Recommended Posts

Posted

Hello all,

I stumbled upon a great deal on an old and well used Stanley #8 (pre lateral adjuster). The body is immaculate, but the blade and chip breaker are a little rough. I'd like to buy a veritas or hock replacement set. I'm just wondering if any of you have tried one of these on a pre-lateral plane? From what I've found on blood & gore, the plane is a type 1 or 2.

Thanks,

Ryan

Posted

Hey there Ryan I have the same style #8 and had to replace the blade. It still had the original which was used up. I went with the Hock blade because I had used them in other planes. One thing to keep in mind with this is that you may have to pay attention to the clearance in the mouth of the plane due to the Hock blade being a fair bit thicker than the originals; it has worked wonderfully since then. The blade actually cost me more than the plane which I got for a song ($27.00) at an estate sale.

Posted

Thanks Croessler!  I appreciate the quick response.  Is there a remedy if the mouth is too small?  I assume you could widen it with a file... but I'd hate to dig in and find out I'm wrong :wacko:

Posted

I have a Bedrock 604 from about the same time and my Hock fit right in. On my #6 I did have to open the mouth a bit with a file. I just took off a little, tried it, rinse and repeat. Your frog gives you adjustment but I still only wanted to remove the bare minimum. Rob Cosman has some from Pinnacle that were made on a short run, thicker than the Hock so there are tabs that work with the chip breaker. They are A2 only, I use oilstones so I prefer the 01, just thought you may be interested. I have always been happy with Hock and I have a Pinnacle in my scraper plane that I am very pleased with as well.

Posted

I was able to adjust the frog back just enough. However, you don't want to back it so much that it leaves the lower end of the blade unsupported. If that is the case that's when i would open up the mouth.

Chris

Posted

RW, 

 

Just to throw a different opinion out there, don't junk that blade. If you are using exotics or wild grained timbers then go for it, you will need all the help you can get.

If you are just using regular timbers I would question if it's worth investing just yet. 

I have an old family stanley #8, it's taking a rest on my tool chest  :)

Wooden-Tool-Chest.jpg?resize=418%2C519

 

I have found the standard blade and cap iron/chipbreaker just fine (so far). Learn how to sharpen on the old blade. Tidy up the cap iron/chipbreaker, it wont take long and enjoy the tool. 

I found a standard blade can cut very well. These cuts were taken in oak after I had tuned up my #4

 

Heavy end grain cut

4-Plane-end-grain.jpg?resize=441%2C588

 

Light long grain cut

 

4-Plane-long-grain.jpg?resize=441%2C588

 

I would never rule out upgrading, I would just do it when my hand is forced. If you want to see the guidance I looked at follow this link and go to the "Tune Up" section and scroll to the bottom of the page.

 

You will notice also that David Charlesworth within the articles on Rexmill does not promote opening the mouth, just adding a back bevel to the front of the mouth, even with the thicker blades he advocates. 

Posted

I had to go to Google for a conversion from mm to understand the thickness of that shaving.  I also have never needed anything "better" than the standard blades.  I use planes 3 through 8, with two 6s, as part of what I do for a living,  and have never bought a high end new plane, or upgraded the iron on anything except one block plane.  I'm not saying I wouldn't like to have one of the fancy irons, but I can get half a thousandth with the standard irons on Stanley and Record planes, and they hold an edge plenty long enough for me.  The real trick is to find old planes that don't have the backs of the irons pitted, and the sole of the plane needs to be perfectly flat regardless of what iron you have in it.  You need to be able to polish the back of the iron down near the cutting edge to get a truly sharp cutting edge, and it the back is pitted it leaves little knicks in the edge.

Posted

Thanks for all the replies!

I should have been a little more specific...

The quality of the blade is not an issue, The previous owner seems to have taken a hammer (or some other heavy blunt object) to the chip breaker and left it dented.  I've tried to straighten it out without success.  The blade is in reasonable shape with only a little pitting, but its very heavily cambered.  I just figured if I'm going through the hassle of mail ordering a new chip breaker I'd try a fancy new blade to go along with it B) .  I had set aside some money to buy a decent jointer plane, and even with a new blade in this one I'm still WAY under my original budget.  And I'm kinda curious to find out what all the buzz is about with the hock blades.

 

P.S. With a little help from GS's blog and a few of the threads here I've done a little work on a couple of old (barely useable) planes and had great luck refurbishing them.....Thanks GS!

Posted

RW,

 

That makes total sense. If you already investing in a replacement chipbreaker why not go all the way. I'm glad you found the articles useful. That said I was only following David Charlesworth's method. Like almost anything in the traditional/hand tool genre it's all been done before! 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.