Caught Posted May 6, 2013 Report Posted May 6, 2013 Does anybody know why the 3HP Sawstop is $430 more than the 1.75HP? The guy in the store says they are the exact same saw with only the HP being the difference. Quote
Dave's Not Here Posted May 6, 2013 Report Posted May 6, 2013 http://www.sawstop.com/products/compare/ Quote
Trip Posted May 6, 2013 Report Posted May 6, 2013 I assume you are comparing the 1.75/110v and 3HP cabinet saws? Not a sawstop guy myself, but I looked at them a year ago... The basic difference was what's 'standard' in the 3HP and 'optional' on the 1.75 -- I believe you get a longer fence, dust-removal in the blade guard, etc on the 3HP, but these are optional on the 1.75... I seem to remember that the actual fence system was different on the 3HP saw, but may be an option on the 1.75... I also seem to remember that the guts looked beefier on the 3HP -- but I was also looking at the 5HP, so could be mixing/matching... Quote
dwacker Posted May 6, 2013 Report Posted May 6, 2013 My guess is that they pay more for three hp motors than 1.75 and the electronics are beefed up a bit along with maybe even a larger mount for the heavier motor. Just looking at the specs they are the same as long as you get the same fence. More HP more money. Quote
jimmykx250 Posted May 6, 2013 Report Posted May 6, 2013 More HP= more money. Look at the motors over at grainger and that will tell you. The only other thing I can tell you is the dust collection guard is standard in the 3hp model. I am kicking myself for missing the recent promotion. I personally believe they are a top quality saw and until you play with one and compare it you simply wont be able to tell. Just spin the height adjustment knob. Wow! Quote
croessler Posted May 6, 2013 Report Posted May 6, 2013 My wife, who is a reseller, said the $430.00 difference is in the HP and a upgraded blade guard. 1 Quote
Caught Posted May 6, 2013 Author Report Posted May 6, 2013 Thanks to all. I called tech support and it boils down to some beefed up electronics, larger motor, and a dust collecting blade guard. Sure wish I could swing the extra $500. I bought the 1.75 today and will report on the progress. Quote
jimmykx250 Posted May 7, 2013 Report Posted May 7, 2013 Please update us with your honest thoughts and possibly a video or some pics. I am certain this will be my next saw as I havent heard one bad review yet. Quote
knotscott Posted May 7, 2013 Report Posted May 7, 2013 Aren't the stock fences different between the 3hp and 1.75hp too? From their website: PCS3hp: PC1.75 Quote
Trip Posted May 7, 2013 Report Posted May 7, 2013 that's my memory -- i think the better fence was an option at the time. From memory, the better fence was indeed much better and worth it... Quote
krtwood Posted May 7, 2013 Report Posted May 7, 2013 You can buy both the 1.75 hp and 3 hp with either fence. It's $2300 vs $2730 with the basic fence or $2470 vs $2900 with the better fence. So it's a $430 difference either way. The 3 hp comes with the dust collecting blade guard which you would have to buy for $140 on the 1.75 hp, bringing the difference down to $290 to get them equipped the same. An extra $300 on a $2500 saw is well worth it when you think about how long that saw is going to be in service. Of course if you have to hire an electrician to get 220 that changes the situation. Quote
jimmykx250 Posted May 7, 2013 Report Posted May 7, 2013 You can buy both the 1.75 hp and 3 hp with either fence. It's $2300 vs $2730 with the basic fence or $2470 vs $2900 with the better fence. So it's a $430 difference either way. The 3 hp comes with the dust collecting blade guard which you would have to buy for $140 on the 1.75 hp, bringing the difference down to $290 to get them equipped the same. An extra $300 on a $2500 saw is well worth it when you think about how long that saw is going to be in service. Of course if you have to hire an electrician to get 220 that changes the situation. Thats a big factor to think about especially when you would need to upgrade your main panel from 100 amp to 200 to accomidate the saw because all your circuits are full! Quote
knotscott Posted May 7, 2013 Report Posted May 7, 2013 The thought of spending $2300 and getting an "ok" to mediocre fence sends shivers up my spine. This is a case where I think spending $2470 is the better value.... 1 Quote
Trip Posted May 7, 2013 Report Posted May 7, 2013 ==> This is a case where I think spending $2470 is the better value.... +1 -- I seem to remember that the 'low end' fence looked pretty sketchy. Quote
jimmykx250 Posted May 7, 2013 Report Posted May 7, 2013 I would agree the stock fence looked like a joke. On this kind of a saw the beismeyer fence is the only way to go. I thought why do they even have that stock fence? Im sure its a marketing thing. Quote
Caught Posted May 17, 2013 Author Report Posted May 17, 2013 So it's been a week or so and I thought I'd say a bit about my new SawStop. * I went with the 1.75 model and the 36" fence. The basic saw has only a low end fence which, unfortunately, is pretty bad and the deflection, front to back is dramatic. The stock miter gauge is your typical "stock" miter gauge and I have replaced it with a V120 from Incra, (more on that in another post). * As everyone has said in numerous posts, the setup and instructions are amazing. They left out a few items but the tech support is awesome and very willing to help. * It's important to attach the wings starting with the center of the three bolts and then move to the outer ones after getting the center of the wing even and tight. Maybe if I had done set up on more than one saw previously, I would have known that but all's good now I just wish it had been mentioned. * The other thing not in the destructions is that leveling the wings is dependent on the angle iron used to for the fence so don't worry about that until you mount the fence and auxiliary table. * I had to adjust the table just a tad to align it with the blade and the fence needed adjusted but overall, everything was good. * Both of the blade inserts, the one that came with the saw and the dado insert, were warped right out of the box but after a call to tech support, they had two new ones overnighted and they were both dead on. Overall thoughts, it's a great saw and extremely well made, tech support is probably the best I've ever dealt with, assembly was easy, and it looks really nice. Only complaints were the "stock" fence and miter gauge as it seems that for $3K they could include a higher grade components and the warped inserts but dodo occurs and they took care of the issue promptly. Bill Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted May 17, 2013 Report Posted May 17, 2013 I would agree the stock fence looked like a joke. On this kind of a saw the beismeyer fence is the only way to go. I thought why do they even have that stock fence? Im sure its a marketing thing. I actually talked to a SS factory rep on this very issue. He told me that the cheapo stock fence was done with the specific goal of reaching a certain price point. Their market research assured them they needed to hit x dollars and no more. They didn't want to sacrifice the quality of the components of the saw which are difficult to up-grade. So, the took the cost out of the fence to reach the specified price point. That's what the factory rep told me. Seems logical to me, my company does the same thing. We offer product designed to serve specific markets. We offer product to serve specific customers. And we offer product designed to hit specific price points. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.