Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust Collection System Under the Slab

Featured Replies

Hello All,

I am in the process of designing a new shop and wanted to get ideas on putting my dust collection system under the slab during construction as not have to worry about all the over head piping that goes with a retro-fit garage or older shop. I am curious why Mark didn't incorporate the collection system in the slab or below the slab with his new build? I plan on having frequent clean outs and will likely use PVC with wiring for grounding. Also, I wonder if I should put the dust collection in a separate closet in the shop or just outside the shop? I thought that I would make the connections for the different tools to be 4" in diameter and the central line in 6 or 8" pipe back to the vacuum unit. I plan to have a central air compressor as well with air outlets throughout the shop. I appreciate everyone's comments in advance.

Winston

Shops are dynamic and anything buried in concrete is not. Over time, your habits and skills change and so will your tool placement. I'll not even a fan of electrical in the floor as floor outlets gather dust and any spilled fluids. I think mark also was looking to the future resale value of the shop by making it possible to be a garage easily. Overhead is as convenient as in the floor and allows earlier changes.

BRuce

While I have mine in a crawl space, I wouldn't have considered a direct bury in concrete for the reasons mentioned above. Plus, if you ever got a really solid clog, you'd have a difficult time clearing it. I can always go down and disconnect things and move them around, if I really need to. That's why I also have a 1/4" luan finish floor that is only screwed down. If I ever need to move piping or outlets, I can just plug the subfloor and reinstall a new piece of finish floor, but I can't resell my shop as a garage. That'll narrow the field of any prospective future buyers.

The only time I would consider this is if your shop has a big combo machine in the middle of the shop -- something like a 2400lb Felder setup.

Something like that is never going to move so that line could be run in a service chase (accessible from the top through a panel level w/ the floor) along with electric and compressed air). But every other run to the perimeter tools would be overhead.

There's also the little issue with concrete settling and moving over time. If it cracks, and pressure causes the floor to slope one way, or lift at another end, you end up pinching the duct, and then you have to rip the floor up to fix the duct. This will then leave you with patches that settle differently, as they were done later, and your shop floor ends up suffering.

Also, if you discover that you put down ducting that is either too big or too small, you can't make any changes to it to fix your collections. Sure, you could tweak the blast gates, but that would be about it.

If he was to use PVC he would not need to worry about it pinching nor would a clog really be that big a deal. The PVC will flex with the slab movement. Also you would not actually I case the PVC duct in the concrete you would put it in the ground like you would a sewage line. Also the benifits of it being in the ground is that it's grounded. As for the before mention clog, that's what snakes are for.

Now if I was to do this my lines would be near the walls and down the center. This would allow you the best layout options and flexability in the future. And while you are at running your ducting you might as well run the electrical conduit also and place outlets at the gates.

Of course an engineer should be involved in all this so that you know it's planned right and you have his million dollar stamp of approval.

Charles, what is the difference between running it underground around the perimeter and over head? I understand the advantage "down the center" but not around the edge.

Heheh, I agree that that would make the most sense and probably would not impair the resale value.

We also have to keep in mind that the shops we are talking about here are for the most part "hobby shops". Yes it is better to not have the duct running across the floor but it could when you needed it to. I just put my TS left of center, ran the duct on the floor and don't walk around that side. I also don't need more than 4' to the left of the blade. There are lots of places in hobby shops that will be compromises, due to space, noise, dust and $$.

BRuce

Well, I tend to either re-arrange my tool layout and/or my dust collection about every 6 months anyway. Our last house was slab above grade and had some electrical and plumbing in the concrete. I worried about that until the day we moved out.

I would put things on the side for tools I would have there. My planer is on the side. So is my chop saw and bandsaw. If I had a jointer it would probably be there and my router table is on the side. I have fab tables and table saw in middle.

I actually like the idea of the service chase that hhh said. That really is the best way as far as maintenance goes.

  • Author

I would like to thank everyone for their comments. As far as the tool layout, I thought if I placed a suction location about every 10-12 feet or so on the parameter that I could use flexible hose to connect in whatever configuration the tools move to or end up at. As far as the resale at a later date, the locations could be covered with brass covers or just filled with concrete with a plug in the PVC. I do plan to run electrical in the floor and walls and ceiling.

I am going to research the gates and see how hard it would be to automate them when a particular tool turns on. I just don't want to make it too complicated. I like the idea of the service chase with the vacuum and air compressor inside with easy access.

I really liked Mark's idea of a "Festool station" in the shop with its separate vacuum with those tools. That way I can keep my large tools hooked to the cyclone and not have to worry about having to reduce the connection from the Festool equipment to the 4" PVC.

I wonder how I can find an engineer that understands what I am trying to do and who can help me with drawings, etc.?

  • 3 weeks later...

I have a relative whose house has buried HVAC ducting. Over time, the cement cracked, and the ducts now suck dirt into the air. I'm not sure if this matters for shops, but it's something to keep in mind.

