Ryguy1418 Posted November 14, 2012 Report Posted November 14, 2012 I have access to a lot of rough cut hardwoods and it bugs me not being able to mill my own boards. So I'm buying a planer and a jointer. Now it won't be heavy everyday use so I don't need an industrial size. What are my best bets? I've done a ton of research but I'm still agonizing over these purchases. Help me out please! Price range: $0 - $1500(for both) Planer: I was looking at the dewalt 735 13" but people complain about the noise, and the crappy blades. Steel city has a helical head planer, but its 2 cutting edges not 4 and its not carbide I guess. Anyways I'm open to all suggestions. Jointer: I saw the grizzly w/ spiral cutting head that looked nice for 750 but again I'm up for any suggestions. I would prefer a spiral headed planer but they dont seem to come cheap. I can't make up my mind please help me out! Thanks ahead of time. Ryan Quote
Jfitz Posted November 14, 2012 Report Posted November 14, 2012 The 735 is loud but it does a nice job. With an aftermarket upgrade to a Shelix head, it still loud but it's a different type of sound and not as piercing - sort of a loud droning instead of a scream. Many people had problems with the knives early on, but that seems to have been resolved. The 2 speed feature is really nice - the low speed leaves a very smooth surface You can also get decent aftermarket knives from Freud or Infinity. What sIze lumber can you get? It might make sense to plan on an 8" jointer (instead of 6) so you can take advantage of wider boards. The price you quote looks like their 6" jointer with a spiral head. If you can afford it, get a spiral head in both - but IMO it makes more sense to at least have it on the planer since boards will typically be run through it last (jointer is only for flattening one face). Grizzly has a sale on their 8" Polar series jointer (3HP, mobile base) for $715. In your budget you could also get a 735 (new or used) and use it with the knives until you find you need a spiral, and in the meantime save your pennies for the Shelix head. If you're not sold on the 735 there are a lot of good other options out there for "lunchbox" planers, or you might pick up a stationary one on Craigslist. Quote
Ryguy1418 Posted November 14, 2012 Author Report Posted November 14, 2012 That looks like a solid way to go. Thanks for the input! No one really recommends Steel City...so I'm assuming their price reflects the corners they cut making their products? Quote
Rick LoDico Posted November 14, 2012 Report Posted November 14, 2012 If you have 1500.00 I'd spend it all and a little bit more. I'd go for an 8" jointer and a reconditioned DW735. 6" jointers are fine but you'll soon discover that you have many boards that are 6 1/2" wide and wider. I've never had a problem with a Recon tool. http://www.grizzly.c...gram-Beds/G0490 http://www.amazon.co...&keywords=dw735 Quote
Dave F Posted November 14, 2012 Report Posted November 14, 2012 I'm not going to try and talk you out of the DW735. It's a fine planer. Personally, I own the DW734. It's almost 15 years old, is a primary workhorse in my shop and I've never had a days problem with it. They're still available as well as replacement part and ascessories. Yeah, it's noisy, but so is my table saw, jointer, miter saw. Let's face it... power tools make noise. DF Quote
Rick LoDico Posted November 14, 2012 Report Posted November 14, 2012 Noise is always a problem around woodworking machinery. That's what hearing protection is for. Here's a video I made on DC and planer noise. Quote
pghmyn Posted November 14, 2012 Report Posted November 14, 2012 I'm not going to try and talk you out of the DW735. It's a fine planer. Personally, I own the DW734. It's almost 15 years old, is a primary workhorse in my shop and I've never had a days problem with it. They're still available as well as replacement part and ascessories. Yeah, it's noisy, but so is my table saw, jointer, miter saw. Let's face it... power tools make noise. DF I agree with the noise. If the only problem with the tool is the noise, it can be dealt with. The quality is really what matters. Quote
Jfitz Posted November 14, 2012 Report Posted November 14, 2012 Let's face it... power tools make noise. So do my kids. At least the tools have an 'off' switch 1 Quote
Ryguy1418 Posted November 14, 2012 Author Report Posted November 14, 2012 Ok so, I'm gonna go with the portable dewalt with the feed tables then whenever I choose to upgrade the cutting head I can.....that gives me about $1000 to play with for a jointer. 6" spiral or 8" bladed. Opinions and recommendations? Looking at the grizzlys now. But I'm open to any other ideas too. Thanks for all the info thus far! Quote
Ryguy1418 Posted November 14, 2012 Author Report Posted November 14, 2012 So do my kids. At least the tools have an 'off' switch Haha, so true! Quote
pghmyn Posted November 15, 2012 Report Posted November 15, 2012 I don't mean to hijack the thread, as I hope this question helps the future decision. Say the rough budget is as the original post says, $1,500. A jointer and planer are to be purchased. Out of the two, which is more essential to purchase a higher quality model? In other words, the step up planer models jump from $500 to well over $1,000 - pretty quickly. Whereas, there are bench-top jointers for a few hundred, and then 8" jointers for - again - well over $1,000. So, is someone better off sinking $500 into a planer, and $1,000 into a jointer - or the other way around? Quote
