up the RO125 and the CT26. Thanks for the tip about the bag size. My dealer told me the same thing. Also I am using a cyclone so that helps. I have never been more impressed with a power tool, and this thing is just a sander - probably a tool no one gets excited about. I was so impressed with the overall quality of the tool that I made it back to the store within 5 minutes of closing and grabbed the OF1400. I haven't used it yet, but can't wait to fire it up later on. I have a feeling a large collection of systainers is in my future.

Eric, It's not going to be a "garage" anymore. I'm in the process of gutting it completely and turning it into a really nice space. I'm one of those people that believes the quality of your environment has a lot to do with how you work, and the output of your work. With a nice. pristine looking shop (brand new walls, cabinets, benches and floor), I'll be more apt to keep it looking brand new. My least favorite activity now is cleaning up the dust and shavings everywhere. Right now the DC is still in the box. I started hanging pipe last night - thus no festool router fun). My wife also enjoys woodworking, so we have no intention of ever putting cars or lawn equipment in there ever again.

Posted

I understand that sentiment completely. I keep a very clean and organized shop. But it does get dusty and chips go flying on occasion no matter how hard I try to contain them. So at the end of every day, and sometimes a couple times a day, I open up the garage door and back door and windows, and blow the whole thing out with my backpack blower...and I'm back to clean.

I hear what you're saying about a clean shop being more conducive to quality and enjoyable work, and completely agree.

Enjoy your new toys!

Posted

I was so impressed with the overall quality of the tool that I made it back to the store within 5 minutes of closing and grabbed the OF1400. I haven't used it yet, but can't wait to fire it up later on. I have a feeling a large collection of systainers is in my future.

Yep, that's how it works. I originally got an OF1400+CT26, was back at the store the next week for a TS55. Few months later bought the RO125, and just recently got the Domino. Thank god for disposable freelance income. Fortunately the slippery slope is nearly at an end for me, I 'might' consider the Kapex depending on how the Xmas bonus goes this year, but the Kapex is a trickier sell on me. Same goes for their jigsaws, I might get one if I decide to switch to a barrel grip, otherwise my current Bosch is pretty good. And I have no use for the handdrills, they work very independent of the Festool ecosystem anyway, and DeWalt is hard to beat.

Anyway, enjoy your new toys.

Posted

A portion of my xmas bonus has been reserved for the Kapex since March when I saw one in action in a demo. I have a SUPER crappy craftsman CMS that I need to replace badly, but am holding out. I haven't even used it in over a year. I do all my cross cutting on the table saw with the multitude of sleds I have. It will be a welcomed addition though. It's a pain to retool the saw (cross cut blade, remove fence, remove guards, get the sled down, etc) every time I want to make a cross cut. I also have no use for the drills and drivers, unless one falls in my lap. I also have no use for a track saw (unless someone convinces me otherwise) because other than jigs, templates, and shop fixtures, I rarely use sheet goods of any kind.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

I have the RO150 (won it from Wood Magazine a few months ago, Awesome!) but prior to that I purchased the ETS150/3, OF1010 router and a CT Midi dust extractor. So far I am happy with everything.

The 1010 is just awesome. I really hated using my Freud router freehand so I only used it in a table but the 1010 is very user friendly and light as all heck so it's fun to use. The ETS 150 has changed my opinion on sanding completely, if you get one, get the hard pad for it, it's just great... I have mixed feelings on the RO150, it is LOUD and buzzy but can remove planer marks and burns like nobody's business... I switch to the ETS when I get to finer sanding but like the RO for initial sanding. The CT Midi is quiet and decently powerful. Since the majority of my use is sanding, the bags last a long time for me. I can see if I get the plunge saw or Kapex that I'd be going through bags quicker but the size and weight of the Midi make it nice and it handles what I am using it for quite well.

I think a DTS-400 is my next Festool (delta pad sander)... Sanding isn't a glamorous job but anything that makes it easier and less time consuming I am all for...

So my advice is look for holes in your existing tool collection that you need to fill and see if there is something you actually need. In my case it was a router that I was more comfortable with using by hand and my PC sander died so I needed a new one. Dust extraction just made sense and the CT was far quieter then any other vac I owned...

-Jim

Posted

I recently attended a local woodworking tool show and saw a demo of the Domino. I am very new to the hobby so don't have a lot of practical experience, but that being said, to me, the Domino would be one of the first green tools I would get. I don't have anything else that does what it does or see competitive alternatives This provides a new capability - which where I am at currently - is what I am looking for in a new tool. If I were doing anything woodworking related as a business or for hire, I would buy this tool immediately...as a hobbyist, I have to get a little thirstier before I take my first swig of the kool-aid...

Basshunter

Posted

I will end up getting a domino, but I have mixed feelings about it. It feels like cheating. I use traditional mortice and tenon a lot. Loose tenons would be good for things I need to slap together quickly, but I am not a production kind of guy. I don't even sell anything I make, but it would be useful for the quick and dirty stuff that makes the wife happy - radiator covers for example. I have 15 of those on my project list.

Posted

I will end up getting a domino, but I have mixed feelings about it. It feels like cheating. I use traditional mortice and tenon a lot. Loose tenons would be good for things I need to slap together quickly, but I am not a production kind of guy. I don't even sell anything I make, but it would be useful for the quick and dirty stuff that makes the wife happy - radiator covers for example. I have 15 of those on my project list.

I feel that way whenever I turn on the table saw or reach past the brace for the drill press :)

j/k

Posted

I feel that way whenever I turn on the table saw or reach past the brace for the drill press :)

j/k

BURN!! I wasn't expecting that in the Normite City over here, but you are technically correct!

Posted

Where to start? IMHO start with a TS55 and rails, maybe a Domino for loose-tenon joinery, a vac and that's about all. If you want to do 32mm cabinetry, get a 1010 and the LR32 kit.

Where to go from there depends on whether you're working in a shop or on site. The Festool system is heavily biased toward the portable carpenter: self-contained storage, easy setup, well integrated with different components. And it comes at a hefty price. If you work primarily in a shop these things aren't so important. There are other tools that compare in quality and dust collection ability and sometimes exceed the Festool in ease of use and come nowhere near in cost.

Take routers for an example: I have an OF 1400, with the little added shroud below the base it sucks up dust pretty well when flush trimming or edge forming. But it has a big damned hole in the base so when I go around a corner it tends to tip and not cut. It has a handle on one side that's well above the center of gravity, the other handle is low down so keeping an even pressure on the base is problematic, especially when plunging. So I spend another $125 for the "Table Widener" only to find it has an even larger hole in the base... And at that price they can't even afford to throw in a knob to give you something to hang onto.

In the meantime my Bosch 1617 and it's $22.00 dust collection accessory do an equally efficient job of dust collection and handle much better. Actually it does better at DC on edge work than the Festool because vac pickup is below the base. For plunge routing, the Dewalt 621 does just as good at DC and handles lots better, no accesories required. And these are routers that sell for less than half the price of the OF1400.

Sanders? Do you really need 4 or 5? I spent more on my Ceros than any individual Festool sander but I only bought one. Dust collection is excellent with the Abranet discs, great with pre-punched paper discs. Handles much better than any Festool sander I've ever grabbed, weighs lots less. Maybe it doesn't do everything the full line of Festool sanders will do but if I absolutely have to have something that specific I'll go buy the Festool, until then I'm good with the Ceros and a little handwork.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not anti-Festool(I own enough of their tools) but there is this concept of cost-effectiveness that comes into consideration along with the problem of where to store all the Systainers. If I was working out of my truck as a trim carpenter as I was 20 years ago I'd be all over the whole system but I'm too old for that and have a small hobby shop so the portability thing isn't an issue. No arguement, their tools are well made and their customer service is great but that cost/benefit ratio is still present. That's a personal call.

My take on the Festools I own: TS55 and rails definitely keepers, wouldn't trade them for the world. Parallel guides, meh, I have a table saw. MFT-3, buy the basic table and some Qwas dogs: fence, angle guide thingie and the rail thingies are inconsistent and problematic. MIdi and CT26: good vacs, suck better than my Fein but a bit noisier, would buy again. OF1010/LR32 combo, definitely a keeper. OF 1400, I'll give you a good price. Kapex: Every time I use it I try to remember what I was smoking when I shelled out $1300 for a chop saw...

Next purchase: Domino.

Build quality on their tools is excellent, ease of use varies. Accessories are 'way overpriced IMHO. Take advantage of their 30-day return policy, if you don't like a tool don't be afraid to return it even if half the folks on the internet swear up and down it's the greatest thing since sliced bread. And mind your $.

Just my $.02 worth,

Bill

Posted

Greetings everyone. I recently purchased an old fire station and looking at purchasing the rotex 90 sander with a dust collector. I'm building a wood shop in a portion of the bay area, but I'm wanting the sander now because I need to strip the years of paint from the stairs and some of the other wood trim and woodwork in the building.

A couple of questions, first off, I'm going to be purchasing both at the same time, what other accessories should I pick up then also? I'll definitely need some paper, but anything else that you guys would recommend? Does the sander come with a systainer case?

Would you recommend a dusk mask, or what type, when I sand the stairs? This building was built in the early 1900's. I'm sure the paint at some point was lead base.

Also, I need some ideas on how to make the doors for the poles? I don't want the floors open all the time, just when I'm getting ready to slide down one of the poles. Thanks for any and all suggestions.

Brad in Belleville, IL

Posted

Greetings everyone. I recently purchased an old fire station and looking at purchasing the rotex 90 sander with a dust collector. I'm building a wood shop in a portion of the bay area, but I'm wanting the sander now because I need to strip the years of paint from the stairs and some of the other wood trim and woodwork in the building.

A couple of questions, first off, I'm going to be purchasing both at the same time, what other accessories should I pick up then also? I'll definitely need some paper, but anything else that you guys would recommend? Does the sander come with a systainer case?

Would you recommend a dusk mask, or what type, when I sand the stairs? This building was built in the early 1900's. I'm sure the paint at some point was lead base.

Yes, all the Rotex units (and most Festool tools) come with a systainer. Accessories...well, not counting extra sandpaper of course, depending on what you're sanding I might suggest a hard pad. Otherwise the Rotex comes with edging guards already - the 90 has that delta corner pad included - and I haven't wanted for much with either my 90 or 125. A small assortment of sandpaper is included as well.

Lead paint? Yeah, that's serious business and I'm pretty sure you'll need more than a mask not only to protect yourself, but to follow everything by the rulebook for removal and disposal, so to speak. Someone else here will undoubtedly know more.

Posted

I'd consider using a chemical stripper (like citristrip) for the majority of the paint. Lead paint removal is no joke. We had it done as a contingency on a house we just bought (built in the 1800's). You don't want that dust getting everywhere. The rooms were sealed off and they had some weird air system (negative air pressure in the work area I think). In addition they had special EPA certified vac's. A standard shop vac even with a HEPA cert was not up to the task apparently.

Plus paint clogs up sandpaper in a hurry and that could take quite a bit of time to remove it all. Congrats on the purchase! That seems like it will be an awesome space.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 68 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined