Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Staining Question

Featured Replies

I figure the best way to get help is to ask, I am rather new to woodworking (about the last year or so) and I am starting to get into some more detailed projects. Desk's, TV Stands Etc... What is the best way to stain these types of projects or any project at all. I appreciate the help in advance....

Dave Turner

What kind of wood are you using? Some woods are better with water dyes and others oil stains. On white oak I use both. Applying both is pretty much wipe on and wipe off.

Bubba's right. It depends entirely on the wood being used. For example, Black Walnut. It really doesn't need anything other than 6 or 8 coats of a excellent quality oil finish. Cherry, again just oil or shellac, then give it a year or two to age into that lucious deep amber patina. Poplar.... stain it, dye it, paint it... it needs something.

As far as stain application goes, I've always just stuck with the liberal application, let it sit for 10 minutes or so, then wipe/buff off the excess method. Always had great results.

In the early stages of woodworking, I usually recommend people avoid staining all together. You already have your hands full getting construction techniques down and then applying a clear protective finish. Adding in staining/coloring is a whole additional world of materials, techniques, and potential problems. Of course sometimes the wood we have access to, like David indicated with Poplar, just isn't all that pretty on it's own. So I totally understand why one would be tempted to stain. But if at all possible, do yourself the favor of pushing off your staining education for a while. Makes the whole finishing thing a lot less daunting.

  • Author

That's just the problem, I'm using Pine for this particular project and I just don't care for the look on its own. I am just looking for a way to dress it up a bit, nothing overbearing but noticeable.... :rolleyes:

Dave Turner

Dang, pine can be the trickiest of all to stain. It's so porous and open grained that if you just use a basic stain your results can be really blotchy. If you going to attempt to stain pine use a gel stain, you'll get a more consistant result.

  • Author

If you do use something besides gel stain, would you just have to use more coates to make it even???? :unsure:

If you do use something besides gel stain, would you just have to use more coates to make it even???? :unsure:

No... that's not the problem. The point is that pine absorbs more stain in some places than others... adding more coats won't really help (unless you just super super soak the wood, which isn't what you want either...)

There are ways to deal with it other than gel stain, but I don't really know them well (maybe others can chime in) - I just prefer to avoid staining pine all together.

That's just the problem, I'm using Pine for this particular project and I just don't care for the look on its own. I am just looking for a way to dress it up a bit, nothing overbearing but noticeable.... :rolleyes:

Dave Turner

Pine? For me, milk paint (the stuff you mix yourself from powder, not the canned stuff; that's just latex paint) or natural finish. Forget staining pine (at least until you are more experienced with it). Pine creates several challenges when staining that make it tough to do even for the best professionals. I agree with Marc. For now, clear coat it and learn to love the look of pine (it grows on you, trust me), or paint it. Avoid staining or dying until you are more experienced with those products because they are very hard to use on pine.

Staining pine is definitely not something I would recommend as an early finishing project. As I mentioned above, pine creates several challenges when it comes to staining and dying. First, it tends to blotch...badly. This is very difficult to avoid because it is caused by areas of differing density within the wood. Less dense areas absorb more stain, more dense areas absorb less. This causes very obvious light and dark blotchy areas. More coats of stain don't help, they just make it darker. The problem is, there isn't really any easy way to tell where the more dense areas and less dense areas are within a growth ring. Pre-stain conditioners and wash coats of shellac prior to staining help with blotching somewhat, but in pine they do not prevent it completely. They also make the stain much lighter that what you think it will be because they prevent the uptake of the color by the wood (which is what they are designed to do). As for gel stains, they really don't prevent blotching if you don't use a sealer (they just make the color lighter), and they also don't prevent the second big problem.

The second problem with staining pine, and this is one that is not frequently mentioned, is that the light and dark areas tend to reverse when you stain it. Take a look at a pine board. You will notice distinct light and dark bands. These are the early and late wood of a growing season. The early wood is the light, softer band. The late wood is the darker, denser band. In pine, there can be a vast difference in the density & hardness of the early and late wood. This is what causes big chunks to pull out of the end grain when you chop dovetails in it with a less than newly sharpened chisel. When staining, this difference in density between the early and late wood causes reversing of the colored bands. It's more obvious using darker stains, but basically, the soft early wood absorbs the stain or dye like a sponge, getting very dark, while the dense late wood resists the stain. This causes the early wood to become darker than the late wood, reversing the look of the grain pattern. Sometimes this isn't that noticable or not that important. Other times it is glaringly obvious and ruins the entire look of the board. Again, it's worse the darker the stain you use.

