Recommended Posts

Posted

I am committed to purchasing SawStop in the near future.  The saw I have chosen is the professional cabinet saw.  I would like to get the 3HP, but here is the deal:   My shop space is pretty tight and the truth is the 30" fence would really fit the space better and give me room to work.  I am a hobbyist but, but tend to push things!

 

I actually don't mind the 30" fence as opposed to the 36", but am I going to regret not getting the T-Glade fence and going 3HP???

 

**The 30" model only comes in 1.75HP and the premium fence.**

 

Hard decisions!


Please do not turn this into a Sawstop hater thread.   ;)


Thanks for your comments.

Posted

I bought the 36 in sawstop with the 3hp motor and love it.  I don't know how the other motor does but mine has never bogged down. I purchased the whole set up back in 09 when I was still living at my parents and shop space was limited, so I made sure i got the jack stand for it as well. I was able to alter my router table and slide in underneath the extension when not in use. 

 

I just tried to buy the biggest and bestest when I was a bachelor and had money. Sure glad I did it then. 

Posted

Get the T-Glide and don't look back.  While my saw isn't a sawstop, I have the Delta T2 on it, which is a smaller T-Square fence.  They are definitely the way to go!

Posted

I have used a 1 1/2hp 120v UniSaw for 25 years in my cabinet shop. I use the thin kerf rip blades and sometimes 8/4 hard maple can bog it down a bit but otherwise I have been happy with the smaller horsepower . I have a 5 hp 240v UniSaw as well and nothing bogs it down, but that can get dangerous when a kerf closes up on a blade. So there are 2 sides to every coin. The Sawstop saws I have played with seemed like nice equipment. I would have to have serious space issues before I went with a smaller rip capacity and a lesser fence. Just my opinion.....

Posted

I am dealing with this same issue while trying to choose a table saw in my current 12x20 garage. Is it possible to upgrade to longer rails in the future when you obtain a larger workspace, or is that way more expensive that buying a larger capacity saw from the get-go?

Posted

I have a 1.75hp sawstop and it has never had an issue. I cut 8/4 material regularly (mostly cherry and walnut) and I've never had a problem. As far as the fence goes, I have the upgraded T glide fence and would HIGHLY recommend it. It's butter smooth and more accurate than I am.

Posted

Can you go to a showroom where you can try out both fences?  Even if the saws are not plugged in, you can get an idea of how smooth and reliable the fences are.  I've got the upgrade fence and like it, but I never tried the regular fence.  Given Sawstop quality, I can't imagine that it's crap.  To make a decision, you really need to check out both.

 

+1 on the peninsula idea.  I bought the 52" rails and then realized that they didn't really fit in my oddly shaped basement.  Putting the rails against a wall worked well for me.

 

Definitely get the mobile base.

Posted

Thanks all for the great feedback.

 

Yes I have a peninsula set up now.  In fact I designed the whole shop around being able to open the door and have long stock feed out the door.  My fear is that I will have a very small space at the end of the table to get around.

 

I've tried the Premium fence at the store and did not like it.  Thus my concern.

 

And yes!  I was planning on the mobile base.

Posted

Incra - if you ever tried it, you won't go back

 

Agreed, I have one (actually an earlier version than one sold today) on my SawStop.  I've not had an issue with the 29" rip width that bothered Marc, but then I do not work with sheet goods. 

Posted

Incra - if you ever tried it, you won't go back

 

Yeah, me too. Great fence, can rip 32" although I almost never need to, I prefer breaking down ply with the panel saw.

 

Wouldn't work for your application since you need room to the right of the saw for the carrier to extend.

 

I did play with the Sawstop standard fence at Highland when I bought my CNS but didn't install it since I have the Incra. Seemed to handle pretty well for a stock fence.

 

Personally, if I was going to shell out for a cab saw I'd go for the 3 hp. motor and live with or replace the fence.But that's just me. :mellow:

 

HTH,

Bill

  • Like 1
Posted

The main issues with Incra table saw fences include the inability to use many fence riding quick-build jigs, to quickly work on both sides of the blade, and the big arm that sticks out.   The claim of 1/1000" repeatability is nice, but in my experience, not necessary in a table saw rip fence.

 

Biesemeyer style fences are not shaped the way they are by accident.  There's lots of versatility in the design, requiring no special hardware or milling, that continues to make them popular.

 

When space is not an issue, I really like having as wide a fence capacity as possible, even if I rarely rip 52" pieces.  The fence makes a fantastic crosscut (with a standoff) and dado stop for sleds, and the extra room is handy to temporarily place the fence, stock, or sled, without having to lift things on and off of the saw.

  • Like 1
Posted

If the extra cost isn't a deal breaker for you, I'd just get the better fence and the bigger motor.  I'd hate to see you go this far for a nice saw and end up with somewhat questionable fence.  It's kind of interesting that they call their midgrade fence the "Premium" fence when it's clearly lesser fence than their T-Glide....I guess it is premium compared to the entry level contractor saw fence though!     

 

Even though my 1.75 and 2hp saws could cut anything I needed them to cut, they definitely worked a lot harder in some things than my 3hp saw....extra motor power is rarely a bad thing.  If it's  a matter of one or the other, I'd take the better fence and use thin kerf blades.  

  • Like 1
Posted

Marc tried an Incra and went back. 

Being from the south, I'll just say "Bless your hearts"... :P

I break down any sheet goods with a circular saw in the driveway allowing a little extra - then I get the dead on cut at the TS.  With the Incra, you have the bar in the middle with the hairline cursor lock that is sturdy enough for most rips but if you're cutting a piece of ply, you'll need to lock the fence down at either end of the fence, with the locks that are integrated into the rails.  Then it's as rock solid as any T Square fence.  It's just an extra step.  For most of what I do, the main lock at the hairline cursor is good enough. As far as our man 'Marcksabrahams'.....he's still amazing.... ;)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.