Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Help! I think my table is ruined!

Featured Replies

Hello,

I'm a newbie and have been quite pleased with my first woodworking project, which was to build a farm table and benches. See the pic below.

 

post-13809-0-50649100-1366328880_thumb.j

 

Well, everything has been going smoothly, I sanded the hell out of it, hit it with a coat of stain, lightly sanded and stained it again. I've been waiting for a few consecutive nice days now to seal it with a polyurethane sealer I got from home depot. Ahead of this final stage, I've been covering the table every night with a weather resistant tarp to avoid it getting wet before I hit it with the sealer - I live near the ocean and it's quite humid every night. Well sure enough, like a bozo, I forgot to cover the table last night and when I come to look at it this morning, it's all messed up! The boards used to be flush with little visible gap in between each, now there's as mush as a 1/4 inch gap between each board! And what's worse, the boards are twisting so that they are now no longer level with the breadboards at each end of the table. For some reason, several of the boards are suddenly bleeding tree sap all over the place... And the final insult is that now the table top is full of little black dots, presumably what were water droplets. Needless to say I'm very frustrated. What can I do?

 

Will the boards return to their normal shape? If not, I don't see any solution other than taking it all apart and gluing the boards to each other this time. For the ends, I don't know what else to do but maybe block plane them or sand them level with breadboards... Lastly for the ruined finish, I guess all I can do is sand it all over again and stain it. Again.

 

Any other suggestions would be much appreciated!

 

I guess my last question is - would all this have happened anyways even if I hit it with the sealer before it got wet?

 

Thanks all.

 

Mark

 

PS. The wood I used is regular old 2x4 and 2x6 douglas fir framing lumber from home depot.

Folks will need some data points to help.


==> The wood I used is regular old 2x4 and 2x6 douglas fir framing lumber from home depot.

==> For some reason, several of the boards are suddenly bleeding tree sap all over the place... 

==> now there's as mush as a 1/4 inch gap between each board!
 

First off, there is probably a moisture equilibrium issue with the lumber.  A- It was probably not properly dry enough for furniture use (about 8%) when you assembled the table and B- it moved with ambient moisture changes.

 

When you say ‘regular old’ – is that green framing lumber, kd framing lumber, what? 

 

 

==> the boards are twisting so that they are now no longer level with the breadboards at each end of the table

How much twist relative to the breadboard ends?

How ‘perfect’ does the top need to be? Honest question… There will always be some-level of twisting with outdoor furniture.  How you proceed depends on how ‘perfect’ it needs to be.  Wood is also a natural building material – it moves – that’s one of the things about breadboard ends…

How was the table assembled – glue, screws, glue & screws, etc.  How hard would it be to replace badly twisted members?
 

 

==> I've been covering the table every night with a weather resistant tarp to avoid it getting wet before I hit it with the sealer



It sounds like you worked this outside.  Is there any way to get this in a garage or out of the elements?  Tarps can trap moisture.

  • Author

Hi,

Thanks for the quick reply.

 

Lumber - I don't know if it's kd or green, or what the difference is. Can you please tell me for my next project?

 

Twisting - is significant. The long members used to butt up against the breadboards level. Now each long member has sort of "rabbit eared" at the corner of one end, same on the opposite corner of the other end - literally as if the board were warping into a slight corkscrew shape. How perfect it needs to be well - I'm willing to accept some deformation, I used crappy wood and the thing will stay outside - and it was built outside. I guess I just didn't expect the warping to be so pronounced. Can my block plane help me here?

 

Assembly - mostly all screws, a little use of glue. Should I have glued the long members to each other edge to edge? Removing members is not really an option, I've spent considerably more than I wanted to on this project already and there's so many screws on the bottom side of this thing that the thought of taking them all out is making me dizzy.

 

Storage - Unfortunately the table cannot be moved indoors. While your comment about the tarp trapping moisture sounds logical, all I can tell you is what I've experienced. Putting the tarp on seems to have protected the table. Leaving it off one night with heavy humidity seems to have seriously effed up the table... :(

 

note: I got pissed off and just took off all the stain off the table top with my orbit sander. It got the little black dots off but the wood certainly doesn't look "new" again. I'm worried what it's going to look like now when I stain it again. 

Buck, if this is the worst problem you are encountering with your first project, then count yourself lucky.  I once finished prepping a 5x12 Mahogany conference table for sealing and it was 9:00 pm. I decided to leave it and start fresh in the morning. A front moved in that night, and when I got to the shop in the morning, the table was cupped 1" . It made me sick, but I learned that when it's perfect, and it's ready to seal.....seal it. Backing up is hard to do, but sometimes it's necessary.

Buckwilde 

 

If you can put the table where it is going to be used and let things settle for a couple of weeks or until movement has stopped. You can then review just how bad things will get (I am assuming its an internal table). If you really can't do this I would question if it would be worth doing something like this again.

 

If you have been able to get it inside and let it stabilise you can then dismantle the top, shoot the edges and flatten. If you have lost width after shrinkage and planing the edges straight you may need to add another board.

 

If it's an inside job always use dry timber. Any type of construction lumber will not be dry enough. If you are able to clear a space in a dry area (your shop or room where the item will be) stack the timber with sticks between each layer and let them settle for four weeks you can reduce moisture movement issues.

 

If you don't think you can save it don't take it too hard. Mistakes do happen, it's all part of the journey. Perhaps you now have an outside picnic bench. Just bear in mind making something like this outside is never going to be a good choice.

This method is not for every project but is effective at limiting (not eliminating) cup in a single board if you are willing to disassemble.

You can take badly cupped wood and lay in the grass in the sun with the cup down. The grass underneath creates a moist environment and the sun speeds the drying on the upper side. This is more a technique for working with stock pre-milling but it can give results from near perfect to mildly cupped and workable when you started with badly cupped.

You have to be able to monitor the board because you can completely reverse the cup.

==> Should I have glued the long members to each other edge to edge?

 

than you would have twisted members that were either cracked or split.  The issue is moisture.  the wood is going to move until equilibrium is established -- a little glue isn't going to stop it.

 

==> put the table where it is going to be used and let things settle for a couple of weeks or until movement has stopped.

+1

 

anything you try to do now is wasted effort  (except maybe dissembling the top).  Sorry, but that's pretty much the way it is.  Until the wood achieves equilibrium, it's going to move some more.

 

==> build a farm table and benches

==> I've spent considerably more than I wanted to on this project already and there's so many screws on the bottom side of this thing that the thought of taking them all out is making me dizzy

 

is this destined for an outdoor setting -- like a patio dining table?  If so (and you can live with a bit of 'rustic'), then there is a bit of a desperation move, but I did it once on an inherited patio table that i didn't want to spend any time on and it worked-out for me -- actually surprisingly well.  Just let the wood move for a couple of weeks until equilibrium is established (hopefully the entire top doesn't twist, bow, etc) -- if it does, then it dis-assembly time.  If the movement is just twist against the bb ends (that was my situation) and a bit of up-down movement of adjacent members (had some of that as well), then take a sander (or plane) to the entire top to knock-down the high spots and get the top flat -- you just have to live with some dips dips -- but if it's a patio table, you should be able to live with that.  I used a Festool RAS (I would not do this with a normal random orbit sander -- it would take forever).  A RAS is like a grinder with sandpaper (actually, they make sanding heads for standard hand grinders) -- and took all the high-spots down and took 3/32" from the overall thickness to eliminate most of the low spots.  Did the entire job in under 15 minutes.  I sealed the thing with CPES then epifanes as a finish -- It actually turned-out well.  BoatworksToday has a video on the finish technique, but he uses WestSystems epoxy.

 

==> I don't know if it's kd or green,

 

kd is kiln dried.  it would have been stamped on the sides of the lumber.  green is really wet and has a darker (or green) appearance when placed next to the kd.  it's also heaver (all the water in the wood fibers).  HD tends to stack the two next to each other.  At my local Borg, DugFir Stud = $3.33 green, and $3.56 for kd.  If you used green or mixed greed and kd, then you are screwed.

If you still have the receipt or tags stapled to some of the lumber, you can read it for the wood type.  I'm also assuming you didn't use pressure treated, which I've never been able to do anything with (including burn).

 

One question: how did you attach the breadboards to the tables?

 

Before you take off any more stain/ finish, I'd let the table equalize further.  If you want to protect it outside while it does this, build a small tent for it, using the tarp and some temporary supports to let air flow around it while keeping the tarp off the surface of the table.  It might take the table a little longer to equalize this way, but you'll be letting the air flow around all of it, which will certainly help.

 

(And when you've finished this project, let us know what you've got planned next!  'Cause I see a lot of good stuff coming out of your shop!)

  • Author

Hey thanks everyone for your responses, this community is great. I ended up block planing the high ends of the table and got some 80 grit sanding discs which I will use to even off the remaining unequal edges. I should note for the record this table was built outside and it's meant to stay outside, it's our patio set. We've been getting some fantastic weather for the last week or so and it's supposed to be nice for about another week so every day I've been removing the tarp and letting the table get direct sunlight which seems to be drying it out. At night, the tarp goes on with some chairs over it which seems to be providing adequate protection, at least I haven't seen anymore dramatic movement in the wood. Once I sand the hell out of it (should be today), I'll re-stain and the SEAL IT! at the first opportunity. I'll post some pics when it's done. 

 

@ jHop - you are very kind, thank you! The next plans I have are to build:

 

1. a decent mobile workbench (my "shop" is outside so I have to move my tools from the garage to the backyard every time I want to work). I'm thinking about this one which looks awesome and easy to build: http://www.handymanclub.com/Portals/0/uploadedfiles/mobile_workbench.pdf

 

2. Dining room table. This time I've learned my lesson and will buy proper dry hardwood because this piece is going in the house. I have an idea to edge glue a bunch of strips together to make the table top and stain the strips a variety of shades, ranging from light to dark to produce this kind of effect:

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/66349357/strip%20wood.jpg

 

3. My wife wants a bench for the yard so I'll get working on that next but that will be several months away still I think.

 

Thanks again to everyone for their responses, there's such a massive amount of experience and expertise concentrated on this board, it's damn impressive.

 

buck

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.