Professional finishers typically topcoat pine with a toned laquer or varnish topcoat if they wish to impart more depth or a different color to the wood. This prevents the dark & light rings from reversing and also prevents blotching. However, professionals have lots of toners to choose from to mix up the perfect color and they also typically spray to get even tone over the whole piece. The best way for a beginning home finisher to achieve a similar (not exact) appearance is to use a toned varnish, like Minwax Polyshades (or similar product). This is basically a polyurethane that is colored with toners. If the wood is sealed first with a couple of coats of sanding sealer or (my preference) Seal Coat (very thin shellac), the Polyshades will remain on the top of the wood, imparting a color to the piece without soaking in and getting blotchy or reversing the light and dark rings. The down side to this? It's polyurethane. Again, you can do the same thing yourself by toning shellac or laquer, but this takes some experimenting and a decent outlay of cash to invest in the toners. Plus, laquer is typically sprayed, adding to the expense and learning curve.

While I really don't like polyurethane for furniture, I think the Polyshades is probably the best bet for pine for a new finisher. I think there are several manufacturers that make similar products now. Minwax makes the Polyshades. I think Cabot also makes a colored polyurethane. Both products are carried by Home Depot and Lowes and you can get the tiny little cans to experiment with before commiting to a particular color, or combination of colors.

So after that long winded explanation, if you really don't want to go with a simple clear coat or milk paint, I'd recommend 2 coats of Seal Coat sealer, sanding with 320 after each coat. Then top with 2-3 coats of the Polyshades, or similar product.

I agree with Bob. If you have to stain it, go with the Polyshades. All I would add is that you really need to spend the money for a GOOD brush. Cheap brushes don't do well in polyshades. They leave bubble trails and fisheye really bad. Don't put it on too thick. Instead, use light coats until it gets as dark as you want it. If you make it too dark, you start losing the grain. Oh....it is important that you stir the Polyshades thoroughly and then strain it when you pour it into a separate container to work out of. Otherwise you pick up chunks of pigment that you never can seem to get stirred in completely.

What about a washcoat of shellac over the pine, then stain? I'm hoping that works for a tabletop I'm making. I'll test it out on the underside first. I plan to mix 50/50 shellac (Zinsser in the can clear stuff) with alcohol. I'll lay down one coat of that -- then apply stain (probably minwax provential or fruitwood), let dry for a few days.. then a coat of water poly. Thoughts?

The shellac wash coat will partially block the uptake of the stain, making the blotching less severe but it won't eliminate it completely. It will also make the color much lighter because it is acting to prevent absorption of the color. It also won't prevent the light/dark band reversal I described above. Again it will just make it less glaring by partially preventing absorption.

Dave Turner....just go for it!....Jump in with both feet and finish the thing. How else are you going to learn. Your human and will make some mistakes. Take time and read about finishing, specifically pine. A ton of info is out on the internet. Your going to mess things up. So you strip the finish off and do it again.

Finishing a test board is one thing. Taking a finish from a test board to a finished project is another. My best advice is to practice all your moves (pretend) using brush or rags. Work out what parts you start and what parts you finish on. Its like a boxer working the body over, thus alowing the arms to come down so you can get that head shot!

I like water-based for pine. Use a equal parts of a water-based topocat and water as a wash-coat. Apply a good water-based dye to tone the pine(I like to spray dyes) When dry, apply a good water-based stain. When dry, seal that with a good water-based topcoat. And glaze over that with your water-based stain.

Water-based finishes is our future and in my opinion, come out best when sprayed...So my best advice...to get a spray gun and learn...you'll be glad you did. Take a look in my photo gallery. You will see a shaker style clock made from box store pine.

Just takes practice....not to tough...at all...we have your back!!!!

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Author

I ended up skipping the staining and putting a clear coat on the project.and it turned out really well..... i did try to stain a spare piece of pine with a sealant that i put on before stain and it helped but still didnt give me the results i like so i left it with a clear coat and i like it that way... Thank you everyone for all your help....

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.