Recommended Posts

Posted

I started working on a project involving haunched foxtail tenons (because it's as much about skill building as the final piece) and I ran into my usual problems fitting the M&T joints. The mortises were partially cut by machine, then finished by hand. The tenons are completely hand done, and since i'm still new to this, they didn't fit the first time. That's fine though, since I can always remove extra wood.

 

But where to remove the wood? Usually I end up guessing where the blockage is until I find the right spot by accident (and now the tenon is too loose). This time I looked around for something that would mark where the wood is coming in contact and realize that mineral spirits would work perfectly. I gave the tenon a good wipe down, pushed it in until it stuck, and removed it. Sure enough, there were 2 or 3 spots that were now wet. Chisel, scrape, repeat.

 

I thought I was a genius... for like 5 minutes. Then I realized this has to be a really common thing. Sure enough, it is. Hopefully this helps someone wondering how to make their joints tighter. 

 

Anyone else have any good "How did I not know this until now?" tips/techniques?

  • Like 1
Posted

Cut it right first time  :). Only joking TFB, I've never foxed wedged yet. It always seems a very skilled job to get them just so. Just out of interest when you say the tenons are hand done how do you cut them?

 

I guess the P Sellers blog gave me the first heads up on the alternative hand cut mortice that does not need working from the center, I later found it in an old book book too. 

Posted

I too would like to know your method for cutting them.  Do you use a marking gauge? knife? Pencil? other?

 

About 80% of the projects i've built over the last two years have had m&t joints.  I keep doing them because I want to get them down pat.  My first ones were, uh, terrible.  My most recent project, they went together much better. 

Posted

For the marking, I tend to rough-mark in colored pencil to make sure I'm not crazy, and then use a combination square & utility knife for the final marking. I've got one of those Veritas wheel-style markers, but I find it to be very fiddly for things like this. I find I get nice clear line, and have no control problems as long as I take it easy. I do like using the chisel to get a stronger knife wall, but I don't bother on end grain (at least on the honey locust I'm working on at the moment - it just doesn't mark well).

 

I've flipped between both split (Sellers-style) and cut tenons. Both have worked fine for me, but I've been very careful about only splitting where I was very sure the grain would behave on me.

 

Also, I don't think the foxtail tenons are that hard. In fact - I like them for through mortises. Besides looking very nice, they're great at covering up my not-quite-airtight joinery. I just use my smallest drill bit, draw vertical lines from the entry/exit points, join them at top, and saw down. The hardest parts are relieving the extra wood from the outside of the mortise (since that part tends to be pretty tight on space AND needs to be fairly straight and then making the wedges. I find splitting the wedges is MUCH faster than trying to cut them - if the wood grain is aligned right. I'm making wedges from jatoba now, and it would take forever to saw, compared to splitting and paring with a chisel.

 

Here's a quick illustration of the actual design/setup:

post-6112-0-65606500-1374290296_thumb.pn

Posted

TFB, When wedging a through mortice & tenon I also prefer to have the wedges driven in fox style. It creates a very pleasing look, I can't say if it's stronger but we use this joint on external doors an have never had a problem.

That said the daddy fox wedged closed mortice & tennon is not one I have tried (because I have not needed too and the fear factor) but you have prompted me not to be such a baby about it.

Sounds like you have a system that's working well for you TFB on M&T and that final adjustment is very precise reflecting your desire for snug joinery. I thought you might be shy of the lines and then paring, sounds like your way more advanced than that.

Posted

I don't think it's necessarily stonger, but I like the idea of an actual physical resistance to pulling apart, which is important for the bit I'm working on right now, and it gives me more surfaces to practice on in a single project.

 

 

And yes, I'm still leaving a little to pare away. I tend to cut to sides dead on and then leave the other two slightly proud. I've found with the japanese saws that as long as I pay attention, I can get a fairly straight cut but I don't quite trust my skills (layout or cutting) so I want a little room for error.

Posted

I've wondered about this closed fox tenon joint. I understand the mechanics of the joint, but how do you measure for the spread on the tenon?

I mean, if it spreads too soon, the shoulders are sloppy. And if it closes too late, it means there isn't as much tenon in the mortise as there could be and the strength is less than optimal.

Maybe I am over thinking this. Wouldn't be the first time! I suffer from paralysis from analysis.

Posted

I've wondered about this closed fox tenon joint. I understand the mechanics of the joint, but how do you measure for the spread on the tenon?

I mean, if it spreads too soon, the shoulders are sloppy. And if it closes too late, it means there isn't as much tenon in the mortise as there could be and the strength is less than optimal.

Maybe I am over thinking this. Wouldn't be the first time! I suffer from paralysis from analysis.

Exactly why I have not tried it Mel!

 

TFB, My gut tells me a fox wedge is stronger than wedges not driven into the tenon but my gut is not always hard evidence. I have a feeling your skills are better than you think, next time off  the saw  :ph34r:  :)

Posted

Start with a square bottomed mortise. Scribe the bottom corners. Plan for your relief of material. You can visually check when you are an eighth undercut or a quarter. Match your wedge to your relief plus your saw kerf plus a few thousandths to 1/64". Scribing the square corner should allow you to slip your wedge in the corner pocket by itself. Scribe the wedge intersection with the bottom of the mortise. You want two lines that are slightly farther apart than your saw kerf.

The wedge is usually something soft enough to compress. Over sizing the wedge by a few thousandths plans for that compression as you tap home.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 60 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined