Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey guys! I'm just starting out in the hand tool realm and not getting very far... I've watched countless videos online, read books, etc. but just can't seem to get consistent results with my tools (hand planes in particular)... I don't have hundreds of dollars for classes at the moment, but if anyone happens to live in Southern CT and could spend an hour or two at least helping me with the basics I would be forever greatful (in the form of a case of beer and/or dinner :-) )! I don't want to give up on woodworking, but I need to get over the initial frustration of not really knowing what I'm doing to really enjoy it...

Posted

Classes aren't always hundreds of dollars. If there is a local Woodcraft or Rockler. Many times they have one day or evening classes that are right around $100 and less. I think I paid $75 for my last one. I am on the wrong coast and wouldn't be any help either way. Going from rough lumber to squared dementioned lumber is a skill that eludes me aswell. I just bought a jointer and planer. i use my hand planes cleanup and small stuff for now. Good luck and hang in there...

Also check check the woodwright shop tv show. It's available on unctv.org. Several back seasons too... Roy Underhill is the king...

Posted

Dan, I noticed on one of your other posts you mentioned a 9" stanley from one of the big box stores. It might be worth mentioning what other hand tools you have that you're getting frustrated with. I'm not trying to sound like a hand tool snob or that great tools have to be expensive, it's clearly not the case. But maybe the folks here can steer you away from the really expensive tools: the ones that you pay money for and will never work right.

Having started this hobby just a few short years ago with a few projects under my belt I'd be happy to share any insights that I might have. Classes can be hit or miss. I've taken great classes, and I've taken classes in which I did a lot of teaching (I was asked a lot of hand tool questions in a power tool class) my advice take a short class with a master -priceless-.

Bob's podcasts are a great resource, I really need to rewatch a few of them. :P

Posted

Bob's podcasts are a great resource, I really need to rewatch a few of them. :P

Few of them? That podcast is one of five I don't have autodelete on.... Now I just need to get my iPod to play them, and I'll listen to them while I sit in my Speech class...

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

I'm not close to CT, but let's see iff we can at least start to diagnose the problems you are having.

Can you describe what is happening? What are you trying to do and what is happening when you are trying? What kind of wood are you using? Are your tools sharp enough to easily pare see through end grain shavings from a pine board and leave a polished surface behind?

Many times, frustration with hand tools can be attributed to just a few basic things:

  1. Your tools aren't sharp - I don't mean out of the box sharp, because out of the box is never really sharp. I mean scare the hair off of your extremities sharp.

  2. The wood isn't the best choice for hand work - Today, a lot of folks seem to gravitate toward woods like sugar maple and tropical exotics. These woods, however, are usually really hard, and most exotics contain a lot of silica making them murder to edge tools. I always recommend that folks avoid these woods when first getting started and instead stick to woods that play well with hand tools. These include species like eastern white pine, tulip poplar, black walnut (to some extent; figured stuff can be a nightmare), and South American mahogany (one of my personal favorites). I wouldn't go any harder than cherry to start with and avoid boards with heavy figure until you are more comfortable reading grain direction and getting all of your tools extremely sharp.

  3. Your tools aren't sharp - Yep, time to sharpen again.

  4. Taking too big of a bite - Especially with hand planes, it can be tough to dial in the ideal depth of cut when you are first starting out, especially if you are working with rough sawn boards. Planes won't cut for the whole length of a board if the board is rough sawn or out of flat in any way. They'll ride over the low spots and cut only the high spots. This can make you think the plane isn't set for a deep enough cut, so you turn the depth knob and then the thing starts getting grabby and tearing out chunks. I have enough experience now to set my planes by eye and feel, but when I was new to them, one thing that helped me was to set the desired depth of cut by making test cuts on a small scrap board that had already been planed flat. This allowed me to focus on getting the depth of cut just right and not worry about the high and low spots in my rough sawn board throwing my perception off. Once I had the depth set using the scrap, then I moved to the rough sawn board and knew that the skipping was a result of only the rough textured surface of the board and not an improper depth of cut.

  5. The tools aren't sharp - Sharpen before you think you need to.
  6. Going against the grain - Reading the grain direction can be a challenging skill to learn. A lot of boards don't cooperate in this regard either, because often times, the grain will run in opposite directions in different areas of the board. This skill can only be learned by experience, but it is a vital skill for hand work, so don't give up on it. Sooner or later it will click, but even then, you'll still read it wrong from time to time. It's no big deal when you know how to approach it, but when you are first starting it can be frustrating. The best advice I can give you on this topic is just to practice. It gets easier the more you do it.

  7. Did I mention that your tools need to be sharp?

Start with those and let us know specifically what you are working on and what is happening and we can try to provide more specific guidance.

I spent some time yesterday with a fellow neanderthal (thanks Jay!!) and found all of the above to be true! He showed me how to properly sharpen and tune the planes I've been using (and that I need some better sharpening stones!) as well as how to read the wood I'm working on. I found out that there's a significant amount of grain reversal in certain areas of the mahogany that I had to work in the opposite direction than I was used to, which helped a TON. We also experimented with using card scrapers to smooth the tearout sections which worked REALLY well. I'll post pictures of the final result if you'd like (even though it's not a piece of furniture yet, I'm quite proud of it!). Thanks for all the help everyone! After working with Jay for about 4 hours yesterday I'm really motivated to keep going on this project!

Posted

The other thing is that no one can do this well right out of the gate. It takes practice and time to learn how to properly flatten a board or square it or cut straight or pretty much anything.

I'm to the point that I can do a few things decently like cut a straight line and plane a flat, square board but I still have problems often enough that I still consider myself a beginner after a couple of years at using hand tools. I just don't get enough practice to get really good at it.

I think that's the main thing, it's not rocket science, it's experimentation/training to find the right way to do what you want to do then repetition to get it right continuously.

Keep with it, it'll start to click....

-Jim

Posted

No problem Dan. I'm only sorry I wasn't able to show you more. Yikes that stuff was hard. The edge had two layers of grain, each going the other direction, so you had to baby the plane going one way and with emphasis on one part, then come back from the other direction and baby it with emphasis on the areas where the grain ran the other way. Tetchy enough to frustrate the best of us. With some work from Dan's smoother he was able to get below the railroad tracks on the face left from the lunch box planer, and the wood was absolutely beautiful. I'm sure the finished piece will really bring out the gorgeous figure in the mahogany.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.