Grain Guy Posted April 10, 2013 Report Posted April 10, 2013 So im planning out a new smoother, bevel up style. This will be my first bu and I have some questions. I know that the camber has to be more severe, but will this cause the mouth to be nice and tight in the middle and leave the sides wide open? Also, I thought about having my iron angled at 25 to reduce the camber. Is there any other advantages or issues with this angle? And, is there a reason most bu's are set at 12? Any other thoughts you guys have are welcome as well. Quote
G S Haydon Posted April 10, 2013 Report Posted April 10, 2013 I'm intrigued grain guy, how and what will you be making the bu from? Quote
wilburpan Posted April 10, 2013 Report Posted April 10, 2013 Usually a plane iron has a bevel angle in the 25-30º range. If you make your bevel up smoother with a 25º bevel, that means your effective cutting angle will be 50-55º, in which case you might as well make a bevel down plane. For certain planing operations, such as planing end grain, a lower cutting angle is advantageous. That's probably why 12º is commonly found in bevel up planes. If you have a 25º bevel on the plane iron, that gives you an effective cutting angle of 37º, compared to the normal 45º that you would see in a Stanley-type plane. As far as the camber goes, since you're making a smoother, the camber is going to be pretty minimal with either a bevel up or bevel down plane, so I wouldn't sweat it too much. I set up my smoothers so that they are pretty flat across most of the edge, with the camber occurring just in the area of the corner. Quote
ChrisG Posted April 11, 2013 Report Posted April 11, 2013 Most BU planes are bedded at 12 degrees because it is about as low as you can bed a plane and stilll give enough clearance to the back of the blade for the plane to work properly. Basically, the lowest possible angle gives you the most flexibitly since you can always raise the angle by putting a steeper angle on the blade bevel but you can't very well lower it and still have a blade bevel that is high enough to hold an edge. I'm assuming you are building a wooden plane. If so, be aware that if you try to bed a wooden plane at that low of an angle, the mouth (really the area behind the mouth) will bow and breakout when you set the wedge. Think about how thin the wood gets under the bed as you near the mouth opening if oyu have an exceptionally acute angle. Wood is not strong/stiff enough to support the blade pressue when its thined out like that. Just like a lower blade angle is week as is a low angle piece of wood. BU planes (at least low angle ones) require the strength and stiffness of metal to be able to be structurally sound in the bed/mouth. They make/made "low angle" wooden planes, but they are bevel down. The lowest angle wooden planes I know of are bedded between 37 and 40 degress. To the best of my knowledge these are mainly western "strike-block" planes for shooting end grain, but also Japanese planes tend to be bedded lower than western planes. If you are building a smoother, build it at the angle of attack you want and leave it at that. In wooden planes if you want the variation in angles of attack that a BU plane offers you will be better off building multiple plane bodies. If you're building an infill or other metal bodied plane, then feel free to ignore everything I just said. Quote
Grain Guy Posted April 12, 2013 Author Report Posted April 12, 2013 I'm going infill with a Stanley #4. Found a great site inthewoodshop.com. This guy is awesome and more than generous with his talents. I plan to combine his ideas with my own and a few other infills I've seen. I am looking to have a smoother that I can have several blades for a few angles of attack. I may set the frog at 20 so I can also obtain a 45 cut with a 25 bevel and on up. Thanks for all the info and always eager for more. Quote
G S Haydon Posted April 13, 2013 Report Posted April 13, 2013 Grain Guy. Thanks for this. What a great idea! +1 on the quality of the site and the content. I think I have seen contributions from Derek in the forum before. Yet another one for the ideas file Quote
Grain Guy Posted April 13, 2013 Author Report Posted April 13, 2013 Absolutely. I recognized a few posts from him. Check out his shooting boards. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.