Ryguy1418 Posted November 15, 2012 Author Report Posted November 15, 2012 Good question....I would like to see some opinions on that....the $500 planers are 13" whereas the $500 and under jointers are all 6" which is pretty damn small so I would assume that people would pay some extra money to get a larger jointer to close the size gap between the two. I might wrong though. Quote
mking1 Posted November 15, 2012 Report Posted November 15, 2012 Here’s what I did: 12.5 inch wide dw planner and a 6 inch wide "crapsman" jointer then I made a "jointer sled" similar to the one shown in a past issue of Fine Woodworking. Now I can easily joint a 10-inch or more wide board which is at least 2 inches greater than an 8-inch jointer for a whole lot less money. I would not necessarily purchase a "crapsman" jointer next time but to its credit it has done all that it advertised. I really should not be so critical of that machine it saved me money when I knew nothing. But an 8-inch Delta jointer would be really nice. So what I’m really saying is spend the big bucks on a big jointer and the little bucks on the "lunch Box" planner, then build the jointer sled for those really nice wide boards. Miles. Quote
jsiard Posted November 15, 2012 Report Posted November 15, 2012 That looks like a solid way to go. Thanks for the input! No one really recommends Steel City...so I'm assuming their price reflects the corners they cut making their products? I've had a Steel City 35625 5hp TS for almost three years and love it. The only down side is there no riving knife so I use a shop made splitter. I spent alot of time looking at every Saw out there and the fit and finish is everybit as good as those at more than twice the price, and I only spent 1.5 hrs tuning the saw the first time and has stayed true since. I would not hesitate to purchase another SC tool if it fit my needs. That said, I would consider a combo machine such as the Laguna platinum series 10" jointer/planer w/shc for $1,995. +$275 shipping. Great machine at a great value. Quote
joelav Posted November 15, 2012 Report Posted November 15, 2012 Not sure where you live, but my local Home Depot has the DW734 on clearance for under 300$ brand new. The 735 is a much nicer machine, but the 734 is pretty capable, Quote
Ryguy1418 Posted November 17, 2012 Author Report Posted November 17, 2012 Hmmm last question dewalt 735 portable 13" or a G0453P 15" 3 HP 220V Planer, Polar Bear Series® from Grizzly? Prices aside what would you guys prefer? Quote
Jfitz Posted November 17, 2012 Report Posted November 17, 2012 The G0453 appears to be a very capable machine. You would get a heavier stationary quieter planer with a larger capacity. It has serrated metal power feed rollers (versus rubber rollers on the DW) which might leave marks that need to be cleaned up. It has a 4" dust collection port - you definitely want a Strong DC with this. The DW has an integral chip ejection fan that works very well, especially when also coupled with a DC. To your question - if space and price were no concern, the stationary Grizz would have to be considered a priority. Does this mean your budget has increased? Quote
Ryguy1418 Posted November 17, 2012 Author Report Posted November 17, 2012 I'm at best a hobbiest woodworker so I wanted to stay around that price point and not go to overboard but an extra hundred wont kill me either way....715+945= 1660. And it turns out that I live really close to their Pennsylvania warehouse so I won't need to ship them at all. ( have the means of moving them). Seems like it would be a nice little set of stationary grizzlies that if I ever wanted to upgrade the cutter heads down the road I could. That's my logic anyways! Thanks for all the help! Quote
Ryguy1418 Posted November 17, 2012 Author Report Posted November 17, 2012 Just found out that even if I order online and pickup they will then have to charge me sales tax.....that kinda sucks. Time to find out how much Pennsylvania sales tax is. Quote
sjeff70 Posted November 17, 2012 Report Posted November 17, 2012 I've been shopping for a tablesaw. I found Grizzly warranties their tools for only 1 year. Dewalt 3 years. Delta, Powermatic, and Jet offer 5 years warranties. A little more expensive yes, but I think it's worth waiting a few more months to save a little more cash. A few months when you consider lifetime enjoyment or resale value. Quote
stahlee Posted November 19, 2012 Report Posted November 19, 2012 I would honestly look at a combo machine. With the $1500 you are looking to spend, you are real close to a 12" combo. Grizzly sells their G0633 for $1995, but also send out 10% coupons in their flyers. We'd be talking $1800ish so maybe save up a couple more dollars. Just my $.02. I have the G0634z which is very nice. I also have a G0500 8" jointer and a Dewalt 734 and I usually go to the combo first. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.