swalsh627 Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 Hi, I know this topic has come up before, but I still have some questions. I have only been serious about woodworking for about a year so I am still aquiring tools. Next on the list is a jointer and/or planer. I am having trouble desiding what to get. I saw the grizzly and rikon 10 inch jointer/planer combo machines and heard good things, but know that having a combo machine will mean there are some comprimises to make compared to two quality separate machines. I am also considering a grizzly 8" jointer and Dewalt 13" planer which would come out to be around the same price as the combo units. I like the idea of a 10 inch jointer, but also want decent quality. I am just a hobbist so I do not need the quality some of you may, but also want my projects to be well built and look nice (I do mostly furniture). Which would people recommend? How do people with the combo machines feel about the quality? I know there are higher quility machines out there but want to limit my budget to the price range of the machines above. With that said are there other machines I should consider? I have a large barn that is used for my workshop/yard tool storage, so I have a decent workspace, but it is still not huge. I could fit the separate units, but it comes at the cost of having space to move my projects around. I also do not yet have the barn wired for 220V, but could wire it once I get the power company to run some wire from the pole (the barn is too far from the house and an electrician friend said this would be the best way to do it). Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks. Quote
Kevmc Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 I got an awesome deal on a Robland 12 in jointer planer awhile ago. I was mostly after it for the wide jointer but also thought it would simplify my shop and I would get rid of my lunchbox planer. The switching between the two is a real annoyance for me and really forces you to plan your workflow. I find myself still getting out the lunchbox for all but the largest planing operations. I also find that I use the lunchbox even after using the big guy with fresh blades for final thickness for the best finish since the blades on the lunchbox are easier to change and disposable. The other big downside for me is that my combo machine has relatively shorter beds as do most of the combo machines. Another thing to think about is which way the beds flip up. In my case I can't have the jointer against a wall because of the direction the beds flip up would make it really difficult to move around the machine. So I have to move the machine on its mobile base when I want to convert. My beds flip up independently but some of the combo machines have them flip up as one unit. That's a much better design in my opinion This may just be my machine but I have to always recheck/readjust the squareness of the Fence after switching from planer back to jointer. Lastly. When switching from jointer to planner in my case I have to lower the planer bed all the way back down to flip the dust collector chute. That takes a lot of cranking and if I need to joint then plane another board I have to carefully readjust the planer bed to get a uniform thickness. I think a few of the newer designes have addressed this issue somewhat. This is also another reason why I still use my stand alone planer a lot. For me I would stick with the separate units unless you for sure would use the extra 2 inch width on the jointer. If you are going down the combo machine there was a good review article in finewoodworking about a year ago tha looked at many of the machines on the market. Hope this helps Quote
dwacker Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 I would go separates. The dewalt planer is a good homeowner planer and will serve you well. I dont agree with the space complaints with jointers. The distance from the center of the cutter to the wall is the same on every jointer. It doesnt matter if its a 12" or a 6" You need the same amount of space on any jointer to joint a 6ft board. If your in a tight space and need to pack your tools away tightly to make space then I guess there is benefit of a shorter joiner. The total space that a big joiner takes up vs a smaller one is very little. You will get alot of it works for me so it must be fine opinions. If you can I would go lay your hands on some of these tools. Some woodcraft stores have a good selection and a running shop with a variety. CL offer you the chance to go see some used ones even if you intend to buy new. I went to the grizzly store this past week end and can say my opinion of grizzly has changed, not for the better. We drove three hours each way to buy the son in law a 12" jointer based on internet reviews. We are going to hold off for a used 12" powermatic or oliver. We stopped by rockler to play with the jet 12" combo and will just leave at that, not something I would suggest. What quality level you expect is entirely up to to you, I would stay far away from internet reviews and get your hand on some machines. IMO a good PM or Delta 8" with dewalt jointer is a good homeowner setup. Delta because it will run off your existing 110v. Quote
jmaichel Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 I would go separates. The dewalt planer is a good homeowner planer and will serve you well. I dont agree with the space complaints with jointers. The distance from the center of the cutter to the wall is the same on every jointer. It doesnt matter if its a 12" or a 6" You need the same amount of space on any jointer to joint a 6ft board. If your in a tight space and need to pack your tools away tightly to make space then I guess there is benefit of a shorter joiner. The total space that a big joiner takes up vs a smaller one is very little. You will get alot of it works for me so it must be fine opinions. If you can I would go lay your hands on some of these tools. Some woodcraft stores have a good selection and a running shop with a variety. CL offer you the chance to go see some used ones even if you intend to buy new. I went to the grizzly store this past week end and can say my opinion of grizzly has changed, not for the better. We drove three hours each way to buy the son in law a 12" jointer based on internet reviews. We are going to hold off for a used 12" powermatic or oliver. We stopped by rockler to play with the jet 12" combo and will just leave at that, not something I would suggest. What quality level you expect is entirely up to to you, I would stay far away from internet reviews and get your hand on some machines. IMO a good PM or Delta 8" with dewalt jointer is a good homeowner setup. Delta because it will run off your existing 110v. What did you not like about the Grizzly Machines? Quote