Winston, I missed your first post but WELCOME!!! As far as DC, it is as simple as this....your shop is a constantly evolving, living entity. I believe that there is absolutely no way to say "I want my shop laid out like this or that" and feel the same way 2 years later. If DC is under the slab, it doesn't matter, you're committed. One exception....I'm in a 21x25 shop but if your shop is really large...what's that?...25x40? 30x50? larger? yeah....you could say table saw is HERE and then build around it....chop saw is HERE and build the tables on either side of it and it's permanent...no problem....plenty of room in between all the tools....but if your space is smaller, I think you will always need options for DC arrangement because your layout WILL CHANGE. If you have a serious problem - the unclearable clog....what do you do? Sledge hammer? If you get the revelation that the TS works better over here....what do you do? If you put it all in the slab and you will still end up with DC lines in the air years from now. My opinions are like my feet...sometimes they STINK but I think I'm spot on.

DC unit inside or outside - factors are noise, space, and protection from the elements. If the space outside can be done right, my vote would be for outside - less noise and save the space.

My DC is out of 4" drain pipe - I use reducers and adapters to go from Schedule 20 to 40 and back for addition of wyes (Is that right? Ys?...IDK) but it's cheap and accessible. I do like the idea of a main trunk line that's larger and Y off of it with 4". Right now, mine is 4" from tool to DC unit. I'm planning to up-size my DC unit and then put in [at least] a larger trunk line.

  • 1 month later...

Thanks for all the great information provided. Great reading!

It appears that the only negative is if you have a slab. I am planning a 30X50 shop on my ranch and was planning to use a wood floor with a 12" crawlspace. I would be able to reroute in the future if needed. Would this be a better solution vs going overhead? Does the minimization of vertical drops help suction significantly?

Love to hear your opinions!

Welcome Richard! You could "reroute" if needed if you're Woody from Toy Story :P ...12" crawl space?....why not make the crawl space 30" or 36"?

If you're raising the floor twelve inches, the entire floor could become an open walled service run. As long as you leave access panels to this underfloor area, I don't see too much of a problem. Offices do this kind of thing all the time, running power cords and other shtuph under the floor.

Run DC in the slab if the concrete is like my son's jaws. HUH??? I asked his orthodontist how teeth are moved and still remain steady - "resorbsion".....???. When braces (&^$%...$4500...*&%$ I knew I had the wrong major) anyway...when braces pull on teeth, the jaw parts like the Red Sea and allows the tooth to move and then the jaw closes up behind the tooth. That's wild, but if you can get your slab to do this, I'm a fan of DC lines in the Jaw-Crete. 5 years from now, you will have DC lines that are seen - in the air and/or along the wall and some of the DC inlets in the slab will be capped off. River Room - Georgetown, SC Rib eyes and Seafood are on me if I'm wrong. BTW...good food...if you come to the area, by all means give me a shout, we'll have some fine dining at a working man's price. ;)

Let me pipe in as a cottage builder. In Australia a concrete slab for a house or a garage to go onto has to be designed by a structural engineer. As time went by I became very accustomed to slab construction and ended up advising the engineer on the designs which helped me out with costs and time. We have a couple of standard designs for different soil types. If there is a clay soil we go for a raft slab that is designed to float on the earth after it has been compacted. The other design which I used 99% of the time was pier and beam which relied on drilling a 12 inch diameter hole to rock every 6 feet along the slab stiffening beam and fill it with concrete prior to pouring the slab. This supported the floor much like an ocean oil rig platform. All the services were in the soil below the concrete. There was no movement. Any penetration of the floor slab for a service pipe had to be treated with a suitable barrier to prevent termite attack.

Now, regarding dust extraction pipes in the ground. It is easy to do and as long as it is designed correctly and you have enough cubic feet per minute for your style of machinery. If you have say a 20 inch thicknesser with standard blades I would not do it. But if the thicknesser had a spiral head of some sort, not an issue.

I agree with the comments made about the shop evolving so this is where I would stop supporting the notion of sub floor services. Vic's situation is organic and he has a solution for his shop redesign if it happens. I had the option of running duct under my shop floor when I built it but decided against it. I use an extractor on wheels at present and it will do me.

The things to consider re venting the spent air outside or filtering it for recirculation depends mostly on the climate you live in. If you heat or even cool the shop, you will probably want to keep that air inside, not create a wind tunnel. My dust extractor moves 1200 cubic feet per minute. I would move the equivalent volume of a 20 x 20 x 8 feet garage of air in 3 minutes.

I will also run a 2 inch system behind my permanent areas such as mitre saw and drill press. I have power points every 4 feet along the walls, running on 2 different circuits so that I do not overload 1 circuit and also so that there are not extension leads every where. There will be one power point in the floor under my table saw, but again, mine is a timber floor and I did this stuff when I built. My shop has evolved 3 times in the past 2 years. It just happens as you live in it. A better way makes itself apparent as you use the shop, very hard to foresee some things at planning stage.

Summing up, a few power points and maybe some cat 6 cable in the slab that does not sit proud of the floor surface is a great idea. If you live in a constantly pleasant climate, vent the dust extractor outside. The rest is personal choice.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.