dwacker Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 What did you not like about the Grizzly Machines? Just the overall quality. We stopped looking after the third one we check was unusable. Things from bad fences to motor mount welds to no where. The bases are tinish if thats even a word. Just browsing walking around with a 36" ceramic parallel we found a problems with pretty much every larger machine on the floor. But then again you get what you pay for. I think some folks are more tolerant than others thats why I think everyone needs to try their best to get their hands on different brands. Every one has a different opinion of quality and its best to get out from behind the computer and go play. Tools are no different than anything else. Some people think Ikea cabinets are great some wont settle for anything less than custom build real wood. Quote
G S Haydon Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 Swalsh 627 Ask http://www.woodtalkonline.com/user/3084-terrymck/ how he is getting on with his combo machine. Quote
jmaichel Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 Just the overall quality. We stopped looking after the third one we check was unusable. Things from bad fences to motor mount welds to no where. The bases are tinish if thats even a word. Just browsing walking around with a 36" ceramic parallel we found a problems with pretty much every larger machine on the floor. But then again you get what you pay for. I think some folks are more tolerant than others thats why I think everyone needs to try their best to get their hands on different brands. Every one has a different opinion of quality and its best to get out from behind the computer and go play. Tools are no different than anything else. Some people think Ikea cabinets are great some wont settle for anything less than custom build real wood. I guess you have some good points. I have been to there showroom and have a couple of their lower end tools. I don't mind them at this point in my hobby I think to do the job, my skill or lack their of will hinder my woodworking more than the tools at this point. I did get these tools knowing that they would not be my last more of a stepping stone at this point. I am probably 7 -10 years away from a dedicated shop and at least the same amount of time away from my last tools. I do appreciate your insight and feel you offer great advice. I might have to make my way down to Tacoma at some point and come check out your shop if you are open to it. Quote
G S Haydon Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 The best thing about grizzly for me is the angry bear logo. It makes me smile every time I see it . Quote
pghmyn Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 The best thing about grizzly for me is the angry bear logo. It makes me smile every time I see it . Best comment about Grizzly. 1 Quote
G S Haydon Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 Best comment about Grizzly. What's his problem? Gentle Ben was never angry like the Grizzly Bear is Quote
Pwalter5110 Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 Hey Swalsh. I actually had a jointer/planer combo machine. It was a smaller jet that was low quality, but for me, I may joint and plane table legs then I joint and plane table aprons, Then joint and plane the table top all separately. With the way I like to work, it was a lot of switching back and forth between the jointer and planer. Honestly it became a P.I.T.A. When I outgrew my small jet jointer/planer combo I ended up getting the 8" grizzly jointer and dewalt planer and couldn't be happier! Quote
Freddie Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 The quality issue with grizzly is why I went to the showroom with my 50" veritas straightedge (which I had verified for straightness by my local machine shop) and feelers and went into the warehouse and personally inspected my table saw before purchasing. I can't tell you the headache I went through dealing with crap showing up to my house. I think someone from MO parts facility needs to be called into the main office because the parts they were "inspecting" before shipping were certainly not inspected by someone who knew how to do their job. So for me to inspect it myself negated the headache on the day it was delivered to my house. All I had to do was set it up. So if you are in the market for grizzly, are skeptical of what you will receive, go down to the warehouse and inspect before buying, you can't lose. Quote
swalsh627 Posted April 5, 2013 Author Report Posted April 5, 2013 Thanks everyone for the advice. I was leaning towards two separate machines and your advice gave me convidence in that decision. I'm not near any of the grizzly showrooms, so I'll have to ask around to see if anyone has one I can look at before I take the plunge. Quote
Eric. Posted April 5, 2013 Report Posted April 5, 2013 Don't let Don get you too down on Grizzly...he's a pro and has a big shop full of huge Powermatics, so his expectations may be higher than the average weekend wood duffer. As a serious hobbyist with a number of Grizzly's, my personal experience is they're perfectly adequate. Top quality? Nope. But they've always made right any issues I've had with their machines, and with careful set-up and appropriate maintenance, my Grizzly's have been fantastic...especially for the money. They're a great value for hobbyists. That said, I would suggest staying away from the lowest-end machines they offer. Quote
rodger. Posted April 6, 2013 Report Posted April 6, 2013 I have a 6 inch jointer, and a 13 inch planer. I find myself flattening a lot of stock by hand lately (one side), and then running it through the planer. Eventually when my ridgid planer dies, I will buy a larger unit. The extra mass and width of a 15 inch (or larger) planer would suit me well. Quote
Kevmc Posted April 6, 2013 Report Posted April 6, 2013 And don't forget to check out Craig's list. While 8 in jointers are harder to find on craigslist if you have some time to wait you can get a good deal on a used jointer. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.